Originally posted by Dr Strangelove
View Post
Post-coup Italy was not managed solely by Nazis. It needed Italian support to function. Those Italians that contributed to Nazism's reign in Italy were directly complicit in the murder of Italian Jewish citizens.
The main point here is that Bergen Belsen wasn't run by Arabs, it was run by the Germans. Arabs had absolutely nothing to do with Bergen Belsen.
Arabs may not have organised and established Bergen Belsen but many called for and participated in the Holocaust. Most stayed silent. None enlisted to fight against Nazism. (By contrast many Israeli Jews did and established their own brigade in the British army.)
There is another point to be made. Bergen Belsen wasn't the whole of the Holocaust. The Holocaust was composed not merely of extermination campaigns. It involved the dehumanisation of the Jews by any method. Theft, assault, riots, were the first recourses. Ghettos, next. Then deportation to concentration camps, or death camps. Some Arabs contributed to those elements of the Holocaust in examples already mentioned above.
Further, Arab treatment of Jews post-WW2 involved many of these very tactics. These were deliberately employed to expel Jews from Arab lands.
This Arab treatment of Jews stretches well into the 50's s and even to the present today in the case of the few remaining Jews in the Arab world. The few Yemeni Jews who remained recently in Yemen were subjected to similar treatment prior to their flight from Yemen to the United States and Israel.
My main point does not even strictly depend on Arab treatment of Jews during WW2 (though that certainly contributes to the context). It is this--
The notion that "good avertising" was the cause of Jewish emigration from the Arab states is not convincing. Of course Sephardi Jews went to Israel and were encouraged to do so, but they were happy to go pretty much anywhere except their former homes in the Middle East. The only place where Sephardi Jews -aren't- living in anymore in large numbers is the Middle East. The estimated number of total Jews in the Middle East in 2008 according to Wikipedia (and leaving aside Israel) is 6,400. In 1948 it was anywhere between 700,000-900,000. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_...slim_countries
If this is the quality of Israeli propaganda then we can seriously consider discounting the rest.
I would not counsel you to treat any propaganda seriously.
Originally posted by Felch
View Post
Comment