Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Given the taxation regime of most European countries and the fact that their husband would be subsidizing childcare for those who choose to work, I would argue otherwise. European countries are very hostile tax wise to women staying at home.
    Can´t agree with this, at least for germany, where thanks to tax reduction for married couples, it is very viable if one of them stays at home ...
    also, according to statistics, 47 % of the mothers in germany with at least one child younger than 6 years are stay at home mothers without a job ... in france it is still 41%.
    Which is a higher percentage than within the USA, where it is just 37%
    (although one should add that, at least for germany, thanks to minimum wages and other legal regulations, it probably also is much more economic viable to live with just one paycheck, than it is the case for the USA)


    Last edited by Proteus_MST; January 11, 2016, 06:09.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I have no doubts that there are women who prefer not to study or have a job and instead be 24/7 housewife and/or mother ...
    but those woman already have the freedom to do so in our western society and aren´t forced to study or make a career
    (and therefore aren´t necessarily included in the number of people that study or are successful in their jobs)
    Given the taxation regime of most European countries and the fact that their husband would be subsidizing childcare for those who choose to work, I would argue otherwise. European countries are very hostile tax wise to women staying at home.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Ancestry of James I:

    Stuart, Hamilton, Stuart, Sinclair, Douglas, Drummond, Tudor, Plantagenet, Stuart, Oldenburg, Tudor, Plantagenet, Metz, Egmond, Capet, van Limburg

    Of his 16 ancestors, 3 were Stuarts, 2 Plantagenets and 2 Tudors.

    He is twice related to Mary Tudor (Henry VII's daughter by Elizabeth Plantagenet), once via Archibald Douglas, and once via King James of Scotland.

    Of the Stuarts, all three are different branches, one is the royal line, two are subsidiary lines, and they are very different from each other.

    So out to his great grandparents, he has one overlap, Mary Tudor. That is all. His consanguinity is around 12.5 percent.

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Women are not a monolith, Proteus. Sure, some would feel this way, but just because you feel this way is not how all women would feel.
    Which is why I said "most, if not all" instead of "all".
    I also limited my prediction to those women who study and/or are successful in their jobs

    I have no doubts that there are women who prefer not to study or have a job and instead be 24/7 housewife and/or mother ...
    but those woman already have the freedom to do so in our western society and aren´t forced to study or make a career
    (and therefore aren´t necessarily included in the number of people that study or are successful in their jobs)

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Strawman. You claimed that being born outside the US disqualifies someone from being considered "natural born citizen".
    So you're suggesting that they reserved natural born people to White people is not a significant concession? They wanted people who had similar languages and similar cultures. Race was a placeholder for this.

    The law in 1790 specifically stated that there were cases which being born outside the US still qualified for "natural born citizen".
    Among white people, and they traced citizenship through the father, meaning that Cruz would be Cuban. You immediately dismissed the law as 'misogynist and racist', and yet would take part of it without the rest of it. They had a reason for doing what they did, and I think it's significant that they chose to do things this way.

    Unsurprisingly you adopt the racist portion of the law to "prove" your point, which has nothing to do with what was actually being discussed.
    Mhmm, well I am pretty sure I understand their rationales and it still doesn't get you where you want to go.

    While there are plenty of other stupid things that have happened in history, it doesn't excuse your stupidity for wanting an inbred family to rule over everyone.
    LOL

    Inbred? LOL

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I am sure that most (if not all) of the girls studying today (or being successful in their jobs) would be very unhappy if they would have to quit their study (no higher education for women in the 19th centurey) because boyfriend/husband wouldn´t allow it and if they would only be allowed to have a job, if their husband/boyfriend allowed it (and then usually no higher positions, as jobs with important decision making would bve reserved for men.
    Women are not a monolith, Proteus. Sure, some would feel this way, but just because you feel this way is not how all women would feel.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    My experience with them? How do you know about my experiences with women? And why would by experiences with women mean that I have an adversarial relationship with them?
    Because that's my charism, Kid. Men who feel that they have gotten the short end of the stick tend to harbor resentment.

    In words? Yes. Is that a problem for you?
    You might as well ask, "why are sunsets beautiful?" Words are inadequate.

    Why do you think the Protestant Church is separated from women? That's insane.
    Because I was one and they despise Mary. They have bad theology when it comes to her and the position of women within the Church.

    But what does their gender have to do with anything?
    The fact that I'm saved and will not go to hell because of them? Because of their kindness and support through some difficult periods of my life? Because they would invite me to lunch and tea? Women are not men, and thank God for that.

    Good Night! Are women your God?!!
    No, but they brought me to Him. And for that I am grateful.

    First of all, I don't see the Church serving God.
    We are not individuals, Kid. We are members of one Body, serving our Lord. This, again, is bad theology you have picked up.

    I see individual Christians serving God. And it doesn't matter what gender they are. Did Christ not say in Heaven there are neither male or female?
    Yes, it does matter, Kidicious. We are men because God chose to make us men. Women are women because God chose to make them that way. This, again, is part of the reason why protestants have issues with other parts of their theology, specifically concerning the body and the purpose that God has for us in our lives.

    Women are supposed to be women, and you, and your church does not understand the beauty of this.

    Besides that I have no idea what you are talking about. You have female all tied up in your religion. I've never seen anything so strange. Of course you will say that you don't worship women. You talk crazy dude.
    That you accuse me of 'worshipping women', is what is wrong with your theology. You consider honoring women worshipping them, and we can appreciate them for who they are.

    You need to read your Bible, Kid. "He made them male and female".
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 11, 2016, 05:37.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Don't forget "chastisement" ...

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
    Women were housewives. Middle class homes are not concentration camps. Try listening to yourself some time.
    I am sure that most (if not all) of the girls studying today (or being successful in their jobs) would be very unhappy if they would have to quit their study (no higher education for women in the 19th centurey) because boyfriend/husband wouldn´t allow it and if they would only be allowed to have a job, if their husband/boyfriend allowed it (and then usually no higher positions, as jobs with important decision making would bve reserved for men) ...
    and if all of their money would be managed by their husband/boyfriend, who decided whether they would actually be allowed to use some of the money they earned for themselves, or wether all of the money would go into financing his new car (or some other of his interests)
    (aside from not owning any property in the common household, as all property would belong to the husband by default, also meaning that in case of a divorce she would lose everything, even the property she brought into the marriage (and also the children, who also were seen as belonging to the husband))

    And who would have to ask their husband for permission (and maybe some money if they wanted to go and meet their girls clique

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ming View Post
    Do you even listen to yourself...

    Kidland... woman were more happy when they were treated like slaves and had no choices or freedom.
    Forced to marry people they didn't even know... not allowed to get an education...

    Show some facts... oh that's right, there aren't any. Just keep making things up as usual.
    Women were housewives. Middle class homes are not concentration camps. Try listening to yourself some time.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    "Free white person". Well. I guess you've proved your case that by the law of 1790, that Cruz's father would be ineligible.
    Strawman. You claimed that being born outside the US disqualifies someone from being considered "natural born citizen". You claimed that you wanted to respect the original intent of the phrase. The law in 1790 specifically stated that there were cases which being born outside the US still qualified for "natural born citizen".

    Unsurprisingly you adopt the racist portion of the law to "prove" your point, which has nothing to do with what was actually being discussed.

    Stupider than the whole 'Glorious Revolution?' and the bedpan nonsense?
    While there are plenty of other stupid things that have happened in history, it doesn't excuse your stupidity for wanting an inbred family to rule over everyone.

    Leave a comment:


  • SlowwHand
    replied
    I know an Indian (India ) that just finalized an agreement on marriage for his daughter. Here, in America.
    I can't imagine such.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ming
    replied
    Do you even listen to yourself...

    Kidland... woman were more happy when they were treated like slaves and had no choices or freedom.
    Forced to marry people they didn't even know... not allowed to get an education...

    Show some facts... oh that's right, there aren't any. Just keep making things up as usual.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    That seems to be your relationship with women in general, which is adversarial, due to your experiences with them.
    My experience with them? How do you know about my experiences with women? And why would by experiences with women mean that I have an adversarial relationship with them?
    In words?
    Yes. Is that a problem for you?
    Catholics have the Theotokos, Mary, the Blessed Virgin. So the Church is not 'different', or 'set apart' from women. Women are an integral part of it.
    Why do you think the Protestant Church is separated from women? That's insane.
    For me, again, it does. The conservatives that I look up to, many of them are women, and they have encouraged me and made me a better person, a better conservative and a better Catholic over the years.
    But what does their gender have to do with anything? Good Night! Are women your God?!!
    You see women as not following the role appointed to them by God, ergo, there is a fundamental conflict between women in American culture and the church, which serves God.
    First of all, I don't see the Church serving God. I see individual Christians serving God. And it doesn't matter what gender they are. Did Christ not say in Heaven there are neither male or female?

    Besides that I have no idea what you are talking about. You have female all tied up in your religion. I've never seen anything so strange. Of course you will say that you don't worship women. You talk crazy dude.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    So why are you talking about seeing women as adversaries. Did you learn that in church or from some feminists on the internet? I know you haven't taken any Women's Studies, or have you?
    That seems to be your relationship with women in general, which is adversarial, due to your experiences with them.

    Explain to me why you think only women make life worth living.
    In words?

    You lost me. Yes I think the Church is different from women.
    Catholics have the Theotokos, Mary, the Blessed Virgin. So the Church is not 'different', or 'set apart' from women. Women are an integral part of it.

    Also, being conservative has nothing to do with women.
    For me, again, it does. The conservatives that I look up to, many of them are women, and they have encouraged me and made me a better person, a better conservative and a better Catholic over the years.

    But why do you think I believe the Church has a conflict with women. You aren't being logical. Tell me in a logical way.
    You see women as not following the role appointed to them by God, ergo, there is a fundamental conflict between women in American culture and the church, which serves God.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X