Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post
    so if you're in charge of Russia and you see a Nazi/US backed coup next door and Nazis show up near your border to kill ethnic Russians how long would you wait before intervening to end the war?

    I imagine Russians living in the area were volunteering to defend their kin across the border, I bet Russians were demanding Putin stop the attacks. He helped but it took 8 years of this before he invaded Ukraine. I think he's okay with Zelensky as PM, at least he wanted to end the war but the US and Nazis outvoted him 2-1.
    I would wait until hell freezes over to invade as I think the record of attacking other countries to stop ethnic cleansing is generally one cluster**** after the other and as the interventions nearly always kill more people than the ethnic cleansing. Of course this is assuming I accept the bull**** that 14000 casualties in 8 years of conflict was largely in the form of ethnic cleansing rather than direct conflict between armed forces. As for the Nazis I would do what we do about Nazis in every other country in the world. Nothing because they have zero power and attacking them militarily makes heroes of the Nazis. How ****ed up is that? After my attack do you think the people will sympathize more or less with these Nazis?

    As for volunteering and demanding, so what? Texans volunteer to fight in the conflict and it's irrelevant. People make all sorts of whacky demands. History shows demands to start wars should be the last ones to heed.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post

    And I think his demands are reasonable

    1 stop fighting
    2 Crimea stays Russian
    3 breakaway Republics are independent
    4 constitution amended to ensure neutrality

    under Minsk the Republics would have remained in Ukraine but with autonomy... everyone agreed to Minsk... on paper. But the Ukrainian govt never implemented it, neither the US or the Nazis wanted peace. Thats just the reality.
    1. stop fighting...grossly unreasonable demand as huge Russian military formations have literally invaded Ukraine, especially given they are overwhelmingly in non disputed areas, and Russia recognized the legitimacy of all of Ukraine dejure borders as recently as 8 years ago (before unilaterally demanding changes).

    2. Crimea 'stays' Russian. This actually means Ukraine must surrender its' dejure claims to Crimea. Claims everyone recognized less than 10 years ago. This could be negotiable but it would be an enormous concession.

    3. Breakaway republics are independent. Maybe this could be negotiable if Russia could agree to legally binding commitments to leave them independent.

    4. constitution amended to ensure neutrality. patently absurd. Given Russia's constant aggression Ukraine requires alliances with nuclear powers more than any other country in the world. How could any representative form of government entertain any kind of "neutrality" after all that?

    Leave a comment:


  • -Jrabbit
    commented on 's reply
    Nice attempt to change the subject. I'll take that to mean you think Putin should be appeased.

  • Berzerker
    replied
    But this portrayal does Chamberlain a gross historical injustice. For all his undoubted flaws, including his vanity and self-delusion about Hitler, he deserves a large amount of credit for the RAF’s success in 1940. Far from leaving our defences ill-equipped, he was the leader responsible for ensuring that Britain had the planes ready for the titanic struggle against the Luftwaffe. For most of the 1930s, while he was prime minister and chancellor, his decisions provided the funds for the RAF’s expansion and ensured the money was focused on fighters. As he wrote to his sister Ida in July 1940: “If I am personally responsible for deficiencies in tanks and guns, I must equally be responsible for the efficiency of the RAF.”
    Flying through blue sky towards London, the Luftwaffe crews were in a confident mood. It was 15 September 1940 and their commanders had told them that,


    He won the Battle of Britain by building the RAF

    Leave a comment:


  • Uncle Sparky
    commented on 's reply
    Canada has most of the world's top snipers... I'm peeved we don't get mentioned in the conspiracy!

  • -Jrabbit
    commented on 's reply
    Your supposition/assumption (the "if" part) is extremely problematic, and your "I imagine" scenario is pure fantasy.

    All sovereign nations are free to decide their loyalties and treaties for themselves. It's, like, the definition of "sovereign."

    I suspect you would have been a big supporter of Chamberlain's appeasement approach to Nazi Germany's expansion into neighboring countries.

  • Wezil
    commented on 's reply
    It was neither a "Nazi" nor "US" coup. I don't have the same faith in Jimmy Dore that you have.

    I'd take this argument more seriously if I believed you gave a crap about either Ukraine or Nazi's. . I mentioned before (and you avoided before) the prevalence of fascists in the US Republican party but I have yet to see a single post from you about this. I believe this is just a tool for you to attack Democrats.

  • Berzerker
    replied
    so if you're in charge of Russia and you see a Nazi/US backed coup next door and Nazis show up near your border to kill ethnic Russians how long would you wait before intervening to end the war?

    I imagine Russians living in the area were volunteering to defend their kin across the border, I bet Russians were demanding Putin stop the attacks. He helped but it took 8 years of this before he invaded Ukraine. I think he's okay with Zelensky as PM, at least he wanted to end the war but the US and Nazis outvoted him 2-1.

    And I think his demands are reasonable

    1 stop fighting
    2 Crimea stays Russian
    3 breakaway Republics are independent
    4 constitution amended to ensure neutrality

    under Minsk the Republics would have remained in Ukraine but with autonomy... everyone agreed to Minsk... on paper. But the Ukrainian govt never implemented it, neither the US or the Nazis wanted peace. Thats just the reality.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Berzerker View Post



    sounds like a justification
    It is. And about equally plausible in both settings.

    Ukraine has an azov battalion and exchanges artillery fire for 8 years and you call that deployment of Nazis and massive shelling.

    tell me berz since Euromaidan, how many people have died to separatist and Russian shells and how many from Ukrainian shells?

    Can we call it genocide or ethnic cleansing if it's anywhere near even, let alone with higher loyalist casualties?
    Last edited by Geronimo; March 10, 2022, 14:45.

    Leave a comment:


  • Berzerker
    commented on 's reply
    would you trust an election following a Nazi/US coup?

    they didn't do this for democracy

  • Berzerker
    replied
    Originally posted by Geronimo View Post
    Illegal coups don't justify any of what Russia has done in response
    Only after sensible border states that seceded in the aftermath to try to join Canada were prevented from doing so for 8 years by trumps military campaign to ethnically cleanse those states of Canadians through massive shelling and deployments of Nazis.
    sounds like a justification

    Leave a comment:


  • Berzerker
    commented on 's reply
    the people protesting the coup did not make that decision based on the alleged legitimacy of future elections they couldn't even vote in because they were under attack by Nazis and frankly I dont trust western assessments of fair elections, the west was pouring billions into Ukraine to bribe people and pay for the war.

  • Berzerker
    commented on 's reply
    they have a guy on tape admitting to it and overwhelming medical and eyewitness evidence, even the cop radio traffic shows they were under fire

  • Berzerker
    commented on 's reply
    shall we call them Ewoks?

  • -Jrabbit
    commented on 's reply
    None of that justifies Putin's invasion.
Working...
X