Why was the USS Liberty where it was?

[Az]

look , the troll opened his mouth.
go ahead now , Ec. take your best shot

[Ecthy]

Your rabbi won't like that...

Do you think you make yourself look very clever by adressing to every poster that speaks less than glorifying of your person as a troll? I've just actually tried to help GP distinguish you fellas.

And he's right, it's a pretty tough task.

[Jaakko]

[threadjack]Hey GP, what did you do in the Navy?[/threadjack]

[TCO]

"purity of arms"..."purity of arms"

Originally posted by Sirotnikov
GP, sure, it might be illegal and immoral and what ever.

But the point is, that if you know that someone is spying on you, you may very well try to stop it, even if he's not doing "illegal" things.

Personally I think that the whole thing was indeed an accident.

But if it wasn't, while I agree that it wasn't moral, or legal or justified, had I been in office and had a security issue to protect during war, I might have made the same choise.

Wouldn't you?

No. And unlike you I have gathered intel and seen other intel gathering vessels on the high seas. And been in a couple tight spots...

BTW, that you and other Isr. would justify this attack makes it (sadly, sadly) more conceiveable that such an attack was oredered. Very sad, since it lowers my interest in helping you all.

[TCO]

Originally posted by Dalgetti
look , the troll opened his mouth.
go ahead now , Ec. take your best shot

Those weren't his best shots. He was just helping me label y'all. Have a sense of humor...

[Az]

Ecthelion: 'your rabbi won't like it'?

sure I often accept invitations to a lower level of discussion .
Your furher will, however, like it.

you calling Eli childish lives in the domain of one pot calling another black .

[TCO]

Originally posted by Jaakko
[threadjack]Hey GP, what did you do in the Navy?[/threadjack]

attack submarine and staff officer

[Ecthy]

Originally posted by GP
Those weren't his best shots. He was just helping me label y'all. Have a sense of humor...

thanks... Dal has been not-so-friendly lately

[Sirotnikov]

erm, look, obviously one wouldn't want to do that, and normally would do that.

however, sometimes you do illegal things in special operations.

in any case, i do not represent israel or israelis, at least not in that point.

[Sirotnikov]

Dal, answer me in the "kto ruski" thread

[TCO]

But if there are lots of Isr. who feel as you do, that makes a deliberate attack more plausible...

[Jaakko]

Originally posted by GP


attack submarine and staff officer

Thanks.
What kind of a sub? I used to love EA's 688 Attack Sub when I was a kid.

[Sirotnikov]

well obviously a deliberate attack is plausible.
i don't claim we're so very holy and so on, even though i do think that we're usually much more moral than most world countries.

my problem with the deliberate attack claim, is that i see no profit coming out of it - only troubles.

[Ecthy]

Originally posted by Jaakko
What kind of a sub? I used to love EA's 688 Attack Sub when I was a kid.

Yeah, cool, played that a lot!

[TCO]

Originally posted by Jaakko


Thanks.
What kind of a sub? I used to love EA's 688 Attack Sub when I was a kid.

2 Sturgeon class boats. 1 class older than the 688.