Post your Revenge of the Sith Reviews and Commentary here!

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by DinoDoc
Oh for ****s sake if we're going to ***** about the changes Lucas has made to the original trilogy, there's more crimes than inserting Hayden in it that he has to answer for.

[DinoDoc]

Originally posted by Boris Godunov
People have already complained about the other changes made that are worse. This is called moving on to a new complaint.

Mea culpa. I stopped reading after the stupid naming arguement.

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by DinoDoc
Mea culpa. I stopped reading after the stupid naming arguement.

It was actually before the naming argument.

[Alexander's Horse]

Originally posted by Geronimo


have you ever enjoyed any Science fictions movies/TV AH?

Oh yeah, but I like more cerebral fair like 2001 and The Day the Earth Stood Still.

On TV Red Dwarf was a favorite, as was Lost in Space.

[JohnT]

Originally posted by Geronimo


have you ever enjoyed any Science fictions movies/TV AH?

AH was born a 72 year-old curmudgeon. Don't worry about the likes of him.

[JohnT]

Originally posted by Geronimo


this makes no sense whatsoever. I'ts baffling that Lucas would put anakin in that scene when he makes clear in his latest film that he intended only for Jedi who have had intensive years of training and access to a nearly unknwon breakthrough by Qui-gon to be able to live on as force ghosts or whatever they are.

How would anakin have learned that? Why go to the bother of tampering with the scene if not to remove the inconsistant element?

[Kuciwalker]

Originally posted by Jaguar
Oh, and JohnT, if you've never seen the ROTJ DVD, don't. It has Hayden in it.

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU for warning me

[Dis]

Hayden Christenson is just too small for the roll.

I'd rather see them have Ving Rhames as Anakin. though he is a little old. Maybe michael Duncan.

Although it would be tough explaining their white children.

[Zkribbler]

Originally posted by JohnT
I PWN everybody. It's a model of argumentative brilliance.

Lots of good stuff there

And Jar Jar has yet to die a slow yet painful death.

[Alexander's Horse]

please don't write in and ask Lucas to do a third trilogy

[Lonestar]

Quickie Comments:

-The Jedi seem to have no reservations about overthrowing an elected government.

-The Clonetroopers seemed to have finally grasped prepared defensive positions...why they left them on Kashyyk I don't know.

-Coruscant has HUGE staging areas for the Republican/Imperial Starfleet.

-Coruscant's home fleet is massive, indicating the Core Worlds have fleets far exceeding the Flotilla we see in ROTJ.

-The Wookies' tactical prowess would make the Zulus proud; no wonder the Empire kicked their teeth in.

-Automatic Blasters!

-The Republic was on the Strategic Defensive by ROTS, probably the Seperatists would have won if Palpatine hadn't been running the show.

[Kuciwalker]

Coruscant's home fleet that we saw was smaller than the fleet with saw in ROTJ.

[Alexander's Horse]

Originally posted by Lonestar
Quickie Comments:

-The Jedi seem to have no reservations about overthrowing an elected government.

-The Clonetroopers seemed to have finally grasped prepared defensive positions...why they left them on Kashyyk I don't know.

-Coruscant has HUGE staging areas for the Republican/Imperial Starfleet.

-Coruscant's home fleet is massive, indicating the Core Worlds have fleets far exceeding the Flotilla we see in ROTJ.

-The Wookies' tactical prowess would make the Zulus proud; no wonder the Empire kicked their teeth in.

-Automatic Blasters!

-The Republic was on the Strategic Defensive by ROTS, probably the Seperatists would have won if Palpatine hadn't been running the show.

that's just sad

[Geronimo]

Originally posted by Alexander's Horse


that's just sad

which part is the sad part?

[DaShi]

Wesa free!