Okay, the EPC thread is back on track, time to work out the details of the most important civs. This has been done before by others but IMHO not in a way that is useful to send to Firaxis as a clarification on why exactly the civs that we picked are so important. This thread is intended mainly to determine what kind of information should be collected and how it should be organized.
As examples to guide us in determining this and to show how I personally think this should roughly look like, I made examples for the Mongols and Spanish (see below), the two most popular civs in the poll. I modeled these examles after the 'Civ of the Week' feature on Civ3.com but I expanded a bit upon the concept. The setup I propose contains some 'technical' info on each civ, such as name, possible unique units and leaders, abilities, etc, and a very short (one or two sentences) mention of it's historical significance. This is followed by a somewhat more elaborate description (roughly 1000 words) of its history and achievements. I had hoped to put in the same amount of humor in the this as Firaxis puts in their CotW descriptions but either the civs I wrote about aren't particularly funny or I'm not... To finish things up, I also added a list of (50) suggestions for city names, roughly in the order in which they should also appear in the game (one might say this is not a very important issue but I'm still baffled by the incredible low quality of some city lists in Civ1/2 and CtP1/2). Of course, this setup is just a proposal and very much open for suggestions.
As far as contents of the two examples goes, this too is open for suggestions and improvements. Both examples can no doubt be improved upon, but personally I think the Mongol one is of fairly high quality (I've always been a greatly admired them and know far more about their history and culture than most people). OTOH, I have my doubts about the Spanish one (I find post Classical Age European history extremely boring so I know fairly little about them and had to rely almost entirely on Internet sources of which I can't really assess the quality) so quite possibly lots of room for improvement there. Any comments on either of them is most welcome, like I said, this is just a proposal, it's by no means final.
When we worked out the details for the general setup of this and are satisfied with the descriptions of the two example civs, similar descriptions can be made for all other civs from the top 16-32 (depending on how things develop). Volunteers for making these descriptions are most welcome but I suggest you only volunteer for civs you really like and/or know a lot about because my 'struggle' with the Spanish was one that I wouldn't want anyone else to go through
In short: read and (hopefully) enjoy and give me any feedback you have...
Red, green and orange parts have been edited as a result of the discussion below.
---------------
* The Mongols *
---------------
Names: Mongolian Empire, the Mongols, Mongol
Time Period: 1200 AD - 1750 AD (Medieval)
Leader: Genghis Khan - alternatives: Kublai Khan, Borte Khatun (f), Akbar the Great
Unique Unit: Horse Archer - alternatives: Composite Bowman, any kind of Medieval Seige weapon (Catapult, Ballista, Mangonel, Trebuchet, Battering Ram, Sapper, etc)
Great Leaders: Subedei, Chepe, Muqali - alternatives: Jelme, Khubilai
Abilities: Militaristic, Expansionist - alternative: Commercial
Historical significance:
Enormous empire that at it's height ruled over much of the Eurasian continent and had a large impact on Asian history from Medieval times onward.
Description:
History has not been kind on the Mongols. Many, historians and laymen alike, have always viewed them as primitive and terrible barbarians who did nothing but conquer, destroy, kill, pillage, plunder and commit all kinds of atrocities (and who disappeared as quickly as they came). All too often are their great accomplishments overlooked. Their military was in every way except size (they were virtually always severely outnumbered) superior to any opponent they ever encountered: their armor, weapons, their seige equipment, their tactics and strategies, their endurance, everything. And as shortlived as it may have been, the Mongols conquered the largest empire that ever existed (though some say the British empire was slightly larger, this just depends on how you measure it) and did this within a human lifetime. They also created a unified China and Russia, both still superpowers today, and made it possible for the Turks to rise to power in the Mediterranean area. And then there are their cultural accomplishments - often influenced by foreigners but distinctly Mongol nonetheless - things like the Great Yasa (see below), the yam (imperial postal system that continued to exist long after the Mongol empire had declined), their literary works ("Secret History of the Mongols", "Collection of Chronicles" et al), poems, artwork, scientific accomplishments (in areas such as mathematics, astronomy, agriculture, philosophy, theology, economics, etc) and construction projects (Taj Mahal and other Moghul construction projects, Beijing, Golden Horde and Central Asian cities). And let's face it, where would the world have been without the great sport that is polo?
But greatest of all was without a doubt their founding father Temuchin, better known under his title Genghis Khan. He was without a doubt one of the greatest, if not the greatest, conqueror and statesman in human history. He took a bunch of rivaling nomadic tribes, conquered them, managed to unite them all under the (back then meaningless) term 'Mongol' and with them conquered much of the Eurasian continent. Genghis didn't just rush into one battle after another like a brute and violent barbarian. On the contrary, he carefully planned each battle and each campaign, he knew exactly what he was doing and where he was going, he was a great strategist. Additionally, Genghis found the pursuit of knowledge very important and made sure the Mongols took advantage of every kind of new technology they encountered during their conquests (most famous examples: writing and siege warfare).
Already early on, Genghis realized very well that with all these different tribes and sedentary nations in his empire, it would not be long before disunity would cause his empire to fall apart. To prevent this, he wrote the Great Yasa, a book containing all the rules and regulations the Mongols had to follow. Although punishment for breaking them was very severe (which resulted in a virtually crime-free society), it was one of the most enlightened and civilized codes of law the world had seen until then. This code said that all people were to be judged by merit and ability rather than by birth or social position, it condemned racism and promoted religious freedom and women's rights (the most skilled Mongol women even fought in the army). Important decisions were to be made not by the Great Khan alone but by the khuriltay, a general assembly of the Mongolian aristorcracy plus other important people in the empire. Genghis even made rules about hygiene, drinking, the environment, combat and hospitality. His basic philosophy was that all men (and women) are equal and that people should always help each other, regardless of who or where they are. These laws kept the Mongol empire together for as long as they did and probably would no doubt have done so for much longer had they been better enforced by Genghis's successors.
In 1206 Genghis was given his title by his people and the next year he invaded Northern China and Korea, then ruled by the Chin and Tangut states. In 1215 the Chin capital, Zhongdu (at the site of present day Beijing), fell to the Mongols and was completely destroyed; this was the Mongols' first success in conquering a heavily fortified city (while being outnumbered 8 to 1). In 1218, after many provocations from its leader, Genghis declared war on Khwarezm (another 'barbarian' state that at that time ruled over present-day Afghanistan, Turkmenistan and Iran). In 1221 he had conquered the whole of the Khwarezmian empire and in the subsequent years the Mongols performed their first raids into present-day Russia. In 1227 the great Khan fell of his horse on a Chinese battlefield and died.
But wise as he was, Genghis did not die without leaving behind a will. He divided his empire amongst his sons and wanted Odegei to take over his position of Great Khan. He also left detailed strategical plans for the conquest of the whole of China (including the south, which was still ruled by the Sung) and Europe. The khuriltay approved Genghis's wishes and Odegei became Khan and set out to conquer the south of China. Once this was accomplished, Batu (Genghis's grandson), in the middle of the winder of 1236, set out for Russia. He conquered the Russian cities one by one and conquered eastern Europe as well. However, when the first Mongols had reached the outskirts of Vienna in 1242 a message arrived: Odegei had died and all Mongols would have to return to Karakorum to choose a new Great Khan, forcing Batu to abandon Genghis' strategy for the conquest of Europe. If it wasn't for this, the Mongols could well have conquered Europe entirely. Once Batu returned the momentum was gone and the Mongols could only consolidate and form the Golden Horde khanate (=province) in Russia, the only part of the empire in which the Mongols actually built a large number of great cities (in the rest of the empire they mostly relied on existing cities). In Persia the Il-Khan khanate was also formed (which would at its height as far west as present-day Turkey) while Central Asia became the Chaghatai khanate. China was conquered and ruled by Kublai Khan (a grandson of Genghis), founder of the Yuan dynasty. From this time forward, trade caravans could travel freely throughout the Mongol empire and an unprecedented cultural and scientific exchange took place between China, Persia and Europe (Pax Mongolica), which among other things accomplished that Europe was pulled out of the Dark Ages.
More armies were launched in many directions (Japan, Java, Egypt, Vietnam, etc) but all failed for different reasons (storms, treachery, etc). The various khanates increasingly grew apart because the descendants of Genghis struggled for power within the empire and Mongols everywhere increasingly adapted to the people they had conquered and thus alienated from each other. In 1260 Kublai moved the capital from Karakorum to the newly founded city of Dadu (aka Beijing, where Marco Polo served under him), thus alienating the other Mongols even further. Over time the various khanates grew weaker and weaker and were eventually conquered by local enemies, only the Golden Horde managed to hold out until 1502 (the others all ceased to exist before 1370). However, this is not the end of the Mongols. For one thing, the conquerors of the Il-Khan (the Timurids) were Mongols themselves and continued to rule this area until the early 16th century. The Moghul (or Mughal) dynasty that conquered the Indian subcontinent from 1520 onwards were Mongols as well. They established a great empire there which brought forth great leaders such as Akbar the Great and Shah Jehan (under whom the Taj Mahal was built). In the first half of the 18th century the power of the Moghul was greatly reduced by the Marathas and in 1858 they completely vanished from the Indian stage when the British officially took over control of India.
Capital: Karakorum - Capital of Mongolian empire
City Names:
Dadu - aka Beijing, Yuan Mongol Capital (Winter Palace)
Shangdu - Yuan Mongol 'Capital' (Summer Palace)
Sarai Batu - Early Golden Horde Capital
Sarai Berke - Late Golden Horde Capital
Tabriz - Old Capital of Il-Khan
Sultaniyya - New Capital of Il-Khan
Almalik - Chaghadai capital
Yihe Huree - modern Mongolia capital (aka Ulaanbataar/Niyslel Huree)
Samarkand - Capital of Timurids; Chaghadai city
Bukhara - Important Timurid city; Chaghadai city
Kashgar - Important Khwarezmian/Chaghadai city
Otrar - historically important Chaghadai city
Saray al-Dzedid - Major Volga (Golden Horde) city
Hadji-Tarkhan - Major Volga (Golden Horde) city
Beldzamen - Major Golden Horde city
Ukek - Major Golden Horde city (aka Ukaka)
Qrim - Major Golden Horde city (aka Solkhat/Surgat)
Azov - Golden Horde city (aka Tana)
Bulgar - Major Golden Horde city, Captured from Bulgarians
Kazan - Major Golden Horde city
Djuketau - Major Golden Horde city
Hangzhou - Important Yuan port city
Kaifeng - Important Yuan city
Chang'an - Important Yuan city
Herat - Important Il-Khan/Timurid city, place of large revolt
Kabul - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Hormuz - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Urgench - Golden Horde City
Orhei - Golden Horde city
Delhi - Indian Moghul Capital
Agra - Important Moghul city
Nishapur - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Kerman - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Aleppo - Il-Khan city
Amber - Moghul city
Lahore - Moghul city
Khiagt - Early Important modern Mongolian city
Darhan - Modern Mongolian industrial city
Erdenet - Modern Mongolian mining city
Choybalsan - Modern Mongolian industrial city
Hovd - Town in ancestral territory (i.e. near Onon river)
Uvs - Town in ancestral territory
Hovsgol - Town in ancestral territory
Dalan Balzhut - Mongolian Battlefield from Genghis's youth
Leignitz - Polish Battlefield (Golden Horde territory)
Wahlstadt - Hungarian Battlefield (Golden Horde territory)
Ayn Jalut - Egyptian Battlefield (Il-Khan territory)
Khalka - Russian Battlefield (Golden Horde territory)
Riazan - First Russian city to fall to Mongols (Golden Horde)
As examples to guide us in determining this and to show how I personally think this should roughly look like, I made examples for the Mongols and Spanish (see below), the two most popular civs in the poll. I modeled these examles after the 'Civ of the Week' feature on Civ3.com but I expanded a bit upon the concept. The setup I propose contains some 'technical' info on each civ, such as name, possible unique units and leaders, abilities, etc, and a very short (one or two sentences) mention of it's historical significance. This is followed by a somewhat more elaborate description (roughly 1000 words) of its history and achievements. I had hoped to put in the same amount of humor in the this as Firaxis puts in their CotW descriptions but either the civs I wrote about aren't particularly funny or I'm not... To finish things up, I also added a list of (50) suggestions for city names, roughly in the order in which they should also appear in the game (one might say this is not a very important issue but I'm still baffled by the incredible low quality of some city lists in Civ1/2 and CtP1/2). Of course, this setup is just a proposal and very much open for suggestions.
As far as contents of the two examples goes, this too is open for suggestions and improvements. Both examples can no doubt be improved upon, but personally I think the Mongol one is of fairly high quality (I've always been a greatly admired them and know far more about their history and culture than most people). OTOH, I have my doubts about the Spanish one (I find post Classical Age European history extremely boring so I know fairly little about them and had to rely almost entirely on Internet sources of which I can't really assess the quality) so quite possibly lots of room for improvement there. Any comments on either of them is most welcome, like I said, this is just a proposal, it's by no means final.
When we worked out the details for the general setup of this and are satisfied with the descriptions of the two example civs, similar descriptions can be made for all other civs from the top 16-32 (depending on how things develop). Volunteers for making these descriptions are most welcome but I suggest you only volunteer for civs you really like and/or know a lot about because my 'struggle' with the Spanish was one that I wouldn't want anyone else to go through
In short: read and (hopefully) enjoy and give me any feedback you have...
Red, green and orange parts have been edited as a result of the discussion below.
---------------
* The Mongols *
---------------
Names: Mongolian Empire, the Mongols, Mongol
Time Period: 1200 AD - 1750 AD (Medieval)
Leader: Genghis Khan - alternatives: Kublai Khan, Borte Khatun (f), Akbar the Great
Unique Unit: Horse Archer - alternatives: Composite Bowman, any kind of Medieval Seige weapon (Catapult, Ballista, Mangonel, Trebuchet, Battering Ram, Sapper, etc)
Great Leaders: Subedei, Chepe, Muqali - alternatives: Jelme, Khubilai
Abilities: Militaristic, Expansionist - alternative: Commercial
Historical significance:
Enormous empire that at it's height ruled over much of the Eurasian continent and had a large impact on Asian history from Medieval times onward.
Description:
History has not been kind on the Mongols. Many, historians and laymen alike, have always viewed them as primitive and terrible barbarians who did nothing but conquer, destroy, kill, pillage, plunder and commit all kinds of atrocities (and who disappeared as quickly as they came). All too often are their great accomplishments overlooked. Their military was in every way except size (they were virtually always severely outnumbered) superior to any opponent they ever encountered: their armor, weapons, their seige equipment, their tactics and strategies, their endurance, everything. And as shortlived as it may have been, the Mongols conquered the largest empire that ever existed (though some say the British empire was slightly larger, this just depends on how you measure it) and did this within a human lifetime. They also created a unified China and Russia, both still superpowers today, and made it possible for the Turks to rise to power in the Mediterranean area. And then there are their cultural accomplishments - often influenced by foreigners but distinctly Mongol nonetheless - things like the Great Yasa (see below), the yam (imperial postal system that continued to exist long after the Mongol empire had declined), their literary works ("Secret History of the Mongols", "Collection of Chronicles" et al), poems, artwork, scientific accomplishments (in areas such as mathematics, astronomy, agriculture, philosophy, theology, economics, etc) and construction projects (Taj Mahal and other Moghul construction projects, Beijing, Golden Horde and Central Asian cities). And let's face it, where would the world have been without the great sport that is polo?
But greatest of all was without a doubt their founding father Temuchin, better known under his title Genghis Khan. He was without a doubt one of the greatest, if not the greatest, conqueror and statesman in human history. He took a bunch of rivaling nomadic tribes, conquered them, managed to unite them all under the (back then meaningless) term 'Mongol' and with them conquered much of the Eurasian continent. Genghis didn't just rush into one battle after another like a brute and violent barbarian. On the contrary, he carefully planned each battle and each campaign, he knew exactly what he was doing and where he was going, he was a great strategist. Additionally, Genghis found the pursuit of knowledge very important and made sure the Mongols took advantage of every kind of new technology they encountered during their conquests (most famous examples: writing and siege warfare).
Already early on, Genghis realized very well that with all these different tribes and sedentary nations in his empire, it would not be long before disunity would cause his empire to fall apart. To prevent this, he wrote the Great Yasa, a book containing all the rules and regulations the Mongols had to follow. Although punishment for breaking them was very severe (which resulted in a virtually crime-free society), it was one of the most enlightened and civilized codes of law the world had seen until then. This code said that all people were to be judged by merit and ability rather than by birth or social position, it condemned racism and promoted religious freedom and women's rights (the most skilled Mongol women even fought in the army). Important decisions were to be made not by the Great Khan alone but by the khuriltay, a general assembly of the Mongolian aristorcracy plus other important people in the empire. Genghis even made rules about hygiene, drinking, the environment, combat and hospitality. His basic philosophy was that all men (and women) are equal and that people should always help each other, regardless of who or where they are. These laws kept the Mongol empire together for as long as they did and probably would no doubt have done so for much longer had they been better enforced by Genghis's successors.
In 1206 Genghis was given his title by his people and the next year he invaded Northern China and Korea, then ruled by the Chin and Tangut states. In 1215 the Chin capital, Zhongdu (at the site of present day Beijing), fell to the Mongols and was completely destroyed; this was the Mongols' first success in conquering a heavily fortified city (while being outnumbered 8 to 1). In 1218, after many provocations from its leader, Genghis declared war on Khwarezm (another 'barbarian' state that at that time ruled over present-day Afghanistan, Turkmenistan and Iran). In 1221 he had conquered the whole of the Khwarezmian empire and in the subsequent years the Mongols performed their first raids into present-day Russia. In 1227 the great Khan fell of his horse on a Chinese battlefield and died.
But wise as he was, Genghis did not die without leaving behind a will. He divided his empire amongst his sons and wanted Odegei to take over his position of Great Khan. He also left detailed strategical plans for the conquest of the whole of China (including the south, which was still ruled by the Sung) and Europe. The khuriltay approved Genghis's wishes and Odegei became Khan and set out to conquer the south of China. Once this was accomplished, Batu (Genghis's grandson), in the middle of the winder of 1236, set out for Russia. He conquered the Russian cities one by one and conquered eastern Europe as well. However, when the first Mongols had reached the outskirts of Vienna in 1242 a message arrived: Odegei had died and all Mongols would have to return to Karakorum to choose a new Great Khan, forcing Batu to abandon Genghis' strategy for the conquest of Europe. If it wasn't for this, the Mongols could well have conquered Europe entirely. Once Batu returned the momentum was gone and the Mongols could only consolidate and form the Golden Horde khanate (=province) in Russia, the only part of the empire in which the Mongols actually built a large number of great cities (in the rest of the empire they mostly relied on existing cities). In Persia the Il-Khan khanate was also formed (which would at its height as far west as present-day Turkey) while Central Asia became the Chaghatai khanate. China was conquered and ruled by Kublai Khan (a grandson of Genghis), founder of the Yuan dynasty. From this time forward, trade caravans could travel freely throughout the Mongol empire and an unprecedented cultural and scientific exchange took place between China, Persia and Europe (Pax Mongolica), which among other things accomplished that Europe was pulled out of the Dark Ages.
More armies were launched in many directions (Japan, Java, Egypt, Vietnam, etc) but all failed for different reasons (storms, treachery, etc). The various khanates increasingly grew apart because the descendants of Genghis struggled for power within the empire and Mongols everywhere increasingly adapted to the people they had conquered and thus alienated from each other. In 1260 Kublai moved the capital from Karakorum to the newly founded city of Dadu (aka Beijing, where Marco Polo served under him), thus alienating the other Mongols even further. Over time the various khanates grew weaker and weaker and were eventually conquered by local enemies, only the Golden Horde managed to hold out until 1502 (the others all ceased to exist before 1370). However, this is not the end of the Mongols. For one thing, the conquerors of the Il-Khan (the Timurids) were Mongols themselves and continued to rule this area until the early 16th century. The Moghul (or Mughal) dynasty that conquered the Indian subcontinent from 1520 onwards were Mongols as well. They established a great empire there which brought forth great leaders such as Akbar the Great and Shah Jehan (under whom the Taj Mahal was built). In the first half of the 18th century the power of the Moghul was greatly reduced by the Marathas and in 1858 they completely vanished from the Indian stage when the British officially took over control of India.
Capital: Karakorum - Capital of Mongolian empire
City Names:
Dadu - aka Beijing, Yuan Mongol Capital (Winter Palace)
Shangdu - Yuan Mongol 'Capital' (Summer Palace)
Sarai Batu - Early Golden Horde Capital
Sarai Berke - Late Golden Horde Capital
Tabriz - Old Capital of Il-Khan
Sultaniyya - New Capital of Il-Khan
Almalik - Chaghadai capital
Yihe Huree - modern Mongolia capital (aka Ulaanbataar/Niyslel Huree)
Samarkand - Capital of Timurids; Chaghadai city
Bukhara - Important Timurid city; Chaghadai city
Kashgar - Important Khwarezmian/Chaghadai city
Otrar - historically important Chaghadai city
Saray al-Dzedid - Major Volga (Golden Horde) city
Hadji-Tarkhan - Major Volga (Golden Horde) city
Beldzamen - Major Golden Horde city
Ukek - Major Golden Horde city (aka Ukaka)
Qrim - Major Golden Horde city (aka Solkhat/Surgat)
Azov - Golden Horde city (aka Tana)
Bulgar - Major Golden Horde city, Captured from Bulgarians
Kazan - Major Golden Horde city
Djuketau - Major Golden Horde city
Hangzhou - Important Yuan port city
Kaifeng - Important Yuan city
Chang'an - Important Yuan city
Herat - Important Il-Khan/Timurid city, place of large revolt
Kabul - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Hormuz - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Urgench - Golden Horde City
Orhei - Golden Horde city
Delhi - Indian Moghul Capital
Agra - Important Moghul city
Nishapur - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Kerman - Il-Khan/Timurid city
Aleppo - Il-Khan city
Amber - Moghul city
Lahore - Moghul city
Khiagt - Early Important modern Mongolian city
Darhan - Modern Mongolian industrial city
Erdenet - Modern Mongolian mining city
Choybalsan - Modern Mongolian industrial city
Hovd - Town in ancestral territory (i.e. near Onon river)
Uvs - Town in ancestral territory
Hovsgol - Town in ancestral territory
Dalan Balzhut - Mongolian Battlefield from Genghis's youth
Leignitz - Polish Battlefield (Golden Horde territory)
Wahlstadt - Hungarian Battlefield (Golden Horde territory)
Ayn Jalut - Egyptian Battlefield (Il-Khan territory)
Khalka - Russian Battlefield (Golden Horde territory)
Riazan - First Russian city to fall to Mongols (Golden Horde)
Comment