Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
So how long will Ben last this time?
Collapse
X
-
Short answer, Ranke is not a follower of Rousseau, but of Hobbes. He is a conservative German monarchist protestant. You might like him. He's a bit out of favor with me now, I found his history of the Catholic church was not that well done. There are better histories, and his is not bad if you have a can of white-out handy.Last edited by Ben Kenobi; January 30, 2016, 19:21.
-
Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostAlso, I have a request, Kidicious, can you take the time to please look up von Ranke?-wikiIn his 1833 article "The Great Powers" and his 1836 article "Dialogue on Politics", Ranke claimed that every state is given a special moral character from God and individuals should strive to best fulfill the "idea" of their state. Thus, in this way, Ranke urged his readers to stay loyal to the Prussian state and reject the ideas of the French Revolution, which Ranke claimed were meant for France only.[citation needed]
You'll have to explain
Leave a comment:
-
No. You are confusing the current state of progress with his absolute truth. He believed that progress is leading us to the absolute truth. And that's the same way anyone believes that believes studying history objectively gives us absolute truth, because as time passes more data is accumulated. As time passes philosophers and theologians can think of concepts that more accurately represent absolute truth. But it doesn't work that way. A person in the first century can know the absolute truth to the same degree that a person living in this century can know the absolute truth. 2,000 years of history has not brought us to know the absolute truth more.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostThe dialectic is contrary to absolute truth because it argues that any truth in which we presently apprehend can be improved through progress. Thesis, antithesis and synthesis.
No. That wouldn't be a solution. That would only make us able to know historical facts with more reliability. But it's not the historical facts that are really important. We would know that Jesus died on the cross. We would know that he performed miracles. But we would still not know that everything he said is the truth. We would not know that if we followed Him we would gain eternal life.Well, the solution would be data recorders on a time machine, but the next best thing are primary sources.
Absolutely not. Neitzsche is not the only person who relied on what he believed subjectively. The Bible says that Abraham acted on faith, not on what he knew objectively.As to abandoning all objective thinking, again, Neitzsche is the only alternative.
That's not objective. That makes no sense.The alternative isn't to discard the principle of objectivity, but rather to throw out everything as false.
Leave a comment:
-
Also, I have a request, Kidicious, can you take the time to please look up von Ranke?
Leave a comment:
-
The dialectic is contrary to absolute truth because it argues that any truth in which we presently apprehend can be improved through progress. Thesis, antithesis and synthesis.Hegel believed in absolute truth, and he took an objective approach to finding it.
Well, the solution would be data recorders on a time machine, but the next best thing are primary sources. As to abandoning all objective thinking, again, Neitzsche is the only alternative. The alternative isn't to discard the principle of objectivity, but rather to throw out everything as false.The best you could say is that it's an approximation of the truth. I would still disagree with you though. My belief is that those who look for truth in that way won't find it. They will only find it when they abandon all objective thinking.
Leave a comment:
-
Hegel believed in absolute truth, and he took an objective approach to finding it. He did exactly as you do. The problem is that you can't find absolute truth that way. The best you could say is that it's an approximation of the truth. I would still disagree with you though. My belief is that those who look for truth in that way won't find it. They will only find it when they abandon all objective thinking.Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostI'm not a Hegelian because I'm an objectivist, in the sense that I believe in absolute truth. My school of history is von Ranke's school, and he argues for an empirical basis for History. Everything we know ought to be based on sources in the past and if we cannot find a source for it, we cannot assert that there's any truth for it.
I also came to the conclusion that the bible is a much more reliable source than every other ancient source that we have due to the number and the date of the manuscripts.
That being said, in a sense you are right. We don't have a time machine. We have to rely on sources, so there is always going to be some uncertainty. But, it's the alternative of Neitzsche, where we reject everything. I'm not prepared to go that far, which is why I'm a Christian.
Leave a comment:
-
I'm not a Hegelian because I'm an objectivist, in the sense that I believe in absolute truth. My school of history is von Ranke's school, and he argues for an empirical basis for History. Everything we know ought to be based on sources in the past and if we cannot find a source for it, we cannot assert that there's any truth for it.This view seems almost Hegelian. Have you ever heard of Lessing's Ugly Ditch?
I also came to the conclusion that the bible is a much more reliable source than every other ancient source that we have due to the number and the date of the manuscripts.
That being said, in a sense you are right. We don't have a time machine. We have to rely on sources, so there is always going to be some uncertainty. But, it's the alternative of Neitzsche, where we reject everything. I'm not prepared to go that far, which is why I'm a Christian.
Leave a comment:
-
This view seems almost Hegelian. Have you ever heard of Lessing's Ugly Ditch?Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View PostIf you don't understand your history you do not understand who you are.
http://gewissensbisse.blogspot.com/2...-theology.htmlThe basic idea of the problem is that there can be no "necessary" truths based on "contingent" events. In other words, the ditch is trying to jump from contingent happenings (i.e. historical revelation) to truth that is necessary (i.e., divine revelation). How can one assert the ultimate truth of something that is particular, that happens just at one time and one time only?
This is the problem with trying to find ultimate truth through history. History doesn't reveal ultimate truth.
Leave a comment:
-
Ben can't do anything right. Now we'll have 20 posts of him trying to weasel out of this meaningless error.
Leave a comment:
-
I have post number 1000. You, sadly have reply number 1000. They are not the same.You can't do that properly...
Leave a comment:
-
Too true. There's no recovering from that kind of beatdown. Ben should just leave the forum forever and hope he is forgotten.Originally posted by Bereta_Eder View PostYou tried to claim there was some sort of morality but there really isn't.
Kentonio proved, without a doubt, how indifferent the rulers of that time were about what was going on.
He also slam dunked you against the wall using your own faith by proving that you are actually in dissarey with the catholic church on this.
I think it's plain as day.
Damn.
Kentonio for president
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: