His issue is this "has left me with pretty high standards for things like use of language, structure, complexity of themes and characters, etc., and that's where most genre fiction falls down." and I agree that a lot of SF/F fails in this regard. This includes a lot of what you recommend and like in other threads.
For the four authors I have named though, they have all written books with excellent use of language, structure and very complex themes and characters. Actually, in that list, I would rank Gene Wolfe the highest overall with Dan Simmons the lowest (his books other than Hyperion that I have read were far weaker) with regards to those four issues.
I agree that the settings/ideas that Gene Wolfe, Bujold, and Ian Banks (in his sci fi novels) use are very SF/F, that doesn't mean that they have the failings that Rufus is concerned about. I also have strong doubts that you have read everything of Gene Wolfe.
JM
(Please note that probably of the four my biggest recommendation would be Ian Banks mainstream novels as you wouldn't have any SF/F contamination to worry about)
(Obviously I don't think Gene Wolfe gets enough love.)
For the four authors I have named though, they have all written books with excellent use of language, structure and very complex themes and characters. Actually, in that list, I would rank Gene Wolfe the highest overall with Dan Simmons the lowest (his books other than Hyperion that I have read were far weaker) with regards to those four issues.
I agree that the settings/ideas that Gene Wolfe, Bujold, and Ian Banks (in his sci fi novels) use are very SF/F, that doesn't mean that they have the failings that Rufus is concerned about. I also have strong doubts that you have read everything of Gene Wolfe.
JM
(Please note that probably of the four my biggest recommendation would be Ian Banks mainstream novels as you wouldn't have any SF/F contamination to worry about)
(Obviously I don't think Gene Wolfe gets enough love.)
Comment