A Game of Thrones - TV Show Discussion Thread

[Demonbinder]

I don't think the wall will fall, at least in the TV show. Looks like they are going around it. I also found it hard to believe Euron could build so many ships because I couldn't figure where he would get the wood for it. Plus, where were the look outs for the fleet he first defeated?? I think Sam's brother will survive so Sam can be Maester of whoever ends up on Iron Throne. Can't wait for the final showdown between the Mountain and his brother.

[Lorizael]

If the wall falls...

...will iron thrones, night watches, and maesters even matter anymore?

[Dry]

Maesters take an oath of celibacy, but unlike the Night's watch, clearly not one of chastity.

Qyburn is an ex-maester that has been stripped of his chain, so it seems they can be expelled from the order. Logic would suggest that if they can be expelled, they are also allowed to resign.

[Cort Haus]

http://mashable.com/2017/07/22/euron.../#jQLryTmMeaqw

Nice. I knew the fleet was wrong, but good that someone crunched the numbers.

[pchang]

Are maesters allowed to have a wife and kids?

[Dry]

If he becomes maester, he will be bound by another set of similar vows.
In order for him to become lord of Horn Hill, he'll need to give up his studies.

If the wall falls (Shaka) and the night watch is thus dissolved, I pretty much see him Grand Maester in the Small Council, advising whoever sits on the iron throne.

[Dinner]

I wonder what Samwell Tarley will do after his father and brother get killed along with the rest of the Lannister forces next episode. The Night's Watch is going to be finished soon so it is not like an oath to a dead organization is any oath at all. He might as well just take up being the new lord of horn hill.

[BeBMan]

Of course - to add some history nerdism - numbers in ancient or medieval sources are often (not always tho) shady, for various reasons. And while GoT is fantasy is builds a lot on medieval topics.

There numbers could be "propaganda" (for various reasons, for example to downplay own losses in a battle), simply lack of knowledge about any real numbers, or have primarily symbolic meaning so that XXXX means more something like "a whole lot"

[Proteus_MST]

Spoiler:

Well, how sneaky can a 1,000 fleet be?

Speaking of which: http://mashable.com/2017/07/22/euron.../#jQLryTmMeaqw

Spoiler:

Realistically speaking surely not sneaky enough to surprise another fleet the way that Eurons fleet did with the one of Ellaria during last weeks episode. EDven if we take into account the fog and the night, one would have to say that this would have affected Eurons ships the same way as Yaras ships.But for the general visibility of Eurons fleet, I guess that depends on how near to the coast he actually sails.

As for the link: IO totally agree, I actually mentioned the same counterargument to him, building 1000 ships, i.e., because he would lack the wood. There actually is a fine example: The italian pensinsula. Before roman times it still had lots of woods. Nowadays it is scarecly wooded, reason being that the romans needed lots of wood for shipbuilding. Therefore it is rather unimaginable how he would procure enough wood from his rocky islands

[Dry]

Spoiler:

Only against ships they can see

The attack against both fleets was a surprise attack (actually Dany doesn't know about the secnd surprise attack by now) ... and in order to actively search and destroy Eurons fleet, it fist has to be found ... and it is a very long coastline which Dany would have to search. ...

Spoiler:

Well, how sneaky can a 1,000 fleet be?

Speaking of which: http://mashable.com/2017/07/22/euron.../#jQLryTmMeaqw

[Dinner]

Well, if...

Spoiler:

... she is dead, it just makes you wonder, once again, what they were even trying to do with the Dorne plot.

My guess is the dorne plot in the books will be way more complex will probably involve (f)Aegon so D&D felt they had to include some of it some how but they cut out all of those parts of the book so there really wasn't much to work into the television show.

[Proteus_MST]

Spoiler:

Dany can keep out of range at high altitude while directing the other dragons to go down and wipe out Euron's ships. As for the logistics of searching a large coast line, that would not have been necessary. After the first attack, it would be obvious that you would need to protect your other naval force. You don't have to find Euron. He would have come to you.

Spoiler:

Dany only learned from the attack a long time after it had happened (after all, the few surviving shps first had to make the way back to Dragonstone). Meanwhile the fleet of Grey Worm already was on its travel for several days and Dany had too much to do (doing diplomatic negotiations with Jon Snow) than to have the time to follow the fleet, just for the pure suspicion that Euron might come after the 2nd half of the fleeet as well.
(and actually, considering the lead of several days that grey worms fleet had, it is not very believable that Eurons fleet (with Euron first going back to Kings landing in order to have is triumph) was able to arrive at Casterly Rock just in time to destroy Grey Worms Fleet, when he had conquered the castle)

[pchang]

Spoiler:

Dany can keep out of range at high altitude while directing the other dragons to go down and wipe out Euron's ships. As for the logistics of searching a large coast line, that would not have been necessary. After the first attack, it would be obvious that you would need to protect your other naval force. You don't have to find Euron. He would have come to you.

[Proteus_MST]

I have to ask again where are the dragons? They should be devastating against wooden sailing ships.

Spoiler:

Only against ships they can see

The attack against both fleets was a surprise attack (actually Dany doesn't know about the secnd surprise attack by now) ... and in order to actively search and destroy Eurons fleet, it fist has to be found ... and it is a very long coastline which Dany would have to search. ... and I am quite sure that dragons won't be able to fly 24/7, but will have to land and/or eat every couple of hours (making Dany quite vulnerable during this time)
Also, Tyrion and Missandei already advise against Dany oing on a earch and destroy mission, because they fear that she (as dragonrider) will be quite vunerable against arrows getting shot from the ships

[pchang]

I have to ask again where are the dragons? They should be devastating against wooden sailing ships.