I just went into walmart for the first time in months... I feel physically ill

[Fake Boris]

Originally posted by Kucinich
Yes, since their condition without the company would be worse than their condition with the company.

Spare us that BS, will you? What would be the company's condition without the people working for them?

[Kuciwalker]

The company should also be thankful for the workers, of course. My point is that WE shouldn't complain about this. If the workers want to complain, they can - by striking or passing laws requiring a minimum wage.

[General Ludd]

More importantly, would those people be happier?

This is happening in places where people have lived without any sort of sweat-shop jobs for millions of years.

I admittedly don't know much about the circumstances ('cause frankly I've never been inclined to learn about the subject - enlighten me if you actually know what you're talking about) and I'm sure it varies from place to place, but this is happening in places where people have lived happily for millions of years before sweat-shops existed - obviously, something has changed their society so that they can no longer be self sufficient and now have to rely on the "charitable" hand-outs of their first world masters, in exchange for repetious 16-hour a day work in conditions which are illegal in the countries of their employers.

[Kuciwalker]

The "something" that has changed has been that they were offered jobs by the corporations.

They lived as poorly, or worse, before, because they were essentially a primitive civilization. You wouldn't say the ancient Greeks and Romans lived in poverty, even though their conditions were horrific compared to now, would you?

[General Ludd]

They lived as poorly, or worse

They wheren't working in a sweatshop 16 hours a day.


Describe a worse life then that.

[Kuciwalker]

If the sweatshop is worse than what they had before, why did they decide to work in the sweatshop?

[General Ludd]

Originally posted by Kucinich
If the sweatshop is worse than what they had before, why did they decide to work in the sweatshop?

Well, let's take the example of the luddites ( ) - some of the first people to fall victim to this. They where weavers and farmers, and lived decent lives untill factories where opened up which they couldn't compete with. So now they where out of the job, and the only options where to be locked in a factory 16 hours a day for a meager wage they could barely live off, or... well, nothing. The luddites took your advice of "If the workers want to complain, they can - by striking or passing laws requiring a minimum wage." they demanded that the machines where outlawed, and when they wheren't they 'striked' out and destroyed the machines that where taking away their livelyhood and turning self-sustained people into wage-slaves. The result? The army was sent out to kill them.

[Imran Siddiqui]

mom'n'pap shop suck. They suck from a consumer's pov, they suck from society's pov. They ARE NOT The fabric of your community.

I mean, really. They're working 16 hours a day in a factory, and still live in absolute poverty, and you think they should be thankful?

Compared to the other jobs in their country? Uh... yeah!

[Imran Siddiqui]

American companies should be required to treat their overseas peons... err workers as they would an American employee in the States. Benefits, wages that are approirate for their living cost standards and so on.

Yeah, and then these countries suffer massive inflation and everyone who doesn't work for a American company can't afford jack. That's smart .

They where weavers and farmers, and lived decent lives untill factories where opened up which they couldn't compete with.

Boo Hoo... if you can't compete with more efficient and better ways of production, get out of the way.

[Az]

shut up, Imran, you make me look bad.

[Kidlicious]

Wal-mart is very successfull, so it's hard to critisize them. I'm sure they have high employee turnover though. That's why they have recruitment commercials.

The last time I was in there I could hardly stand to wait in line because the ceiling fans and the florescent lights combined into a horrible headache producing effect. Jeez, I'll never apply there even if they paid more than minimum wage. I would go crazy before 1 hour, let alone 8.

[Imran Siddiqui]

shut up, Imran, you make me look bad.

Wal-mart is very successfull, so it's hard to critisize them.

Well not really . Target is much better in terms of prices and quality. Though Sam's Club is very similar to Costco (I prefer Costco, but it is too far away for me).

[General Ludd]

Yeah, and then these countries suffer massive inflation and everyone who doesn't work for a American company can't afford jack. That's smart .

I thought this was your argument for why people should be happy to work in sweat-shops - 'cause they can't afford jack if they don't.

[Kidlicious]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui

shut up, Imran, you make me look bad.

Wal-mart is very successfull, so it's hard to critisize them.

Well not really . Target is much better in terms of prices and quality. Though Sam's Club is very similar to Costco (I prefer Costco, but it is too far away for me).

I'm sure Wal-mart has much more market share.

[Imran Siddiqui]

I thought this was your argument for why people should be happy to work in sweat-shops - 'cause they can't afford jack if they don't.

Of course they can afford stuff if they don't work in the sweatshops, but the sweatshop worker can afford MORE. That is the reason these sweatshop jobs are in high demand (and with low supply of them, the price of labor, naturally will be low).

Basically it's like people being happy to work in medicine (even though it may suck in the beginning) in the US, because they can afford more, even though a job like retail is much less demanding.