Most "Unbreakable" Sports Record

[PLATO]

The pro football thread got me thinking about Johnny Unitas and the "unbreakable" record he holds of 47 consecutive games with a touchdown pass.

There are many such "unbreakable" records in sports. Which one do you think is the most "unbreakable"?

[Jaguar]

Of those, I'd go with Cy Young. I doubt Brown's record will be beaten, either.

Pitchers in the MLB today get 30 decisions, max, for each season. A pitcher who went 30-0 for seventeen years would still be short.

[snoopy369]

Clearly Cy Young. Every other record there could theoretically be broken; no pitcher will win 25 games a year for 20 years with the 5 man rotation.

I'd go one further and say that Old Hoss Radbourn has the most truly unbreakable record - 59 wins in a season. (Or Jack Chesbro (41) if you want to limit it to 1900+). Again, no pitcher even pitches in 40 games as a starter, and it's not realistic for a reliever to win more than 20 (in fact it's never been done).

[Asher]

Gretzky: 92 goals in a season
Bobby Orr: 139 points (by a defenseman)
Goals by a rookie: 72 (Selanne)
Career shutouts: 103 (Sawchuk)

[PLATO]

Originally posted by Asher
Gretzky: 92 goals in a season
Bobby Orr: 139 points (by a defenseman)
Goals by a rookie: 72 (Selanne)
Career shutouts: 103 (Sawchuk)

Yeah...you have a point. I realized after I posted the poll how heavily biased it was.

Sorry Hockey fans.

Gretzky should get his own thread anyway...How many other players are known simply as "The Great One"?

[SlowwHand]

Cy Young is the clear choice.
I voted for the 2nd. Longest streak of throwing at least 1 touchdown pass per game: Johnny Unitas, 47 games

[Imran Siddiqui]

I voted for Cy Young's record, but did Wilt actually have 55 rebounds in one game?! Holy crap!

[Donegeal]

UCLA winning the big dance 7 times in a row will never be broken. Maybe a school wins 4 if they get a good group of freshmen that actually stay the entire time, but never 7.

[SlowwHand]

Unitas played in 12 game years. That's a TD pass per game for 4 years, in an era not really all that pass oriented.

[-Jrabbit]

I also voted for Cy Young's record, but I gotta say, Richard Petty winning 27 races in one Nascar season sounds pretty unbeatable. Especially now, when they have rules and stuff...

[Guynemer]

Cy Young, CLEARLY.

55 rebounds is big, extremely unlikely to be broken, but no way is anyone getting near Cy Young.


Richard Petty is disqualified since we are talking about sports records.

[Ninot]

Originally posted by Asher
Gretzky: 92 goals in a season
Bobby Orr: 139 points (by a defenseman)
Goals by a rookie: 72 (Selanne)
Career shutouts: 103 (Sawchuk)

I don't think any of those are really out of reach. Specially not Sawchuk. The single season shutout record, maybe.

Cy Young is the most impossible option in the poll

[Arrian]

Cy Young and DiMaggio are the two "unbreakable" baseball records... with Cy Young's probably being safer. Most games won by a pitcher in a season is almost certainly safe as well. Even if they someday go back to a 4-man rotation (possible, if unlikely), hardly anyone wins 20 games in a season now. So what if you bump that barrier up to ~25 games? It's still not gonna get you close.

I don't really know enough about the other sports to comment.

-Arrian

[Ming]

Some great records here...
However, I feel a few of them can be broken, while many won't.

-Longest streak of throwing at least 1 touchdown pass per game: Johnny Unitas, 47 games

Brady could beat this one

-Most seasons leading the NFL in rushing yards: Jim Brown, 8

A good record, and will be difficult to beat because it requires a superstar to stay healthy... but I don't think it's unbreakable

-Most touchdown passes thrown in a season: Peyton Manning, 49

Will probably fall this year

-Most points, single game: Wilt Chamberlain, 100
Even the greedy and selfish Coby can't get close to this one now... so unless the game changes dramatically, this one is safe.

-Most rebounds single game: Wilt Chamberlain, 55
I didn't remember this one... I don't think this one can be beat either. Unless there is an 8 footer somewhere


-Most seasons leading the league in scoring: Michael Jordan, 10

While this is impressive, I think this one can be beat.

-Most career wins: Cy Young, 511

For the reasons many have already stated, this will always be the record.

-Longest hitting streak: Joe DiMaggio, 56 games
Again... an impressive record, but I see this as one that can beat.

-Most consecutive games played: Cal Ripken, 2,632
Another one that can be beat, but still a great record

-UCLA Bruins: 7 consecutive NCAA basketball titles
With the expanded field of teams, I don't see how anybody can beat this one. Just going back to back in impressive, 7 is impossible.

-Oklahoma Sooners: 47 consecutive NCAA Division 1-A football victories

This is one of those records that I think will be very difficult to beat. With players able to opt out to the NFL early, it's hard to keep those dynasties going. However, it wouldn't totally surprise me if somebody did it.


-Richard Petty: Winning 27 NASCAR races in one season
I also really can't put this one in perspective since I don't follow NASCAR. It sounds good, but who knows.

[Stuie]

Most career wins: Cy Young, 511

This will NEVER be broken.

Richard Petty: Winning 27 NASCAR races in one season

I thought the question was about SPORTS.