Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • kentonio
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    She was promised to him in marriage prior to the massacre. Which is my point.

    Glad to see you've conceded that by acknowledging that the contract was already written.
    You shamelessly dishonest bastard.

    She was promised to Alexios, the boy who Andronikos forced to share power with him and then had murdered. The fact that the King of France then had no problems with her marrying Andronikos, the man in power at the time of the massacre shows exactly the kind of priorities Kings had at the time.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bereta_Eder
    replied
    The question never was why you believe what you believe.
    Noone cares.

    The question was why are you so ****ed up.

    Byzantines and crusaders don't interest anyoone anymore, it's just a vehicle for you to describe your complete lack of empathy.

    Similar attempts to try and blame the victim (with always money on your mind) seem to be your stance in life. It manifests a complete lack of empathy and makes you certaintly NOT a catholic.

    Oh well
    here's a nice song of celtic music by serbians

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Personally I felt more at home with Baptists and evangelicals and Catholics than I did with Anglicans. I see that as the great divide, even within the denominations for Lutherans and Presbyterians now.

    There are not a great deal of beliefs that every Protestant shares in common.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Re-baptism is a big deal. Re-baptism is saying infant baptism doesn't count. I don't see how you can lump churches that don't re-baptize with those who do, and churches that have persecuted other churches with churches that have been persecuted.
    Re-baptism wasn't an issue for the first five ecumenical councils because it wasn't practiced then. Same argument vis-a-vis the blessed sacrament, and transubstantiation. If you want to accept all the church councils, you won't be a protestant. If you don't you can't exclude others who also reject the later councils.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    My definition of a protestant is any group that accepts the first five ecumenical councils, but none of the rest, even if they don't know what an ecumenical council is, or understand where their theology comes from.

    Mennonites meet that definition, as do Anglicans, Lutherans, Calvinists, etc. Orthodox are a different group, as are the earlier non-Chalcedonian Christians.

    This definition excludes the Witnesses and the Mormons.
    Re-baptism is a big deal. Re-baptism is saying infant baptism doesn't count. I don't see how you can lump churches that don't re-baptize with those who do, and churches that have persecuted other churches with churches that have been persecuted.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    So you wanted to join a religion that despised Anglicans and you wanted to call yourself a protestant?
    My definition of a protestant is any group that accepts the first five ecumenical councils, but none of the rest, even if they don't know what an ecumenical council is, or understand where their theology comes from.

    Mennonites meet that definition, as do Anglicans, Lutherans, Calvinists, etc. Orthodox are a different group, as are the earlier non-Chalcedonian Christians.

    This definition excludes the Witnesses and the Mormons.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Because protestants were moral cesspools? Yes, I'm aware of their persecution of Mennonites. If you wanted a religion that despised Anglicans, that was a good faith to practice.

    Mennonites would argue that they were the real protestants, and that Anglicans in particular had become corrupt.
    So you wanted to join a religion that despised Anglicans and you wanted to call yourself a protestant?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I'm not sure why you call people protestants who were rejected by protestants. Can you explain that?
    Well, gee. Given that Luther strapped them and burnt them I would have to argue it's because Mennonites practiced the faith that Lutherans did not.

    As a Catholic, it's not great shakes to point out that divisions among protestants are a natural consequence of division from the Body of Christ.

    Mennonites would argue that they were the real protestants, and that Anglicans in particular had become corrupt. In the sense that they believed what Christ taught. They are also Nestorians, which is why I left when I realized that Menno Simons taught heresy concerning the nature of God. It's one thing to become Catholic because you are convinced it is true, another to leave your church because it teaches heresy.

    That was my life from late 2003 to early 2005 or so, coming to grips with this. Conversion isn't an instant process. You can see some of my early thoughts here.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Personally, if the question is, "why does BK believe what he believes" I have to take a look at the people who have made a real contribution to my life. Many of them are Catholics who have treated me well.

    Apolyton I credit with driving me further to the right (I was a centrist when I first came on here), and showing me the errors of my ways. So many polytubbies have shown me that the way was not with the angry, bitter *******s who pucker up when someone cries the word, "novena". Who go out of their way to treat me like a piece of crap just because they disagree with me.

    There's no better way to convert a fellow classical liberal than to treat him like dirt.

    Apolyton is a fantastic apostolate to the Way. I must give you folks full credit for driving me into the arms of His Church.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    *sigh*. I was an Anglican before that. And yes, Mennonites are followers of Menno Simon. They are Anabaptists, which are distinct from Calvinists, et al, but they are protestants too. You really need to read up on them.
    I'm not sure why you call people protestants who were rejected by protestants. Can you explain that?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    If he truly had faith in his beliefs, he wouldn't be so desperate to find historical links to back them up.
    The facts speak for themselves. I had once thought that the Catholics were ultimately culpable for the Fourth Crusade. When I read into the matter further, my opinion on this changed. This was all after my conversion, btw.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I'm saying he didn't really care, especially as the wave of violence helped sweep him into power.
    So what you're saying is that he was an accessory to ethnic cleansing which he supported insofar as it brought him to power.

    He was a total *******
    Indeed. And that's my point.

    Which didn't happen, because no-one gave a **** about 'innocent lives' back then, they cared about money and power. The popes as much (if not more) than everyone else.
    Uh, they cared a great deal about massacres of their fellow believers. See, Church of the Holy Sepulchre which touched off that whole First Crusade, era.

    The ceremony took place in the Trullo Hall, in the Great Palace, on 2 March 1180 That was her betrothal or wedding to Alexios you uneducated idiot (she was 8 years old at the time, which says a lot about Christian values back then). She married Andronikos in 1183, a year AFTER the massacre.
    She was promised to him in marriage prior to the massacre. Which is my point.

    Glad to see you've conceded that by acknowledging that the contract was already written.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    You were a Mennonite. Most Mennonites don't call themselves protestant. I don't call myself a protestant either, btw.
    *sigh*. I was an Anglican before that. And yes, Mennonites are followers of Menno Simon. They are Anabaptists, which are distinct from Calvinists, et al, but they are protestants too. You really need to read up on them.
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 20, 2016, 00:38.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    "So, I get locked out of my house, hire a locksmith to let me back in, but as soon as he does he rapes my wife and takes all my stuff. I am at fault in this scenario?" His response: "After you refuse to pay him? Yes."
    The analogy would be:

    1, it's not your house. You have stolen someone else's house.

    2, you get locked out by your brother to whom the house does not belong, who steals the house from you.

    3, you decide to go get a locksmith, promising to pay him for his work.

    4, the locksmith comes in, has to evict your brother, he changes all the locks for you.

    5, your brother goes and brings a bunch of his friends back with him.

    6, the locksmith doesn't want to deal with this bull**** anymore and asks to be paid.

    7, you can't pay the locksmith so you decide to rob your neighbors to pay the locksmith, but even then you are short.

    8, your brother's friends come back to take possession. You, being hooped decided to ask the locksmith to help you protect the house.

    9, the locksmith agrees to help you.. for a price. You agree.

    10, the locksmith shoots your brother's friends.

    11, you go to the neighbor again and rob him to try to pay the locksmith his agreed on price. You're still short.

    12, the locksmith, tired of the bull**** decides to take the house that you stole from you, (since you don't have title), he kicks out your family and puts you on the street, taking everything you have. He also steals from your neighbors.

    13, the neighbors come to the locksmith looking for you. They find you, you get hung in the street.

    There's no good guys in this story, least of all Andronikos, who stole from the treasury, stole from the people, stole from the Crusaders, and stole and killed his own brother. And in the end, ended up dead.

    There is always a price to be paid for evil deeds. Andronikos paid for his, and the Empire suffered because of it. Had Andronikos not sought out the crusaders, had he accepted the deposition, had he done pretty much anything else, it would have had a different result.

    Yes, the Crusaders could have said no. But do you blame the one selling evil or the one choosing to participate? You are right that the Crusaders are morally culpable for their choices, but so were the Byzantines.
    Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 20, 2016, 00:37.

    Leave a comment:


  • -Jrabbit
    replied
    Oh no, that part is clearly performed live.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X