5th Official Top Games Poll

[Hot Mustard]

1. Civ 3
2. Civ 2
3. MoM*
4. MoO 2
5. Railroad Tycoon (original)
6. M.U.L.E.
7. SimCity (original)
8. Starcraft
9. Lemmings (original)
10. Tetris

And so many more that wouldn't get points...

* Where's the sequel, dammit!

[gjramsey]

1. Dragon Warrior
2. Alpha Centauri
3. Wizardry 8
4. Master of Orion 2
5. Master of Magic
6. Knights of the Old Republic
7. Heroes of Might and Magic 3
8. Legend of Zelda
9. Might & Magic VI
10. Age of Wonders: Shadow Magic

[Pave]

1. Civ3
2. CtP 1
3. Steel Panthers: World at War
4. IL-2: Forgotten Battles
5. Homeworld 1
6. Magic: The Gathering
7. Return to Krondor
8. Age of Empires 1
9. Shogun: Total War
10. Master of Orion 2

[Krill]

1. C3
2. Tetris
3. Command and Conquer: Generals
4. Unreal Tournament
5. Lemmings
6. Total Annihilation
7. C&C: Red Alert
8. Rollercoatser Tycoon
9. Mine Sweeper
10. Free Cell

[Moral Hazard]

I tried to pick the best of a series for the top ten, so others in the series only get honorable mention if anything. This is also based on personal experience i.e. NCAA 2004 was the first football game I really got into since the clunkers on Snes.

1. Civilization 2
2. Fallout 2
3. Hardball 3
4. Ultima 7
5. CTP
6. Pirates!
7. Medieval: Total War
8. Freelancer
9. Red Baron
10. Age of Wonders

Honorable Mention(pretty much in order: NBA street Vol.2, Planescape Torment , Unreal Tournament, NCAA Football 2004, Fallout, Railroad Tycoon, Tie Fighter, Lemmings Series, Civilization 1, Wolfenstein 3D, Airborne Ranger, NHL Hockey Series, MVP Baseball 2004, No One Lives Forever, Giants: Citizen Kabuto, DOOM, Shogun TW(I need to get Rome), Ultima 4 -> 7.5.

[Drogue]

1. SMAC
2. Baldur's Gate II
3. Baldur's Gate
4. Phantasy Star
5. Ultima IV
6. Quake
7. Unreal Tournament
8. Civ (I)
9. NHL '93
10. Smack the Penguin

[Nikolai]

1.) Europa Universalis 2
2.) SMAC (not X)
3.) Civ 2
4.) Commander Keen (all of them, but if I must choose one, Keen 4)
5.) Civ 1
6.) Super Mario World
7.) Civ 3
8.) Crusader Kings
9.) GTA 3
10.) SimCity 3000

[Dis]

err, my vote for X-com was for the first one.

Some people are saying the name of the game was Enemy Unkown.

I'm not sure what the exact name of the game was. So my vote for X-com is for the first one.

[Dis]

also my votes are mainly based on the hours played (roughly as far as I can guesstimate)

I figure the game I played the most is logically the game I enjoyed the most. I think that line of reasoning is sound.

That's why you see Civ2 higher than Civ3 in my poll even though I no longer play civ2, and only play civ3 now.

[Skanky Burns]

There was a European version and a US version. One was called UFO and the other was called Enemy Unknown. Both the same game though.

[Admiral]

1: Deus Ex
2: SMAC/X
3: Starcraft
4: Neverwinter Nights
5: Warcraft 3
6: MOO2
7: Civ 2
8: Civ 3
9: Jedi Knight II
10: HoMM 3

Though I'm not entirely sure that I ranked it as it should be ranked.

[EPW]

1. CTP2
2. CTP
3. Morrowind
4. Starfox 64
5. Starcraft
6. Freecell
7. Counter-Strike
8. President Forever
9. Warcraft 3
10. Solitaire

[Jaguar]

I agree. His rights to select games should be revoked.


1. Civilization 2
2. Half-Life
3. Halo
4. Deus Ex
5. Warcraft II
6. Colonization
7. Simcity (original)
8. Super Mario Bros 3
9. Doom
10. Imperialism

[Paddy]

1. Reach for the Stars - PC
2. Civ III - PC
3. Command & Conquer - PSOne
4. NBA '98 - PSOne
5. Gran Turismo III - PS2
6. SSX Tricky - PS2
7. Diplomacy - PC
8. Carriers at War - PC
9. Panzer Battles - PC
10. Civ II - PSOne

[DrSpike]

Wow, Skanky must need more posts if it's poll time.