Goddamn Indians are ruining American Idol!

[Drake Tungsten]

And Sanjaya is bothering me less an less since even he knows it's a joke now.

I feel the same. I couldn't stand him when he was both untalented and boring, but he's alright now that he's merely untalented.

Remember David Cassedy and Michael Jackson? Talent, bah!

Yeah, Michael Jackson didn't have any talent...

[MRT144]

Originally posted by b etor


WHO?! I don't watch the show. I only watched the YouTubes with him.


All her songs are not like that. I love her music too!



SING FOR ME

you have terrible taste in music which isnt surprising, considering gender and age.

[b etor]

I love tons of music. I have a fabulous taste tycm. And you STILL are ignoring my command for you to sing for me!

[padillah]

Originally posted by Flubber


My opinion is the same in that I think Melinda is the best singer there. My views on the others -- I'll use my descriptions for them since I think it gives more of a flavor than their names

nice backup singer girl-- da bomb
rocker chick-- liking her more and more-- she is way better than my initial impression
Bald guy-- likeable but top 5 at best
Stubble-face guy-- find a boy band- sings ok

You really think Phil (Bald Guy) is any good? While not as bad as Sanjaya his snob "I've got this won already" atitude is killing me. Did you see the way he strutted back from the bottom three last time? Like he knew he couldn't possibly be the one going home. Dude, you're in the bottom three! What bigger hint do you need?

Big-breasted diva-- 2nd best singer there

There's a couple of these so I'm gonna go with Lakesha.

Clean cut contemporary guy-- I like him a lot-- comes at things with a nice original take

Blake, I like him as well. He's not too over the top and he can deffinately sing. He is very talented at mouthmusic too. He's given some pretty impressive displays.

Tall amazonian woman-- good singer but somehow just doesn't wow me the same

I have no idea who this would be. The tall amazonian woman was ditched before we got to the final 12 so I'm at a loss. Process of elimination makes her out to be Jordan but Jordan is only an inch or two taller than Ryan and that's not that hard.

Hot chick--On talent is the second worst remaining singer..... Could potentially make top 5 depending on any hot chick voting

Haley - yeah she had better start wearing her Catherine McPhee dresses soon or she's just gonna be pretty. And you can get pretty for free on the internet.

Soft spoken kid-- should not have made the top 12. Has been worst on a couple of occassions since making it and cleaarly by a MILE the worst remaining singer overall-- BUT to vote him out might mean that all the others have to rock the house PLUS the judges have to say something nice to him so his protectors don't all go vote 5000 times

The fact that he made it to the top 24 says the producers knew what they were doing and deserve to have him win. I'm with votefortheworst and others on this one: you heard him sing plenty before and tried to coax him out of his shell. You knew what you were doing when you kept him on so I think they should get stuck with him. Melinda is going to get a record deal, Idol or no Idol she's gonna take off like a shot. So let's stick it to the Idol producers and make them have to pony up for this flop.

One thing I don't understand: if he has the balls to come out on national television looking like he did but he doesn't have the balls to put his heart and soul into a song. I don't understand that.

Tom P.

[DaShi]

If Sanjaya loses before the end, do you think he'll get any record deals or will just be forgotten? Even if he makes it to the top 2. Heck, even if he wins.

[Drake Tungsten]

Gina was too good a singer to go out now. And Sanjaya's still not in the bottom-three?

[Wycoff]

Originally posted by padillah
Catherine McPhee dresses soon or she's just gonna be pretty. And you can get pretty for free on the internet.

Haley isn't anywhere close to McPhee. McPhee was really hot, well endowed, and a good singer. Haley's mildly cute and a relatively poor singer.

This whole season is crap. I think the judges screwed up with their Hollywood picks. Are you telling me that there weren't better singers there than Phil and Sanjaya?

The problem with SI is that there are only three decent singers (Lakisha, Melinda, and Jordin) all of them female and all of them with similar style. The guys all suck. If Chris from last year were in it this year, he'd be the favorite

I'm eating this up, because I like the whole Snajaya disaster. It drives my wife crazy.

[FrostyBoy]

Are you all talking about the "Melinda Doolittle Show"?

[Drake Tungsten]

Are you telling me that there weren't better singers there than Phil and Sanjaya?

Phil isn't a bad singer. He's just really, really uninteresting...

[Wycoff]

Originally posted by Drake Tungsten Phil isn't a bad singer. He's just really, really uninteresting...

Phil sucks. He's a bad singer, plus he looks like Dracula from that 1920s Draclua movie. My wide and I refer to him as Nosferatu.

[LordShiva]

Originally posted by Wycoff
My wide and I

That's not very nice

We call them "vertically challenged" nowadays

[Wycoff]

Originally posted by LordShiva That's not very nice

We call them "vertically challenged" nowadays

Maybe I shouldn't be drinking on a Wednesday. Oh well, oyu live, you learn.

[Drake Tungsten]

I thought "vertically challenged" people were short. His "wide" could very well be both tall and really fat...

[Wycoff]

Nosferatu

[Wycoff]

Phil Stacey