Job

[Ming]

Originally posted by DrSpike
Not good policy.

You are welcome to your opinion... but your opinion really doesn't count in these matters

[DrSpike]

Um, did you read that post? I said it would not be good policy to change a pcr after it had been decided.

[Ming]

Did you read my post I thought it was perfectly clear

[DrSpike]

One would presume you would echo my sentiments. So on reading your response I naturally assumed your chest-beating was the result of misreading my post. But even though my sentiment was reasonable and you presumably agree with it, you still felt the need to belittle the worth of my opinion as regards to yours. If so this is disappointing.

[Ming]

No I don't agree with it... we have changed PCR's after they have been handed out. We discuss it in the private forum, and sometimes, it is determinded that the penality was not harsh enough.

And I'm not "belittleing" your opinion at all... I'm just stating a fact. When it comes to punisments, the mods and Admin have the only opinions that matter. This isn't a democracy.

[DrSpike]

Originally posted by Ming
No I don't agree with it... we have changed PCR's after they have been handed out. We discuss it in the private forum, and sometimes, it is determinded that the penality was not harsh enough.

When it comes to punisments, the mods and Admin have the only opinions that matter. This isn't a democracy.

My statement was about the inadvisability of rescinding pcr's though.

To the second point I agree, and I have posted as such in the past. I have always felt though that should a mod/admin *choose* to discuss such matters it can benefit the community, if the discussion can be carried out in an orderly fashion.

But enough.......don't think this is going anywhere now, though there were some very good points made by both of us earlier.

[Ming]

You seem to be the one that has a misunderstanding here. You claim my 50% comment did me no credit.

I was just stating that I have given out higher than 10% PCR's before, implying that I agreed with your point that it should be different for different infractions... and my later post explained how different mods have different styles, and that's just the way it is.

My comment on whether you would like yours changed was followed by a wink... a joke son... A JOKE!

[DrSpike]

Well, the discussion was more fun than work at any rate, and there were some good points made earlier on, though I prefer it when you make those points instead of falling back on the staples.

Still I guess you can't discuss everyone's viewpoints on 'Poly policy with them......might get a bit chaotic....I'd probably come up with some shortcuts myself.......should I lose my sanity and agree to moderate forums such as these.

[Alexander's Horse]

Of course if Mark and Dan were thinking of giving me a Christmas gift, I think a few posts back would be the ideal choice

I've lost about 7000

[Ming]

And I'd be willing to bet that you will lose a bunch more in the future

[Alexander's Horse]

Ah to hell with postage, I'm going to buy myself one of those Apolyton caps for Christmas.

My way of saying "thanks" to Markos and Dan for all the fun this site has given me over the past few years

Keep up the good work boys