Harry Potter 6: Who snuffs it?

[lord of the mark]

quote:
"Originally posted by lord of the mark
yeah, but then we all heard it was Hagrid last time. "

IE, i said it was only a rumor.

to which BG replied:

"This was based on a British news report that a worker from the publisher's had stolen 5 pages from the book which detailed Dumbledore's demise:"

So if YOU meant to say, it was only a rumor, what was the point of your reply?

Maybe hes not a jerk, maybe hes just walking around in a fog.

Seems to me you REALIZE you were denying it was just a rumor, but for whatever reason your not comfortable admiting that or apologizing. I dont know why folks have this thing about not apologizing, but they do.

[Guynemer]

Oh for Christ's sake, let it go, the both of yas.

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by lord of the mark
quote:
"Originally posted by lord of the mark
yeah, but then we all heard it was Hagrid last time. "

IE, i said it was only a rumor.

to which BG replied:

"This was based on a British news report that a worker from the publisher's had stolen 5 pages from the book which detailed Dumbledore's demise:"

So if YOU meant to say, it was only a rumor, what was the point of your reply?

Maybe hes not a jerk, maybe hes just walking around in a fog.

Seems to me you REALIZE you were denying it was just a rumor, but for whatever reason your not comfortable admiting that or apologizing. I dont know why folks have this thing about not apologizing, but they do.

First, I had no what the Hagrid thing was about, since I have never read HP5.

Second, I was only providing where I heard the rumor, not saying it was more than a rumor. Since the article I cited actually says that it's all based on rumor, and nothing in the article is substantiated, I thought it would be pretty obvious to anyone reading it that this was the case.

My hunch is you didn't even bother to read the article closely at first, you just saw the link to the bbc and assumed something definitive was there and decided to lash out about it. So no, I don't feel the need to apologize for your inability to read carefully and for making assumptions about what I was saying.

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by Guynemer
Oh for Christ's sake, let it go, the both of yas.

Thank yous!

I'm done. I will apologize to you, Guynemer, that someone's poutfest led to your thread getting derailed.

[lord of the mark]

Originally posted by Guynemer
Oh for Christ's sake, let it go, the both of yas.

I will say no more. Period.

[Nostromo]

You mean, you guys haven't heard? Rowling is going experimental this time around. She kills the narrator. Then things get really weird...

[Drake Tungsten]

Spoiler etiquette on Poly takes another turn for the worse...

[Nostromo]

And Boris will be happy to hear that Harry finally comes out. There's a hot and steamy scene with Harry and Ron...

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by nostromo
And Boris will be happy to hear that Harry finally comes out. There's a hot and steamy scene with Harry and Ron...

That's supposed to turn me on? Ick.

[Nostromo]

Silly Boris, that wasn't my intention. If it was, I would have posted pictures of fat, hairy guys.

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by nostromo
Silly Boris, that wasn't my intention. If it was, I would have posted pictures of fat, hairy guys.

While I have no desire to see such things, I will point out that you could probably be amply supplied with such photos from the denizens of this very forum.

[Mr. Harley]

Well, then, Boris likes bears? - that has a certain alliterative and cultural appropriateness (I didn't know that term until I cam to Apolyton, thanks to all you gay posters )

[Imran Siddiqui]

Originally posted by Drake Tungsten
Spoiler etiquette on Poly takes another turn for the worse...

It was the slippery slope after your run in with the Star Wars thread. I should have known it would have come to this

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by shawnmmcc
Well, then, Boris likes bears? - that has a certain alliterative and cultural appropriateness (I didn't know that term until I cam to Apolyton, thanks to all you gay posters )

Huh?

Bears ARE fat, hairy guys, which I said I have no desire to see...

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui


It was the slippery slope after your run in with the Star Wars thread. I should have known it would have come to this

Spoiler != Rumor.