Top: Game top list.

[Adagio]

Just one question: When voting for a game, should we then also mention if we're voting for the game+addon, or just the game?

Like if someone only likes Civ3 because of PTW, should he/she then vote for Civ3 - PTW, or just Civ3?

I'd say: Just for the game, not the addon

But what do you others think?

[Pedrunn]

Whoever votes CTP over SMAC is smacked on some serious crack.

Either that or this person never played CTP2 modded

I'd say: Just for the game, not the addon

But what do you others think?

I believe add ons are part of the serie. Next year this is something to discuss about it.
eg. I would never vote CTP2 unmodded. But with the add ons of the modders it will come in the first place

[gwillybj]

SMAC = 12 points

Tanks! (Wargame Construction Set 2, by SSI, aka WCS2) = 6
Steel Panthers = 4
Sim City = 2
Mule = 1

I own, and still play, Sim City and M.U.L.E. on my Commodore 64, of which I own three, all working 100%.

[Maquiladora]

Originally posted by Wittlich
1. CTP2
2. CTP
3. Civ3PTW
4. Civ2TOT
5. CeasarIII

Wittlich youve got 2 more votes there, seeing as civ3ptw + civ2tot = Civ and CTP + CTP2 = CTP.

The next poll i think you should be able to vote for an addon alone, even if it does need the original game. So i could vote for PTW, but thats unlikely. So theres no need to mention why your voting for that particular series yet, unless you want to of course.

[Skanky Burns]

jpww: You have 15 more points to use

Taz: Civ == Civ2 (in this poll), so you have another 2 points to use.

Wittlich: For the reasons Maquiladora highlighted, you have 2 more votes worth a total of 5 points.

Regarding the game vs add-ons for next years poll, that is an interesting question and I would like to hear more people's views on this. I can guarantee that unofficial mods won't be included (makes it way too complicated), but should official add-ons be included, or just the standard game?

[jpww]

2. CTP

[Method]

SMAC
SMAC
SMAC
SMAC
SMAC

[Wittlich]

Ok, then my vote is:

CTP
CIV
Ceasar
Pharaoh

[Pedrunn]

I can guarantee that unofficial mods won't be included (makes it way too complicated), but should official add-ons be included, or just the standard game?

I do know that

[Kirov]

1. SMAX
2. Fallout
3. Starcraft
4. Emperor of the Fading Suns
5. Homeworld

[Zealot]

1. Civilization
2. Masters of Orion
3. Starcraft
4. Sensible Soccer
5. Warcraft

[vmxa1]

Wait a minute Starcraft and MoM are not series, they did not have sequels.
They are are great games, but not a series.

[Urban Ranger]

Well Starcraft has an expansion pack

[Urban Ranger]

Originally posted by Sagacious Dolphin
No game has come close to being as replayable as Civ2 (for me). Not even SMAC - in fact I've racked up about 2 days of SMAC, 1 day of Civ3 and about a week of the CtPs. Compare this to many months of Civ2 and Civ1.

For me, the 4x game I played most is Civ 1, followed by SMACX. CtP, hm, a few hours

[Skanky Burns]

The complete list is available on the last page of this thread.