Post your real Star Wars : Revenge of the Sith commentary here ( with spoilers )

[Agathon]

Among others in this thread, the Leia Mother Knowledge argument has to be one of the most pathetic ever to grace the internet.

It's a story.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Originally posted by JohnT
You're assuming that Vader wasn't enhanced.

Better. Faster. Stronger.

In ANH, Vader's lightsabering was creaky and nothing like Anakin in RotS. Though there was compensation in increased power in the Force, but that's 20 years of learning there.

[Agathon]

Y'know... suddenly nerds appear out of nowhere. It's like Invasion of the Body Snatchers.

[JohnT]

ANH?

Oh, you mean Star Wars.

Let's not forget that Guinness and Prowse actually had to fight with sticks. And that Prowse had to take it easy because he really was fighting an old man. And also that the sticks themselves were fragile and easily broken.

[JohnT]

Originally posted by Agathon
Among others in this thread, the Leia Mother Knowledge argument has to be one of the most pathetic ever to grace the internet.

It's a story.

Of course these are pathetic arguments. They're about Star Wars fer chrissakes!

[Agathon]

Of course these are pathetic arguments. They're about Star Wars fer chrissakes!

Yes, but I stopped having these arguments when I was 11.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Let's not forget that Guinness and Prowse actually had to fight with sticks. And that Prowse had to take it easy because he really was fighting an old man. And also that the sticks themselves were fragile and easily broken.

Backstory on the making of the movie isn't canon.

[JohnT]

So did I. But I've seem to have regressed a bit.

[Agathon]

My favourite one was the one about how the Imperial troops managed to get onto Hoth if it was supposed to be shielded.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Originally posted by Agathon
My favourite one was the one about how the Imperial troops managed to get onto Hoth if it was supposed to be shielded.

How did they....

[Geronimo]

I'm a little surprised revisionist Lucas didn't completely redo the lame lightsabre fight in ANH now that it is so totally outclassed by all of the later fight scenes. Could it be that for once he realised that erasing portions of the public's cherished childhood movies is evil? .....naw

[Imran Siddiqui]

Well having a 70 year old human fight a half-man/half-robot can't be a marvel of swordplay .

[Drake Tungsten]

You know, Ob-Wan sure doesn't look fifty in ROTS. Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru look pretty spry, as well, not to mention Yoda...

[Imran Siddiqui]

I think they were going for a 50ish look for Obi-Wan in ROTS... but they couldn't quite pull it off. Beru and Owen DO look 30, at best. Surely they had some makeup to make those actors look older?

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Drake Tungsten
You know, Ob-Wan sure doesn't look fifty in ROTS. Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru look pretty spry, as well, not to mention Yoda...

wan't ob-wan in his mid 20's in tPM, maybe 40 in AotC, in his mid 40's in RotS, and in his early 60's in ANH?