Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    No, I'm relying on examples of what other people, including the people who wrote the constitution at the time and what they had to say about this question.
    Maybe you should actually look at the laws that were enacted. If you want look at what was originally intended ... the first US Congress of 1790 passed applicable laws:



    FIRST CONGRESS. SESS. II. CH. 4. 1790.

    ... And the children of such persons so
    naturalized, dwelling- within the United States, being under the age of
    twenty-one years at the time of such naturalization, shall also be considered
    as citizens of the United States. And the children of citizens of
    the United States, that mayibe born beyond sea, or out of the limits of
    the United States, shall be considered as natural born citizens
    : Provided,
    That the right of citizenship shall not descend to persons whose fathers
    have never been resident in the United States: Provided also, That no
    person heretofore proscribed by any state, shall be admitted a citizen as
    aforesaid, except by an act of the legislature of the state in which such
    person was proscribed ...
    The simple fact is that "natural born citizens" was used in US legislation ... Yet you have claimed the exact opposite of what they legislated, while claiming you are speaking for the original intent.

    It's ridiculously stupid on your part.

    I like the concept of a republic, but I've always been a monarchist.
    ... again, ridiculously stupid on your part.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    What false dichotomy?
    "Naturalized!=Natural born."

    You've used this (and similar phrasing) several times when presented with the possibility that someone born outside the US is a natural born citizen. By conflating "naturalized" and "citizen by birth" you have created a false dichotomy.

    I've been using three terms. You've been using two.
    You are lying. I have used the terms "naturalized", "natural born citizens", and "citizens by birth".

    The three terms I've been using are:

    1. Natural born citizen = someone born in their country.
    2. Naturalized citizen = someone who acquires their citizenship through the process of naturalization.
    3. Born citizens = someone who is born a citizen of the US outside of the country.
    You only accepted 3 after I proved it, but have not yet recanted your positions you had taken previous to that proof which were promoting a false dichotomy of 1 and 2 by ignoring (and implicitly denying the existence of) 3.

    Leave a comment:


  • C0ckney
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    IMO, he's the best. Cruz is second. Both are great candidates, I just wish Cruz were not a Canadian citizen. Then I'd probably be working for his campaign. I have a copy of a letter I wrote him in 2010, and he actually had the courtesy to reply to me. I have nothing against Cruz the man, it's just the constitution (which I have to teach), is pretty clear on this.
    he's polling at about 1% nationally, stuck in the 'undercard' debates, and has to compete with a much more popular candidate for the hardcore religious vote. it doesn't look very good for him. who will you back, considering that you think cruz shouldn't be running, once he drops out?

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    There was nothing the child did to change their circumstances, but due to the actions of others changes their status. It suggests to me that this form of citizenship is more ephemeral.
    This is another ridiculous attempt to define a delineation which is not used to determine anything legally. It's even more ridiculous because it doesn't delineate between anything if it were to be used. The simple fact is that EVERY PERSON BORN A US CITIZEN could have had their citizenship affected this way. My parents could have renounced their citizenship and gave birth to me in a different country. Not only doesn't it delineate between US citizens, it doesn't delineate between anyone, anywhere, at any time in history. Your mom could have snuck into the US to give birth to you, thus affecting your citizenship status. It's completely meaningless.

    What matters is what did happen. Not what could have happened.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    BK hates the Constitution. This is why only natural born citizens should be president.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    And that's my point, Aeson. Natural Born citizenship cannot be lost this way.
    No. Your claim that they could lose their citizenship was simply wrong. Either they meet the requirements for citizenship at birth, or they don't. Those that meet the requirements are US citizens at birth, and can only lose it if they renounce it. Those who are not US citizens at birth cannot lose their citizenship because they don't have it to lose.

    This was your "point":

    "Citizenship through parents is not Natural Born citizenship, because it is possible for it to be lost depending on the status of the parents at the time, and whether the mother had resided in the US for at least a year."

    It is simply wrong. It is not possible for it to be lost. Either you have it, or you don't.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    His mother's birth certificate has been publicised. The only birther left is BK and Trump.
    Last edited by Kidlicious; January 10, 2016, 09:31.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    As for Cruz would we be having this discussion if his family stayed in Calgary?
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 10, 2016, 07:58.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I like Cruz. I would totally be his favoritist fan forever if he were running for our Prime Minister. I really, really want to be able to take the Kidicious argument and just 'handwave' things away for expediency.

    But, I'm not Kid and I'm not Cruz. Constitution comes first, even when it would benefit myself that it would not.

    Leave a comment:


  • ricketyclik
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Because I'm prejudiced against Canadians?
    Jeez, I don't know why they're suggesting it. Hell, I'm prejudiced against prejudice, so who am I to judge?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    No it wouldn't. You're just ignoring the reality that there are other ways that "natural born citizen" can be defined that also require the clause.
    No, I'm relying on examples of what other people, including the people who wrote the constitution at the time and what they had to say about this question. They continued to assert the issues with a monarchy when the monarchy was governed by Germans and foreigners from outside the country, who did not speak the language of the people they claimed to govern. They contrasted this with a republic which would be governed by a citizen born within the country and the ideal of responsible representation. For them it was an issue of representation, they believed that only those who spoke their language and shared their heritage could adequately govern their republic.

    Personally, I sympathise with their issues, but consider their issues self-inflicted due to their own prejudice. They had a dynasty that they deliberately brought in foreign influence, and later complain about unintended consequences after specifically choosing Sophia.

    I am not a republican. I like the concept of a republic, but I've always been a monarchist. I'm not so much defending my own principles, but the principles that the founders themselves articulated. It makes sense to me why they wanted this even if I disagree with the justifications and how they arrived at this answer.

    It is not possible to "lose" citizenship that way. What you are describing is a situation where someone NEVER HAD US CITIZENSHIP
    And that's my point, Aeson. Natural Born citizenship cannot be lost this way. If some people can 'lose' their claim to citizenship through their parents because their parents never resided in the country for more than a year, then that suggests to me that there is a significant difference between citizenship acquired abroad through ones parents and natural born citizenship.

    There was nothing the child did to change their circumstances, but due to the actions of others changes their status. It suggests to me that this form of citizenship is more ephemeral.

    Someone who was born a US citizen in this way can only "lose" it in the same way that every other US citizen can lose it ... by renouncing it. So if we're going to use "can lose US citizenship" as a litmus test, there are no natural born citizens of the US!
    One, losing your citizenship is not the same as renouncing your citizenship. You don't lose what you don't want.

    Two, not all countries even permit you to renounce and in the UK, you can choose to restore your citizenship. Reason being that your natural born status within the country does not really change.

    That is only for case G. There are several other cases.
    Indeed, and all of them have contingencies, etc. It's a much different relationship.

    Naturalized!=Natural born."
    Yes, and? This is entirely true.

    "You cannot be a natural born American if you have to be naturalized."
    Same as this.

    "If it were possible to acquire natural born citizenship through naturalization, this process would be unnecessary."
    Again, this is true.

    The reason why these fit is because you were using "naturalization" as the only possible alternative to being born on US soil.
    Where did I say that? I've been using three terms. You've been using two.

    The three terms I've been using are:

    1. Natural born citizen = someone born in their country.
    2. Naturalized citizen = someone who acquires their citizenship through the process of naturalization.
    3. Born citizens = someone who is born a citizen of the US outside of the country.

    These are similar things but not the same and I've been discussing the differences between all three.

    You still are promoting that false dichotomy.
    What false dichotomy? The laws are different for those born abroad from those born in the United States. Ergo, I conclude that they are different because the laws for them are different.

    Thus all your statements were denying the obvious reality that citizenship by birth is possible for those born outside the US.
    I never said that. I said that one cannot be a natural born citizen if one is born outside of the united states.
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 10, 2016, 07:43.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Are people here suggesting Ben is a maladjusted, misanthropic, dissimulating, racist sh!t? Say it ain't so!
    Because I'm prejudiced against Canadians? I'm not sure what race has to do with it? I like Jindal very much.

    Leave a comment:


  • ricketyclik
    replied
    Are people here suggesting Ben is a maladjusted, misanthropic, dissimulating, racist sh!t? Say it ain't so!

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    If it were possible to acquire natural born citizenship through naturalization, this process would be unnecessary.
    No it wouldn't. You're just ignoring the reality that there are other ways that "natural born citizen" can be defined that also require the clause.

    Citizenship through parents is not Natural Born citizenship, because it is possible for it to be lost depending on the status of the parents at the time, and whether the mother had resided in the US for at least a year.
    It is not possible to "lose" citizenship that way. What you are describing is a situation where someone NEVER HAD US CITIZENSHIP due to not meeting the requirements for citizenship. You cannot lose something you never had.

    Someone who was born a US citizen in this way can only "lose" it in the same way that every other US citizen can lose it ... by renouncing it. So if we're going to use "can lose US citizenship" as a litmus test, there are no natural born citizens of the US!

    And even that is contingent on being born post 1952.
    That is only for case G. There are several other cases.

    Then feel free to quote me where I said this. I did not.
    "*sigh*. Naturalized!=Natural born."
    "You cannot be a natural born American if you have to be naturalized."
    "If it were possible to acquire natural born citizenship through naturalization, this process would be unnecessary."
    "If it were possible to become a natural born citizen through the process of naturalization, this clause would be wholly unnecessary."

    The reason why these fit is because you were using "naturalization" as the only possible alternative to being born on US soil. You still are promoting that false dichotomy. Thus all your statements were denying the obvious reality that citizenship by birth is possible for those born outside the US.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Stop lying. You claimed with a blanket statement that all such births not on American soil were "naturalization". They are not, they are actually US citizens by birth.
    Then feel free to quote me where I said this. I did not.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X