Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    That is not my answer. My answer was that there was no US to be born a citizen to for anyone older than the US. This is true regardless of how you define "natural born citizen" as long as "born a citizen" is required.
    If it were possible to acquire natural born citizenship through naturalization, this process would be unnecessary. That is my point. It was grandfathered because the understanding of natural born citizenship at the time required one to be born within the country.

    Citizenship through parents is not Natural Born citizenship, because it is possible for it to be lost depending on the status of the parents at the time, and whether the mother had resided in the US for at least a year. And even that is contingent on being born post 1952.

    The mother had previously been physically present in the United States or one of its outlying possessions for a continuous period of at least one year.
    There are two general ways to obtain citizenship through U.S. citizen parents: at birth, and after birth but before the age of 18. Congress has enacted laws that determine how citizenship is conveyed by a U.S. citizen parent to children born outside of the United States. The law in effect at the time of birth determines whether someone born outside the United States to a U.S. citizen parent is a U.S. citizen at birth. In general, these laws require that at least one parent was a U.S. citizen, and the U.S. citizen parent had lived in the United States for a period of time.


    So, again. I'm not seeing the whole natural born citizenship argument here for Cruz.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    No one is questioning that all of those categories are those who would be considered citizens of the united states at birth.
    Stop lying. You claimed with a blanket statement that all such births not on American soil were "naturalization". They are not, they are actually US citizens by birth.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Not at all. As you stated, "the only natural born citizens at that point would be children". And why? because you had to be born in the territory of the United States to be considered to be natural born citizens.
    That is not my answer. My answer was that there was no US to be born a citizen to for anyone older than the US. This is true regardless of how you define "natural born citizen" as long as "born a citizen" is required.

    If it were possible to become a natural born citizen through the process of naturalization, this clause would be wholly unnecessary.
    Strawman. No naturalization needed.

    Which the constitution does not say. Can you see anywhere where this is stated, within the constitution of the United States?
    Hypocrisy. "Soil" isn't mentioned anywhere either.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Well, then. Have at it. Show me the constitutionality of your position.

    My constitutional support is that there is no reference to "soil" anywhere in it.
    And I've provided a quote from the congressional debate over the 14th amendment indicating that Natural Born Citizenship excluded those subject to foreign sovereignty, which automatically excludes 'dual citizens' born outside of the US, like Ted Cruz.

    I have yet to find a single citation concerning natural born citizenship prior to 2005 advocating your position.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    I did support. You've conceded that your argument has no constitutional support. I've read the arguments, and remain unconvinced by their provenance.
    I conceded nothing. Liar.

    My constitutional support is that there is no reference to "soil" anywhere in it.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    You said you only teach what's in the constitution, I challenged. You failed to support. I have nothing to prove.
    I did support. You've conceded that your argument has no constitutional support. I've read the arguments, and remain unconvinced by their provenance.

    [I] find no fault with the introductory clause [S 61 Bill], which is simply declaratory of what is written in the Constitution, that every human being born within the jurisdiction of the United States of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty is, in the language of your Constitution itself, a natural born citizen…[6]
    Rep John Bingham of Ohio. March 9th 1866. My bolds.

    Cruz was born in Canada and so is a natural born Canadian citizen, and a subject of the Queen.
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 10, 2016, 05:58.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    So, if there's nothing in the constitution supporting you, I rest my case.
    You said you only teach what's in the constitution. I challenged. You failed to support. I have nothing to prove. You do.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Back at yer!
    If there's nothing in the constitution supporting you, I rest my case.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Aeson, your link doesn't actually state, "naturally born citizen". No one is questioning that all of those categories are those who would be considered citizens of the united states at birth. However, Natural Born citizenship is different. By definition you cannot hold two of these, and the reason it was in the constitution is to ensure that those elected to the highest office of the land did not have foreign connections. At the time, it was fairly common for people to be governed by those who were not born in the country, particularly in the Spain (by a King in the Low countries and in Austria), and in Russia (by a German). The Americans did not want foreign domination of their government and wanted to ensure that their chief executive was an American.

    By definition, Cruz is a natural born Canadian citizen. Same as me.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post

    This is simpleton logic.



    Which the constitution does not say. Can you see anywhere where this is stated, within the constitution of the United States? No.
    Back at yer!

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Berz, I checked your link, it does not source any of the statements.

    link to the section of the constitution of the United States which defines citizens and natural born citizens.
    Except, all it does is make a 'bald faced assertion' without actually citing the law, and providing a link to the actual law involved.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    No. It is the refutation of your moronic point
    Not at all. As you stated, "the only natural born citizens at that point would be children". And why? because you had to be born in the territory of the United States to be considered to be natural born citizens.

    If it were possible to become a natural born citizen through the process of naturalization, this clause would be wholly unnecessary. The reason that this clause was inserted is to grandfather those born in other countries prior to the formation of the United States.

    This is simple logic.

    It would, if (as it does) having citizenship by birth requires having US citizen parent(s). There were no US citizens to be parents for anyone old enough to hold office either.
    Which the constitution does not say. Can you see anywhere where this is stated, within the constitution of the United States? No.

    Leave a comment:


  • Egbert
    replied
    I am very worried.

    I see my thread on epistemology has fallen on deaf ideas.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Don't worry Braindead, Ben will come up with enough bald-faced assertions and strawmen to cover for those lapses and many more...

    Leave a comment:


  • Egbert
    replied
    Good grief. Now Aeson is also quoting the applicable laws of the USA. Where will this end?

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X