Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBro View Post

    I disagree. Post 2014 development shows where the legitimacy is.
    On that point we don't seem to disagree. As I just said, until another fair election could occur. I am not aware of any extraordinary issues with the subsequent Ukrainian elections. Zelensky is a legitimate leader in a legally legitimate Ukrainian government. I maintain that fair elections can legitimatize an illegitimate government. That said I cannot accept Euromaiden itself as legitimate.

    To go further with the hypothetical successful 06JAN2021 pro trump riot example, if that had occurred I would not recognize the riots as legitimate at any point but after fair and free elections that followed I would recognize the government as having re-attained legitimacy.

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    Yanukovych became pres in 2010, and afaik, the election was ok, so he was seen a the legitimate guy. But the situation changed over time, and in 2013/14 there was a major conflict in Ukraine mainly about the question of further EU approach or Russia friendly course.

    Yanukovych was ousted in result of that.

    Now there's a large amount of stuff/media coverage/whatnot back and forth about the actual turn of events. So far I've seen positions regarding "who shot demonstrators" (that it happened as such seems undisputed) that are:

    - Yanukovych's security service
    - Anti-Russian folks in general
    - Anti-Russian NeoNazis
    - US operatives/CIA
    - Russian operatives/GRU

    (maybe more)

    How much of it is conclusive is a completely different question

    Leave a comment:


  • Wezil
    replied
    Was a free and fair election available in 2014 Ukraine? I really like things to be settled through the ballot box but that isn't always an option.

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
    Euromaidan was wrong. They should have gotten their revolution at the ballot box
    I disagree. Post 2014 development shows where the legitimacy is.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBro View Post

    I see no long-standing popular support (in the sense of majority support) for the Jan 6 events, but we do have a measure of popular support for Biden vs Trump - which is the pres election won by Biden.
    Yanukovych also had popular support and larger mandate than Biden.

    I maintain that Euromaidan is only as legitimate as a second trump term resulting from 06jan2021 rioting would have been. Which is basically no legitimacy until another fair election could occur.

    Euromaidan was wrong. They should have gotten their revolution at the ballot box

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
    If you want to say Euromaidan was a normal legitimate revolution then, had the trump mob successfully overturned the election of Biden on Jan 06 of 2021 then we find ourselves having to call that legitimate as well.
    I see no long-standing popular support (in the sense of majority support) for the Jan 6 events, but we do have a measure of popular support for Biden vs Trump - which is the pres election won by Biden.

    Leave a comment:


  • Wezil
    replied

    Leave a comment:


  • Wezil
    replied
    Well of course, but that would be inevitable. You guys don't let states leave your political union either. We have precedent.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Wezil View Post
    Canada would have been forced to invade to put down the Russian backed Nazi coup in Washington.
    Only after sensible border states that seceded in the aftermath to try to join Canada were prevented from doing so for 8 years by trumps military campaign to ethnically cleanse those states of Canadians through massive shelling and deployments of Nazis.

    Leave a comment:


  • Wezil
    replied
    Canada would have been forced to invade to put down the Russian backed Nazi coup in Washington.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by BeBro View Post
    It's worth noting that the legality of the Maidan stuff is on par with that of the American or French Revolutions, not to mention others. They were all illegal vs. the previous order. That's the nature of these things.

    Ukraine did not only have a "coup", it had democratic elections since 2014, which confirm the pro-western course. If anything support - and so legitimacy - of the post-2014 developments has been rising, to a good deal due to Putins actions over the last 8 years.
    Sure. But while the orange revolution deposed Viktor Yanukovych after serious revelations of electoral fraud forced a second election which he lost, the later Euromaidan fiasco resulted in a duly elected (with international observers vouching for lack of obvious electoral fraud) government being replaced by an unelected one.

    If you want to say Euromaidan was a normal legitimate revolution then, had the trump mob successfully overturned the election of Biden on Jan 06 of 2021 then we find ourselves having to call that legitimate as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • Wezil
    replied
    But, but, Nazis and Biden!!

    Leave a comment:


  • BeBMan
    replied
    It's worth noting that the legality of the Maidan stuff is on par with that of the American or French Revolutions, not to mention others. They were all illegal vs. the previous order. That's the nature of these things.

    Ukraine did not only have a "coup", it had democratic elections since 2014, which confirm the pro-western course. If anything support - and so legitimacy - of the post-2014 developments has been rising, to a good deal due to Putins actions over the last 8 years.

    Leave a comment:


  • dannubis
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post

    For the record i've always recognized euromaidan as an illegal and unjustified coup with a host of criminals and some CIA spooks and other paid western agents attempting to grease it's tracks.

    So what?

    Illegal coups don't justify any of what Russia has done in response and are zero evidence of Washington control of any Ukrainians at all, let alone of the entire Ukrainian government.
    Do you honestly think that COVID was a coincidence ???? Covid -> Vaccines -> Mind control ->... Trump won the election !!!! Biden is 666.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post
    but it is evidence of a coup
    For the record i've always recognized euromaidan as an illegal and unjustified coup with a host of criminals and some CIA spooks and other paid western agents attempting to grease it's tracks.

    So what?

    Illegal coups don't justify any of what Russia has done in response and are zero evidence of Washington control of any Ukrainians at all, let alone of the entire Ukrainian government.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X