Should the People Be Allowed to Impeach the President and Ministers?

[Panag]

hi ,

power to the people , okay , but still there should be something like , a senate oversee group , just to check that the "impeachment" of one is fair .

have a nice day

[Inverse Icarus]

all except the military advisor

[Panag]

Originally posted by UberKruX
all except the military advisor

hi ,

, nope that guy should get no exception , ..... , however he should have a type of assistant , for back-up , just in case , ...

have a nice day

[Jon Shafer]

I think it should only be submitted by a Minister. The public can have its views, but what if one of the ministers has a plan that he/she doesn't want to reveal to the public, and because of how things are going in the game, all of the sudden someone in the populuce calls for impeachment?

[Space05us]

dang the people, they're voting in thier favor.... I'll see that the next cabinet has a member impeached!!

[Jon Shafer]

*Awaits the result where the populuce impeaches every Minister, but doesn't replace them so total anarchy reigns as the save file is leaked in the fiasco and the whole world goes to HELL!*

[Timeline]

You are a couple of despots

[Moral Hazard]

The people called for freedom of the save file No despot going to take that away, well they can as long as I get a save file

[Timeline]

bump

[Panag]

Originally posted by Trip
I think it should only be submitted by a Minister. The public can have its views, but what if one of the ministers has a plan that he/she doesn't want to reveal to the public, and because of how things are going in the game, all of the sudden someone in the populuce calls for impeachment?

hi

to prevent this whe should have a senate , so that we can prevent this , the senate is a sperate body , with high powers , and can just sit back and check , recheck and doublecheck , ....

it should be 5 members , so they always have a nice vote , ....

have a nice day

[Jon Shafer]

The only problem is that kind of thing will never happen. And what else would they do? Why not just let the Ministers do it?

[Panag]

Originally posted by Trip
The only problem is that kind of thing will never happen. And what else would they do? Why not just let the Ministers do it?

hi ,

a senate could be completely impartial , .....

the only thing they would do is to check , ...and when something happens they could act , they could say , no , or not now , yes , yes but later , and so on , ...
imagine some one calls for an "impeachment" , the ministers are "working" on their stuff , so they would loose time , .....
is the impeachment "justified" , that would be the job for the senate , like a judge a bit , people could talk to them , and when this or that is justified , or this of that going in a wrong direction , control it , talk , think , etc ,...

have a nice day

[Chandragupta]

Originally posted by Trip
I think it should only be submitted by a Minister. The public can have its views, but what if one of the ministers has a plan that he/she doesn't want to reveal to the public, and because of how things are going in the game, all of the sudden someone in the populuce calls for impeachment?

Why would a minister have a 'secret plan' unless it involved something that a) the people wouldnt like anyway or b) something bad for another minister.

*Awaits the result where the populuce impeaches every Minister, but doesn't replace them so total anarchy reigns as the save file is leaked in the fiasco and the whole world goes to HELL!*

I think with a 2/3 majority, ministers would rarely be impeached, if ever. Let alone the entire cabinet. I dont think we're that irresponsible... no really we aren't... well maybe we are a little reckless... ok fine!

Also, I think impeachment technically means in the US (correct me if I'm wrong) that the president is to be recommended for removal from office and then the real removal process begins. Remember, Clinton and Johnson were both impeached but neither was removed.

[Jon Shafer]

Yes, but it's easier and more definitive to say that someone was 'impeached' rather than 'removed from office'. As far as the entire cabinet being impeached...

[Panag]

Originally posted by Trip
Yes, but it's easier and more definitive to say that someone was 'impeached' rather than 'removed from office'. As far as the entire cabinet being impeached...

hi ,

that is why there should be a senate , to prevent wrong-doing , and to tell the people wheter or something is wrong , basically , when they start to impeach everyone , we can keep things "under control" , and save you , ahem , the other people from the government , .......so that the can do whet they are supposed to do , .........work , ahem , play the game , ...

so should the senate go in to "office" , .........as of right now , ....

also the senate shall have the powers , according to the foreign powers act , and apolyton , code 6 , paragraph 18 , art.8754 the right to use a secret police , this government control body would only deal with security about and for the government , it should also , under section 10 , code 85 have the right to deal with certain "individuals" , would hold a field of view that is not consistent with the government , ......

have a nice day