China turned from scientific to militaristic?

[Patriqvium]

Originally posted by DarkCloud
CHINA did NOT invent Gunpowder! They invented Powder for Fireworks!

In addition to this, they invented Powder for Hand Grenades v. 0.9b (those Chinese-made "grenades" were iron balls filled with the mixture of potassium nitrate, charcoal and sulphur)...

[DarkCloud]

...Good point

[YefeiPi]

CHINA did NOT invent Gunpowder! They invented Powder for Fireworks!

They not only invented gunpowder, they also invented your mom.

[Dida]

China certainly qualifies as a scientific civ. It invented, among other things, paper, gunpower, compass, and toothbrush. Compass we probably don't use much nowadays, but can you live without toothbrush?

[Sun Zi 36]

Well, I think everyone agrees that the Chinese is not militaristic and more scientific. The only reason they wanted to change it was bcos it triggers golden age when the Great Wall was built. But even that reason I don't agree with. The Great wall shouldn't trigger golden ages for militaristic civs bcos militaristic civs won't build a wall to shield off themselves. Thus firaxis shouldn't have changed Chinese to militaristic. They should instead cancel the militaristic golden age trigger for the Great Wall.

[Sun Zi 36]

I forgot to say about Sun Zi's wonder. It's another reason why they changed China to militaristic.

Well, I don't think Sun Zi should be a wonder at all, amongst many other Chinese achievements that could be considered as a wonder. eg Forbidden City, Silk Road, Grand Canal.

If they want a wonder for militaristic civs, they should make it Napoleon's Academy or Genghis Khan's Academy.

[Urban Ranger]

Originally posted by DarkCloud
And Urban Ranger- Commercial might be good, but remember that China shut themselves away from the world after about 1500... If one would consider the ancient ages commerical may be good- but I think Scientific-Expansion would be best

Yes, Imperial China did become progressively isolationistic after the beginning of Ming dynasty, which was unfortunate. Think of it this way though: out of at least 3000 years about 400 years or so were isolationistic. Not bad at all. How long has those French been at it? Shorter, I submit

As for being Expansionistic, that also came in spurs. At the beginning of certain dynasties (notably Han, Tang, Qing, but particularly Yuan) much was done to push back the borders, only to have them eroded as imperial power declined.