Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Vox Diplomacy

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • response from Don:
    RE: RE: Chat?

    No problem. I was just on line and wondered if there were any pressing questions I might answer.


    DeepO

    Comment


    • For the moment, my response would be:

      Dear Vox,

      while not dismissing your proposal, we can't find the time needed to reach a proper discussion. Also, we fail to see the urgency of doing this mid-turn. Could you continue, assuming we're still at war, while we get the time to think on this? This way, we can have a thought-through response, with more of our members commenting.

      Whether you attack, and perhaps even kill Grog won't affect our decision. We assure you that we wouldn't seek revenge at all. However, at this point in time we're unwilling to sign a cease-fire just to give us the possibility of talking, and we don't want to get pressed in taking such a far-reaching decision either.

      We are discussing your proposal, though, and you should get a response in the next few days. Just not in the next few hours...


      DeepO

      Comment


      • I'm happy with that draft response.

        Although would it be better to make more of a point about us not actually wanting them to attack Grog? - currently it sounds very much like we don't care if they do attack him. I don't want them to attack grog... we want him to stay there for line of sight on their capital.

        Perhaps insert:
        "..and perhaps even kill Grog won't affect our decision. Although we would advise you for your own sake not to mess with him - he is a fierce fighter and has the advantage of higher ground. Still, we are at war, and knew that you might attack Grog if he went back to the gold hill, and so we wouldn't seek revenge if you did so. However..."

        But maybe that's too wordy...

        Comment


        • Why is Don asking you to chat, DeepO?

          They've been told I am the contact.

          Now they're pissing me off.
          (\__/)
          (='.'=)
          (")_(") This is Bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your signature to help him gain world domination.

          Comment


          • Don has PMed me for chat.

            I'll let him know the direction we are headed in so they don't sit on the save.
            (\__/)
            (='.'=)
            (")_(") This is Bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your signature to help him gain world domination.

            Comment


            • That's good nye. Is always helpful for things to go through the correct channels.

              I am soooo hoping that when we get the save, they have attacked and lost...

              Comment


              • Chat with Don.

                Summary:
                - They don't want to lose and feel we have the advantage.
                - They claim not to have BW or AH as of yet.
                - I conclude we can press the issue and if we win, great. If things go against us peace will be an option.
                Donegeal
                Hi there1
                nye
                hello
                Donegeal
                The boss is still letting me use the computer...
                nye
                -heh
                Donegeal
                First off, I'm soory if we put you guys on the spot. I tried to say so in my letter by saying that we understand this is not a quick or easy choice to make.
                Donegeal
                man.. how do I change this so its just Donegeal and not my e-mail?
                nye
                i'm not sure
                nye
                in the windows messanger window. Options
                Donegeal
                If your too busy, we can try this later...
                nye
                now is fine. i don;t think you should sit on the turn.
                nye
                we are wondering why you would send the message now, not last turn, or after the turn
                Donegeal
                Not looking good then, huh? Well just just hadn't made up our mind about attacking yet. Didn't.... oh, thats easy...
                Donegeal
                We sent it after we had explored your land. With us moving to 99 of the Eye, we have your city mapped. If we did it before then and you escepted, we would be allowed to come near.
                Donegeal
                er I mean we wouldn't be allowed near...
                nye
                i see
                Donegeal
                and like I said, we are now fased with the choice of actually hurting you. But if you were to be our allies, we wouldn't want to do so.
                nye
                that is appreciated, however we know the costs of war and we accept them.
                Donegeal
                So it would be looking like your answer is no, right?
                nye
                that is the way it is running.
                nye
                i should ask, what you folks have in mind for borders though
                Donegeal
                All right then. Let me try to convince otherwise.
                Donegeal
                Oh... I hadn't thought of actual borders yet. That wasn't the way I was seeing it.
                nye
                ok
                Donegeal
                As in Civ 4 there is no corruption, so how close a city is is not as important. I know that maint is increased, but that is all
                Donegeal
                In a case where I have an 'Ally', the borders would be determind by whatever would be best for the both of us.
                Donegeal
                Everything comes down to a matter of trust. If you think you can trust us, then what difference to city placement make other than maximizing production and commerce?
                Donegeal
                As a show of trust, ask away any question you have. I'd be happy to answer.
                nye
                i don't know if i should take advantage of that given the direction of opinion in GS.
                Donegeal
                Ok... your a good man for admitting that.
                nye
                however, if you are willing, have you discovered ah or bw?
                Donegeal
                nope
                nye
                ok
                Donegeal
                not yet anyway...
                Donegeal
                I figured you go for the gusto...
                nye
                of course. do you fancy your chances vs Grog?
                Donegeal
                Nope. We have a 24.9% chance of success. But we do have another unit nearby to finish the job.
                nye
                ce le guerre, or some such
                Donegeal
                er... whatever that means....
                nye
                so war goes
                nye
                such is war
                Donegeal
                ah...
                nye
                prolly spelled it wrong
                nye
                you can set your handle in the Options tab of the MSM main window
                Donegeal
                Anyway... want to know why I did this? (I am the current voice of Vox and defacto leader...)
                nye
                the one where you see me online
                nye
                yes, i am curious about why you did this
                Donegeal
                Vox is in a tight spot. We know this, you know this, hell, Snoopy and Aeson know this. I don't think Vox can win against GS at this point. GS can win agaist Vox, but its going to take alot of time and alot of units.
                Donegeal
                The way I see it, peace is more beneficial to both our teams at this point becuse the gain of one city for GS would be chump change compared to the kind of benefits that our two team could have by working together.
                nye
                you are doing the right thing given the circumstances. completely understandable
                nye
                i would be doing the same were the situations reversed
                Donegeal
                I just see no benefit to continueing this war, for either of us.
                nye
                i hope there are no hard feelings, but i don;t agree at this point
                nye
                personally. the team may come to another decision but that will take time
                Donegeal
                Ok, now I ask for some info from you, (don't feel obligated to tell me though): What good can come from this war?
                nye
                may i answer with questions of my own?
                Donegeal
                Sure
                nye
                who has the advantage in this war?
                Donegeal
                You do. But it is not a big enough advantage at this point to make it worth while.
                Donegeal
                It will just take far too long to accomplish.
                nye
                ok. who has the advantage(s) in peace?
                Donegeal
                We both do. We can coodinate research, figure out how to arange borders so there are no resource problems...ets...
                Donegeal
                the advantages that we both get are almost limitless...
                nye
                you are the voice now?
                Donegeal
                Yes.
                nye
                what about when another is the voice, and decides that we would be better dead after your religion is in all our cities and you can see everything we are doing, and we have massive ww when at war with the holy city?
                Donegeal
                If we ally, I don't see that happening. What would the benefits be to going to war against a long term friend?
                nye
                we are very close to each other, and your team may be open to people who are less than stable
                nye
                the problem is that we have no control, and no room for error
                Donegeal
                I could say the excat same thing about your team. However, like I have said, it's a matter of trust.
                nye
                true, but our style is consensus. Vox is a small team and subject to wild swings due to who is active at the time
                nye
                this is my thinking, btw.
                Donegeal
                sure, I understand.
                nye
                not necessarily shared by all on GS
                Donegeal
                Vox was like you described, but we are much more stable now. We have a very active Voice, and two ther very active players.
                Donegeal
                And like I have said, it all comes down to a matter of trust.
                nye
                officially, i can tell you that there will not be a favourable response to your request within 48 hours, so there is no need to sit on the save
                Donegeal
                Hmmm.... ok, I'll take that to my team and will finish the turn tommarow after work.
                nye
                i understand what you are saying, Don. However it also comes down to what we consider to be the best course of action for GS
                Donegeal
                I am SO glad you brought that up NYE. If we are allies, then what do you think the 'best course of action' would be for Vox?
                nye
                i don't know enough to say
                nye
                but researching Writing, right now, would be good.
                Donegeal
                I'll say it for you: The best course of action for Vox would be to help GS.
                Donegeal

                Donegeal
                Its on our 'to do' list...
                nye
                Lego once thought that the best course of action was to ally with GoW and ND. I wonder what they think of that now?
                Donegeal
                They did so because GoW out manuvered GS diplomaticly.
                nye
                Of course. The end result is not changed though
                Donegeal
                (always thought GoW should have stood for Glory of Writting...)
                nye
                heh
                Donegeal
                Hindshight is always 20-20.
                nye
                of course
                Donegeal
                And this is a much different game.
                Donegeal
                No way can an empire like that fall in one turn.
                nye
                true, but fall it still can
                Donegeal
                Anyway... these are matter far into the future. By the time situation like that arise, GS/Vox would be as solid as GoW/ND.
                nye
                how much land do we have?
                Donegeal
                It all comes down to trust.
                Donegeal
                er... not sure. There is room for at least 2, maybe 3 really good cities to our E.
                nye
                are we alone on Bob, or is this map Aeson's snicker at Vox and GS on Stormia again?
                Donegeal
                It sure would be a snicker... but if we are alone, then alling would be the best route.
                Donegeal
                (hell, even if ther is someone else here alling is the best route...)
                Donegeal
                You mentioned earlier about Hinduism spreading to your cities. If you trust us, what difference would that make?
                nye
                how much land is there to your East?
                nye
                trusting you is not the same as trusting whoever else might become the voice in the future, Don
                nye
                is calling you Don OK?
                Donegeal
                Crap... I don't know. Like I said, 2-3 solid city placements. Not sure about number of tiles...
                Donegeal
                Don's fine. Much eaiser than that missspelling I have as a name...
                nye
                i would like to say that there is nothing personal in this war. from my point of view it is just the right move for GS.
                Donegeal
                I know. Nothing personal here either. I just see that there is SO much more potential in being allies rather than enemies.
                nye
                'creppy little *****es' had a lot of us laughing
                Donegeal
                Here is another big possible factor in being allies....
                Donegeal
                huh?
                nye
                in your reply to the war and the dead scout. you called us 'creepy little *****es'
                Donegeal
                did I? Hmmm... I wrote that VERY late in my shift and was VERY tired by the end...
                nye
                it was well written
                Donegeal
                Ah... thanks...
                Donegeal
                anyway... big factor"
                Donegeal
                factor:
                nye
                ok
                Donegeal
                If you choose war, how are you going to compete with other teams that choose peace and frienship?
                nye
                if we win, we will be fine
                nye
                if not, we will be dead
                Donegeal
                If you choose war, I don't see how you could loose. But I also don't see how you'd be able to compete with teams that made friends with their first contact. They would be so far ahead in tech than you that the'y be able to walk over you.
                nye
                it depends a lot on the map
                Donegeal
                Vox is just not worth the effort.
                Donegeal
                Minimal benefit compared to tremendous benefit. All it takes is trust.
                Donegeal
                You mentioed GoW/ND. Look at what they accomplished. And it all happened becuause of trust.
                nye
                point noted
                nye
                as i said, Don, we could decide to go that way. it just won;t be very soon.
                Donegeal
                Yeah... just realize that the longer this war goes on, the farther behind you/we become. Its a dog eat dog world out there and I'd rather be a dog catcher...
                nye
                heh. ok
                Donegeal
                Does this thing auto log?
                nye
                File... Save As
                nye
                if you close the window, it's gone
                Donegeal
                Sorry for the delay... I'm getting my stuff together for work...
                nye
                np
                Donegeal
                Anyway... Personally, I'm in a 'no loose' situation. If we go the route of Allies, my team will have a chance to win. If we stay at war, well then I get to be a thorn in GS's side until they kill us. And once that happens, I get to join them and be a thorn on the inside!!!
                nye
                heh
                nye
                it would be good to have a mad king
                Donegeal
                What a schorcher outside today! heat index of 117 F and I'm out there landscaping with rocks!
                nye
                that's hot.
                Donegeal
                I think I'm not quite so mad anymore...
                nye
                why did they give you the name? it was earned?
                Donegeal
                but I'd get to play the part of Beta being all locked up in a dungeon...
                Donegeal
                No... I got to be turn player for GoW once. I invaded ND with a warrior we were scouting with. Trip had just done the same thing to us so I figured "what the hell" and did it to them. I didn't ask and it almost ruined the whole thing... I had to go to their forum and apoligise...
                nye
                ahh, and they blamed it on your madness. i see. good story
                Donegeal
                Glory of Writting!
                Donegeal
                (I was also banned from playing the turn)
                nye
                figured that would be part of it. must be a real kick to be more erratic than Farb.
                Donegeal
                I wasn't, but guess who came up with the idea?
                nye
                haha!
                Donegeal
                Ok... so do you have any other questions?
                nye
                not really. have a good shift and take care
                Donegeal
                Die scum
                nye
                :E
                nye
                those are my fangs
                Donegeal
                ok... one last time. How do i save?
                nye
                File... Save As
                Donegeal
                Thanks. Talk to you later... scum
                nye
                buh bye
                Last edited by notyoueither; July 31, 2006, 22:38.
                (\__/)
                (='.'=)
                (")_(") This is Bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your signature to help him gain world domination.

                Comment


                • Originally posted by notyoueither
                  Why is Don asking you to chat, DeepO?

                  They've been told I am the contact.

                  Now they're pissing me off.
                  I don't know... I haven't sent a single PM to anyone outside our team in this game. But Don's in my buddy's list, so perhaps I'm in his too. Or otherwise he was stalking our forum, and saw me posting a few posts in quick succesion. These are about the only spot where the 'hide your bulb' thing doesn't work.

                  DeepO

                  Comment


                  • The chat seems to have been fine... it surely was not emotional or so. We all kind of know where we stand, I guess.

                    DeepO

                    Comment


                    • "Give us your Religion and we call off the Skirmishers (for now)..."
                      And her eyes have all the seeming of a demon's that is dreaming...

                      Comment


                      • Good chat.

                        I also gained a bit of respect for Donegeal - he certainly seemed very frank and honest (though I guess that could be put on). He's definitely playing this the same way I would if I were in position - knows they are losing, tries to point out the long term benefits of an alliance, grasping at any way out of his situation.

                        Still, nye made it clear to him just where we are negotiating from: a position of strength.

                        (my opinion)
                        Short term, our advantage only grows, so on with the war!

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by Dominae
                          "Give us your Religion and we call off the Skirmishers (for now)..."
                          That is a card that could be played at some point in the future.
                          (\__/)
                          (='.'=)
                          (")_(") This is Bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your signature to help him gain world domination.

                          Comment


                          • I must say things are looking well on our part . I too think we are to keep our position of strength in our relations with Vox. Of course as long as we have real advantage and we're not risking pretty much nothing this is a no-brainer: maintain the state of war and keep the pressure on Vox's territory.
                            What we do need now is some sort of assessment on the risks/gains of war versus peace/alliance in the next 10-20-50 turns and beyond. Also, since we have time on our hands, and we're not handling a crisis (unlike Vox perhaps) we would well if we comprise an action plan for war, perhaps with a crude timeline to winning this thing.

                            Anyway, in case I'll be going back to lurking (army service is such a drag, though fortunately I'm quite safe from the growing fighting in the north) I'd say this:
                            Good job, good luck- and long live Stormia!
                            Save the rainforests!
                            Join the us today and say NO to CIV'ers chopping jungles

                            Comment


                            • Looking at the situation with a fresh pair of eyes, I agree with the general consensus regarding relative strengths, and the advantages of war vs. peace (in case that’s of any comfort ). That said, is there really any reason why we shouldn't discuss what the terms of a peace deal might be? Given how early in the game we are I suppose there’s not too much we’re able to trade, but unless there are simply no terms under which we would except peace then what's the harm in opening up the dialog (as long as we're careful what we say)?

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by zeit
                                Anyway, in case I'll be going back to lurking (army service is such a drag, though fortunately I'm quite safe from the growing fighting in the north) I'd say this:
                                Good job, good luck- and long live Stormia!
                                Good to see you, zeit. And stay out of harm's way!

                                Randolph, good to see you too

                                DeepO

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X