Eve Of Destruction Battle Report Discussion Thread

[Moonbars]

*groan*

[Micha]

Originally posted by ormuzd
Horse army (12/12) attacks bowman Micha (4/4), wins (2/12)

*MUAHAHAHAHAAA* (ouch) *MUAHAHAAA*
/me laughs diabolically while slowly passing away...

------------------------------

I am back!

[Moonbars]

nearly dude, nearly!!! I dont know what came as more of a suprise to me there, AM has an army, or Micha the Bowman nearly pasted it.

[Aqualung71]

A point of order needs to be discussed.

Clearly AM have a Horseman Army. If this Army was built by an MGL generated in battle, the generation of the MGL should have been disclosed as it is part of a battle result.

Of course, if it was built by an SGL, no such disclosure is necessary.

I therefore call upon AM to state categorically that the Army was not built by an MGL, or if it was, which particular battle resulted in the MGL being generated.

Naturally, I also call upon all other teams to disclose if they have generated an MGL through battle, and which particular battle(s).

The Desolation Row has not, thus far, generated any MGL's from battle.

[Krill]

Hey, I was not around when the save was played, and the battle reports posted.

And as Babylon have thus far refused to correct their battle report, I fail to see why we should.

[Moonbars]

it might help if you explained what was wrong with their report. I cant see anything amiss with it.

[Aqualung71]

Originally posted by Krill
4/4 Khan Horseman Tervel attacks 4/4 Warrior, Khan Horseman Terval wins 1/4
4/4 Khan Horseman Omurtag attacks 3/4 Warrior Scaeva, Khan Horseman Omurtag wins 2/4
4/4 Khan Horseman Krum attack 3/4 Horseman, Khan Horseman Krum wins 2/4

4/4 Khan Horseman Telerig captures Lake Ishtar. Lake Ishtar captured and abandonned

Krill, why have you named some of your units after the BOH leader?

[ormuzd]

You never see when the opponent gets a military leader, so why should I report it? I'm giving information that would be visible for the other team if they were playing against an AI

[Krill]

*Points at Ormuzds flag*

Khan is Bulgarian for leader. Probably has something to do with how the Real Life (TM) Mongols invaded the Balkans and influenced the language.

You could say the same is true here.

[Aqualung71]

Originally posted by ormuzd
You never see when the opponent gets a military leader, so why should I report it? I'm giving information that would be visible for the other team if they were playing against an AI

Generally you can see when the AI gets an MGL.

I would also go so far as to say that if a team receives an MGL in defence, it should be disclosed in the Battler Reports thread.

Again, the production of an MGL is an integral result of the battle and should be disclosed.

We all have a right to know if there are MGL's or Armies floating around out there as a result of battles.

[Krill]

Um, actually if an MGL is generated by the defender that is in a city, the attacker will not know that the MGL has been generated.

So, either we go ahead and say that only MGLs generated by attackers are mentioned, as the ones generated by the defenders are not none about until either the stack that they are in is obliterated or are used to make an army, or we just forget about reporting them.

[Aqualung71]

Originally posted by Krill
Um, actually if an MGL is generated by the defender that is in a city, the attacker will not know that the MGL has been generated.

Yes, that's true, but IMHO it's mere semantics.

I think MGL's should be disclosed. And I think it's fun (remember that concept?) that we all know

What do others think?

[Ljube]

I agree. We should disclose all military great leaders.

[Micha]

Of course. We want to know who we´re messing with. Propaganda is much more effective if it´s personal, and having an ingame-character for that is much better than having to concentrate on team members


Disclose MGLs

[E_T]

Originally posted by Krill
Hey, I was not around when the save was played, and the battle reports posted.

And as Babylon have thus far refused to correct their battle report, I fail to see why we should.

What's wrong with our Battle Report?

E_T