Post your Revenge of the Sith Reviews and Commentary here!

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Alexander's Horse
I remember when the first film came out - it was uncool nerdy entertainment in 1977/8 and its the same today.

the first 2 films of latest trilogy are amongst the worst films I have ever seen.

Unfortunately now I'm a Dad and I have to take my kids

have you ever enjoyed any Science fictions movies/TV AH?

[Jaguar]

Oh, and JohnT, if you've never seen the ROTJ DVD, don't. It has Hayden in it.

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Jaguar
Oh, and JohnT, if you've never seen the ROTJ DVD, don't. It has Hayden in it.

I haven't seen it but where on earth could that have put Hayden in ROTJ? is he in the DVD commentary or something?

[Jaguar]

Think final two minutes. At just the right time to spoil it.

[Imran Siddiqui]

Yes, remember where Vader sans mask used to be?

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Jaguar
Think final two minutes. At just the right time to spoil it.

last two minutes? isn't that the celebrations and dancing and music and what not after Vader is not only dead but cremated? What did they do, tack on a flashback or something? I thought at first youmeant they had put him in the dead jedi ghost group shot at the end, but Hayden is too young to pass as the older Anakin, unless they added some years with a cheezy make up job.

In any event I can't see any way of adding Hayden to that movie that would be anything but bad.

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui
Yes, remember where Vader sans mask used to be?

No no, it's after that.

[Boris Godunov]

Oh for heaven's sake, why the secrecy?

Lucas replaced the actor who originally played Anakin in RotJ with Hayden Christensen in the scene with the ghosts standing and watching the Rebels and Ewoks celebrating. He is meant to be Young Anakin, as his ghost apparently reverted to his pre-evil visage.

[DinoDoc]

He's in the dead Jedi group shot as you guessed.

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Boris Godunov
Oh for heaven's sake, why the secrecy?

Lucas replaced the actor who originally played Anakin in RotJ with Hayden Christensen in the scene with the ghosts standing and watching the Rebels and Ewoks celebrating. He is meant to be Young Anakin, as his ghost apparently reverted to his pre-evil visage.

this makes no sense whatsoever. I'ts baffling that Lucas would put anakin in that scene when he makes clear in his latest film that he intended only for Jedi who have had intensive years of training and access to a nearly unknwon breakthrough by Qui-gon to be able to live on as force ghosts or whatever they are.

How would anakin have learned that? Why go to the bother of tampering with the scene if not to remove the inconsistant element?

[Boris Godunov]

Well, since he already had Anakin in the scene, that point is moot. If he had deleted Anakin out of it entirely, that would probably have caused a bigger uproar. Not from me, mind you, as found that entire shot to be among the most cheesy, maudlingly sentimental moments in the entire series.

However, having Anakin in as his young self does make more sense than the one originally in it, I suppose, since that visage never existed in the first place...

[DinoDoc]

Oh for ****s sake if we're going to ***** about the changes Lucas has made to the original trilogy, there's more crimes than inserting Hayden in it that he has to answer for.

[Boris Godunov]

People have already complained about the other changes made that are worse. This is called moving on to a new complaint.

[MrFun]

wow, what a concept

[Imran Siddiqui]

How would anakin have learned that? Why go to the bother of tampering with the scene if not to remove the inconsistant element?

Well, Qui-Gon learned it after he died. It is not out of the realm of possibility that he and the rest of the dead Jedi help him along (or focus the power with Anakin).

having Anakin in as his young self does make more sense than the one originally in it,

It would have been better having the older actor without his legs or his arms .