Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    It's a myth, really truly it is.
    ...
    It's only rather later on with the Spanish Habsburgs that it got concentrated enough to be a problem.
    I claimed hereditary rule has an innate pressure to consolidate power by marrying close relations. It clearly does have such a pressure. I also claimed that there were many cases throughout history of incestuous royal marriages. That is also true.

    You claimed it was a myth ... then accepted that it was true. You're just ridiculous.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Your statement was unqualified. You claimed that "natural born citizen" could not apply to a citizen by birth born outside the US.
    I stated that the understanding at the time of the constitution was that there was a distinction for natural born citizens that applied to them being born inside the United States. I was able to show this through my earlier quote of one of the discussions surrounding the 14th Amendment. Which, naturally, sought to supercede the earlier standard of restricting citizenship based on race and replacing it with one based on the location where one was born.

    The Constitution does not defend discrimination on race, it does not say that only 'free men' are to be recognized in their God given rights. It says that all have been granted by God inalienable rights.

    It doesn't matter one iota what the specifics of the case
    So it matters not a whit that the law specifically excludes anyone who isn't white?

    The rest of the law is not applicable to the matter in question. It is clearly racist and misogynist, and you are clearly racist and misogynist, so it's not hard to see why you "understood their rationales".
    No. You believe that I am racist and misogynist. Those are two different things, Aeson.

    That you chose to focus on how "rational" the racist and misogynist aspects of the law were, rather than to accept that you were wrong about how "natural born citizen" was applied by the law, shows clearly how you'd rather be racist and misogynist than to admit a simple factual truth.
    Nonsense, I argue that the law you quoted did not uphold the constitution of the united states, and thus was superceded by the Fourteenth, which the Constitution anticipated. Of course, I say that because I believe that the Constitution protects the rights of everyone, not just Free white men.

    That being said, I'm curious why you're arguing the fallacy that only arguments you agree with are rational arguments.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    You are lying about my religion. Heck. I've got my own problems with it. I've got my own problems with my church. I'm an individual. I can know who I am. You don't know who you are BK. I don't know how your world view got so screwed up, It looks like you got brainwashed. You think you are inferior because of your gender and you hate men.
    So I hate men because I affirm the unique, and God-given dignity of women?

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Did I say I believed that was good? I said I understood their rationales. There's a difference. I can understand something without supporting it. The law is the law. You need to look at the law in it's entirety not just a portion of it.
    Your statement was unqualified. You claimed that "natural born citizen" could not apply to a citizen by birth born outside the US. Thus there is only one requirement for disproving it, to show that "natural born citizen" could apply in at least one case to a citizen by birth born outside the US. It doesn't matter one iota what the specifics of the case are, so long as it is applying "natural born citizen" to citizens by birth born outside the US. You are wrong no matter what the other specifics.

    The rest of the law is not applicable to the matter in question. It is clearly racist and misogynist, and you are clearly racist and misogynist, so it's not hard to see why you "understood their rationales". That you chose to focus on how "rational" the racist and misogynist aspects of the law were, rather than to accept that you were wrong about how "natural born citizen" was applied by the law, shows clearly how you'd rather be racist and misogynist than to admit a simple factual truth.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Because that's my charism, Kid. Men who feel that they have gotten the short end of the stick tend to harbor resentment.



    You might as well ask, "why are sunsets beautiful?" Words are inadequate.



    Because I was one and they despise Mary. They have bad theology when it comes to her and the position of women within the Church.



    The fact that I'm saved and will not go to hell because of them? Because of their kindness and support through some difficult periods of my life? Because they would invite me to lunch and tea? Women are not men, and thank God for that.



    No, but they brought me to Him. And for that I am grateful.



    We are not individuals, Kid. We are members of one Body, serving our Lord. This, again, is bad theology you have picked up.



    Yes, it does matter, Kidicious. We are men because God chose to make us men. Women are women because God chose to make them that way. This, again, is part of the reason why protestants have issues with other parts of their theology, specifically concerning the body and the purpose that God has for us in our lives.

    Women are supposed to be women, and you, and your church does not understand the beauty of this.



    That you accuse me of 'worshipping women', is what is wrong with your theology. You consider honoring women worshipping them, and we can appreciate them for who they are.

    You need to read your Bible, Kid. "He made them male and female".
    You are lying about my religion. Heck. I've got my own problems with it. I've got my own problems with my church. I'm an individual. I can know who I am. You don't know who you are BK. I don't know how your world view got so screwed up, It looks like you got brainwashed. You think you are inferior because of your gender and you hate men.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I can see why you want to pretend such a thing is good, since you are racist and misogynist.
    Did I say I believed that was good? I said I understood their rationales. There's a difference. I can understand something without supporting it. The law is the law. You need to look at the law in it's entirety not just a portion of it.

    The argument wasn't about whether it was a good law or not, but whether "natural born citizen" applied to those born outside the US.
    Then why are you arguing that I believed the law was good? Yes, it does - for white people only, which I suspect you find unacceptable.

    you were wrong to say that "natural born citizen" could not apply to anyone born outside the US
    You want to take part of the law and get rid of the rest of the law which I find curious. Again - the reason that was there was because they believed in retaining the culture of the United States, and that this was a proxy. Somehow I don't see you taking this desire into consideration when drafting a law today. Odd that.

    It is a natural pressure in hereditary rule to consolidate power through marriage to close relations. There are many cases throughout history of incestuous marriages within royal families.
    A little learning is a dangerous thing,
    Drink deep or taste not the pierian springs
    For shallow draughts intoxicate the brain
    And drinking largely sobers us again.

    It's a myth, really truly it is. The Tudors themselves are not inbred, because the Tudors had no relations to the Plantagenets. The Stuarts are not themselves inbred because they have relations with every single Scottish noble. None of the northern German families (Hohenzollern, etc), are inbred because they had quite a significant mix of families. There are only two lineages for which this sometimes comes into play.

    1. The house of Jimenez in Spain. And even then, you get quite a bit of outbreeding due to illegitimate lines. Really, all it takes is one every three generations or so. Trastamara was an illegitimate branch, so they had a concentration that was not particularly inbred with the rest of Europe.

    It's only rather later on with the Spanish Habsburgs that it got concentrated enough to be a problem.

    And then you have some of the Capetians particularly the Valois cadet branch, where you can get 8, or 9 of 16 as individual Capetians.

    For the Stuarts? Not an inbreeding problem in the slightest. If anything House Este was more inbred than they.
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 11, 2016, 07:11.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    However you said that 'many women want to stay at home' as a blanket statement.
    Yes. 47 percent of women staying at home with their children who are younger than 6 is an indication that many do want to stay at home. I did not say most. I said many. I'm not sure why that is controversial.

    The implication I draw from that is that you think that women in general would prefer to be housewives. Proteus picked up on it, pointing out that many of these mothers will resume their jobs.
    Did I say most?

    At least your sexism towards women is less strident than Kid's, but it's still there.
    Mhmm, I was surprised that number was as high as it was. So that should lead you to believe that I thought that number would be considerably less.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    So you're suggesting that they reserved natural born people to White people is not a significant concession?
    It is clearly racist and misogynist (since it was white males). I can see why you want to pretend such a thing is good, since you are racist and misogynist.

    You immediately dismissed the law as 'misogynist and racist', and yet would take part of it without the rest of it.
    The argument wasn't about whether it was a good law or not, but whether "natural born citizen" applied to those born outside the US.

    Mhmm, well I am pretty sure I understand their rationales and it still doesn't get you where you want to go.
    Where I want to go is to show that you were wrong to say that "natural born citizen" could not apply to anyone born outside the US. You argued we should try to stick to what the founders wanted.

    So the law of 1790 is as close as we can get to a legal definition of "natural born citizen" in regards to the founding of the US. And it clearly states that it can apply to someone born outside the US. You were wrong.

    Inbred?
    It is a natural pressure in hereditary rule to consolidate power through marriage to close relations. There are many cases throughout history of incestuous marriages within royal families.

    Leave a comment:


  • NICE MOBIUS
    replied
    Yes, your head hurts because Ben is making stuff up as usual.

    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Funny that Mobius considers women who stay at home 'misogynist.'
    Funny how I said absolutely nothing of the sort.

    However you said that 'many women want to stay at home' as a blanket statement. The implication I draw from that is that you think that women in general would prefer to be housewives. Proteus picked up on it, pointing out that many of these mothers will resume their jobs.

    At least your sexism towards women is less strident than Kid's, but it's still there.

    It would be interesting to see what the stats are for UK mothers, seeing as for the longest time the majority of nursery care was left up to market forces and therefore exorbitantly expensive.

    Leave a comment:


  • Egbert
    replied
    Can a woman be a misogynist?

    I guess so. seems odd though.

    Now my head hurts.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Funny that Mobius considers women who stay at home 'misogynist.'

    Leave a comment:


  • Proteus_MST
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    I'm surprised it's that high. If it's 47 percent, I'd argue that's pretty solid evidence that many women want to stay at home.
    Many of the stay at home moms will resume their jobs later when the kid goes to school.

    It just makes most sense during the first year of the life of a child, when a child needs most of the care, for one of the couple, sto stay at home.
    Escpecially as, in germany, it is hard work to get a place in a daycare center (which would be a necessity if both would want to work full time, despite the kid). I would guess that the percentage of stay at home moms (with a child between 0 and 6 years) in the USA also would rise, if there were more regulations (like minimum wages and tax cuts) that would make it economically viable for one of the couple to stay at home.

    Also one should add that the decision alone, to get a kid, already means a certain commitment to a family (unless the conception happened "by accident", of course)
    To add another percentage:
    20% of women in germany, between 40 and 44 years, have no children

    Which seems to be a clear indication that those women prefer(ed) career over raising a family
    Last edited by Proteus_MST; January 11, 2016, 06:33. Reason: Replaced Singular with Plural

    Leave a comment:


  • NICE MOBIUS
    replied


    Normal service is resumed.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    47 % of the mothers in germany with at least one child younger than 6 years are stay at home mothers without a job
    I'm surprised it's that high. If it's 47 percent, I'd argue that's pretty solid evidence that many women want to stay at home.

    Leave a comment:


  • NICE MOBIUS
    replied
    I think I've seen it all:

    Kid's misogyny is so bad that even Ben is jumping in to defend women's rights against him!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X