Who would have been the best Captain of USS Voyager?

[St Leo]

Enough Iraq for one day, kiddies.

I've always been partial to the idea of making B'Ellana Torres Captain, though 7of9 had a good point or two in her favour.

[Gangerolf]

i have no idea what this is but wesley crusher sounds like a decent fellow

[Boris Godunov]

Captain E. J. Smith

[St Leo]

i have no idea what this is but wesley crusher sounds like a decent fellow

That is wrong on so many levels.

Wil Wheaton is a decent person in RL, but...

[Dominikos]

I can see this thread dropping to page 4 very quickly.

The war is a priority for discussion at the moment...

...but I don't mind throwing in my 2 cents.

I vote Captain Janeway.

Tuvok is too logical.
Bellana is too aggressive.
7 of 9 is too logical, practical, efficient.
Tom Paris is too reckless.
Chakotay looks as if he's asleep all the time.
Wesley Crusher is a child prodigy whom everyone hates.
Kim is too goody-goody.

------------------
~Dominik - Lord of the Putumayo~

[Dominikos]

The doctor is too unstable (How about a captain you can turn off?)

Neelix looks like he's made of cheese! A cook for a captain? I hate his optimism!

Kes is too small.

Captain CowboyNeal: Who the **** is he?


All things considered, Jean Luc Picard made the perfect captain and TNG was by far the best of all the series. I liked the rest too, but TNG is superior to them all.

------------------
~Dominik - Lord of the Putumayo~

[St Leo]

7 of 9 is too logical, practical, efficient.

I fail to see the problem.

[TheGuitarist]

I'm always amused by the similarity of Tuvok's name to that of 2pac.

[Dominikos]

St. Leo, perhaps you are lacking in nutritional supplements? You should re-generate!

------------------
~Dominik - Lord of the Putumayo~

[GePap]

They horribly wasted what they could have done with the 7 of 9 character, but the notion of wasted potential runs all along the Voyager story.

I say Chakotay, just cause he was level headed and a bit les simpulsive than Janeway. More like Picard and less like Kirk......

[Ozz]

Scotty from TOS

The rest are wimps, except 7/9 who can be yeoman

[Verto]

As the Doctor and 7 of 9 were the only decent characters, I voted for the Doctor.

[DRoseDARs]

Originally posted by Gangerolf
i have no idea what this is but wesley crusher sounds like a decent fellow...

*A cooold shiver runs down DRose's spine at the thought...*
...Wrong on so many different levels.

God, what would he do, whine his enemies to death? Maybe initially, but after a while his reputation would preceed Voyager and every Delta Quadrant species they come across would try to destroy them on sight.

Picard: "Shut up, Wesley."
Beverly: "Shut up, Wesley?"
Moments later after Wesley says something else whiny for the umpteenth time, Picard and Beverly: "Shut up, Wesley!"

[Joseph]

Originally posted by Dominikos
I can see this thread dropping to page 4 very quickly.

The war is a priority for discussion at the moment...

...but I don't mind throwing in my 2 cents.

I vote Captain Janeway.

Tuvok is too logical.
Bellana is too aggressive.
7 of 9 is too logical, practical, efficient.
Tom Paris is too reckless.
Chakotay looks as if he's asleep all the time.
Wesley Crusher is a child prodigy whom everyone hates.
Kim is too goody-goody.

------------------
~Dominik - Lord of the Putumayo~

Janeway did just fine.
I was a little concern when they said a lady Capt., but after watching the show for a while, she did OK.
Due to my age, I have seen evey Star Trek show the first time. Have yet to miss one.

[Sandman]

A sarcastic captain.

"Remind me to ask Starfleet for some consoles which don't explode."

"Oh goody. Forehead aliens with no concept of cultural relativism."

"Thanks, Chakotay, your spiritual advice is really helpful."