Mafia XIX - Mafia on the Nile

[Chaunk]

I don't know, but I think you're probably as dangerous as the mafia whether you're actually the mafia or not.

[Kassiopeia]

A blind hen can sometimes find her corn, I don't see why this couldn't apply to *tko and mafias too.

[Jon Miller]

let me jump on the Ljcvetko bandwagonp

JM

[Kassiopeia]

The thought of *tko being "it" did cross my mind. It'd be a silly move from a GM to make him the mafia, though, as he'll be quite prominent (and an arrogant know-it-all sonofafemaledog) and thus a real vote magnet.

[Hercules]

Blast, the Mafia on board are really afraid of real detectives and ADG seems to lead the posse.

[Ljube]

Originally posted by Kassiopeia
The thought of *tko being "it" did cross my mind. It'd be a silly move from a GM to make him the mafia, though, as he'll be quite prominent (and an arrogant know-it-all sonofafemaledog) and thus a real vote magnet.

Ah Kassi, don't try to reason with pilers like Chaunk and Jon Miller.

In fact, the two of them always vote me regardless of the clues or anything.

[Chaunk]

Not so! If the clues are more substancial than mere conjecture, then I'll follow them. Currently, I can't make head nor tails of any of the clues, and your clues seem to be as clear as mud.

Therefore in this instance, I'm voting for you, because you have no logical reason - logical to my mind at least - to vote for Skanky. That immediatly makes you suspicious to me, as it seems like you're trying to divert attention to someone, who as far as I can tell isn't the mafia.

Further, your previous history of clue finding - AFAIK - isn't great. Generally you find clues that point to people who are innocent, which helps the mafia more than the villagers.

I'm willing to be wrong on this, but I feel that currently it's hard to pick out the clues - no recuring themes etc as we're on the first kill. You, OTOH, state with full assurace that it's skanky. To my mind, it doesn't add up, hence me voting for you.

[Kassiopeia]

Conjecture is better grounds than simple guessing. Of course, the reasoning that someone trying hard to find clues is bent on deflecting attention is valid as well.

However, *tko has been doing this for several games without being the mafia, ergo it's not a requirement for him to pull this stuff out of his arse. (Then again, behaving differently this time would've made him much too suspicious...)

[Ljube]

Originally posted by Chaunk
Therefore in this instance, I'm voting for you, because you have no logical reason - logical to my mind at least - to vote for Skanky. That immediatly makes you suspicious to me, as it seems like you're trying to divert attention to someone, who as far as I can tell isn't the mafia.

Further, your previous history of clue finding - AFAIK - isn't great. Generally you find clues that point to people who are innocent, which helps the mafia more than the villagers.

Ok, that's your right, though you should bear in mind that I only played 4 games and was guest in 3 other and I got the mafia in 4 of them. That's not too bad of a score don't you think?

I'm not trying to say I can't be wrong of course, but the clues are so obvious now that I had to post them.

Originally posted by Chaunk

Currently, I can't make head nor tails of any of the clues, and your clues seem to be as clear as mud.

I've never seen clearer clues in my life.

[duke o' york]

Name

Voted
for



1. Skanky

ljcvetko



2. Jamski

-



3. ADG

ljcvetko



4. Zopperoni

-



5. Ljcvetko

Skanky



6. Nuclear Master

- 



7. Rah

- 



8. Theben

-



9. Joncha

- 



10. GJRamsey

- 



11. Spaced Cowboy

-



12. Kassiopeia

Skanky



13. Tuberski

-



14. Jon Miller

ljcvetko


16. Guynemer

-



17. SnowFire

-



18. Rasputin

-


19. HongHu

-



22. Octavian X

-



23. Pave

-



24. Geomodder

-



25. Chaunk

ljcvetko



26. Jonny

-

This is fun.

[Chaunk]

Originally posted by ljcvetko

I've never seen clearer clues in my life.

I rest my case [], but apologise profusely if you're right, and Skanky is the scheming mafia masquerading as a barman.

[Pave]

Originally posted by duke o' york
coming to
Olympic

Remember, it's a half of a paper, and the words might not have anything to do with each others, thought the change for that is quite small.

After some incpection and number-summing and subtraction, I'll vote for Ra, Ra, Rasputin, the dangerously acting Russian priest.

[duke o' york]

Skanky's masquerading as a barman, not a 'tec!

[Ljube]

You seem to be trying your best to defend Skanky Duke. Why? You didn't put half as much effort in the defence of the Doctor (if any).

[Chaunk]

Thats what it says, barman! See, look up there, barman... that edit was for... umm... spelling.