Apolyton civ3 rankings

[drake]

We should have a wide base of people now who own the game. I am curious as to what the average rating civ3 gets from this community. Please vote honestly

[drake]

No negative votes so far...interesting considering all the negative comments around here

[dainbramaged13]

what... a 7 isn't negative enough for u?

[felder]

Originally posted by dainbramaged13
what... a 7 isn't negative enough for u?

This means you're saying that Civ3 is considerably better than half the other games you'd rate. Doesn't sound negative to me.

[drake]

a 7 is basically a "good" rating....still a very respectable mark.

10 excellent
5 average
1 horrible


Only 16 votes so far...average score - 8.3

[Adagio]

After having a look at all other games released (or having a demo released) in the last few months I'd give it.........10

[TrainWreck20]

This is a tricky question, vague enough to be something USA Today would post

Compared to what.......?
A. Other Civ games (or TBGs)...............7
Some definite improvements/advances, but a few left out, too. Would have liked to see some of CtP2s ideas included.

B. Other computer games....................9
I definitely prefer TBG to arcade and/or graphic intensive 'adventure', but just my opinion.

C. My expectations...............................5
Like the game (found that '1 more turn syndrom'), but see 'A', had higher hopes.

[drake]

It's not vague at all tw
What is your personal opinion of the game? Period. Thats the question!

Through 37 votes, the average score is 7.83...pretty good civ3

Keep the votes coming.

[drake]

Keep em coming...I know we got more than 49 people here....I'd say we need atleast 100 poly people to make this survey worthwhile.

[sekong]

I vote a 7. Almost quit from playing it for a variety of reasons. But with its excellent trading and dipo options, civ3 will potentially make much better dipo games than civ2 does. But MP is not included yet. Better wait till MP release. Or maybe I can send you my copy for you to evaluate/practice. :P

[Ralf]

Lets all help out with bumping this Poll from time to time, so that as many visitors as possible have a change to vote. That is; if not MarkG decides to "glue" this one at the top, for a while.

[drake]

After 54 votes, the score stands at 7.96....after taking a slight drop its on its way back up!

[drake]

250 views and only 57 votes......

[Ralf]

64 votes and almost 3 out of 4 visitors (71.88%) currently thinks that its worth something between 8 and 10.

[TrainWreck20]

Ok, so whose job is it to do the statistical analysis, throw out the outliers, and come up with a final average and a standard deviation?