Avatars

[KrazyHorse]

Mods, my rights are being violated by the unauthorised use of an avatar I created. Original picture was specifically public domain. I put work into resizing, cropping and saving as different file format. This gives me copyright on resulting image at least until I die. Mr. Fun's unauthorised use of said kitten avatar is unlawful, and your facilitation of said unauthorised use is also unlawful. I politely request that action be taken, as Mr. Fun has ignored my repeated pleas for withdrawal of his current avatar.

Thank you for your consideration.

[Skanky Burns]

My feeling is he thought you were joking with your requests. Did you try PMing him?
Benefit: He probably wouldn't ignore you.
Cons: You don't increase your post-count.

[Ming]

Hmmmm.... Some interesting points your raise...

I could go either way on this issue.

On one hand, it is a public domain photo. The fact that you resized it and cropped it doesn't really change that. Public domain means just that... ANYBODY can do what they want with it.

Yet on the other hand, since you have used it for a long time, one could argue that your handle and avatar are synonymous and that you do have certain rights to it on these forums.

In addition, one must look at the "intent" behind its use to judge if it is being used in a way which violates forum rules. IMHO, in this case, it is not being used to Flame you, or to attack you. While it's use might irate you... I don't think it is violating any forum rules.

So you raise some valid questions. While the owners of this site have given me some flexibilty in the determination of acceptable and not acceptable avatars... I would love to hear their opinions on the subject.

Personally, I agree with you. Based on your long use of it, and the fact that everytime I see the avatar, I think you are posting.

So unless MarkG or DanQ have a different opinion, I will request that he stop using it. But not until the owners have had a chance to respond to this. Probably a day or two. And who knows, by then, the "joke" may have run it's course, and no action will even be needed.

That's my two cents worth. Any other opinions will be listened to.

DISCUSS...

[Ari Rahikkala]

Simple solution: Ban Eli's avatar so that KH can move back to the kitten and MrFun may go back to his avatar.

[TCO]

Oh come on! Power to the people. Keep the kitty free!

Ming, don't go down this road. Next thing you will have to stop Stefu from dropping his anvil on Galis's avatar...

[Ming]

Originally posted by GP
Ming, don't go down this road.

The problem is, we have already gone down that road. We don't allow user handles that are specifically aimed at making fun of another member... and we have already "restricted" the use of certain types of avatars (ie, those that use Nazi symbols or others that can be perceived as hatefull).

So pandora's box is already open...

Also, please note that I said I would "request" that he change it

[Colon™]

If Krazyhorse gets his kitten back, I demand all rights on avatars featuring cookies and chocolates from then on.

[Chris 62]

I have to disagree, Ming.

Pictures cannot be moderated in this manor.

I wouldn't care if somebody used my airborne patch, nor the others I use elseware, it's the height of arrogance to claim a picture is your personal property because you used it for a bit.

Did Krazy take the picture himself?

If not, he's a hypocrit, for he's stealing someone else's work.

Freedom for all avatars, with the exceptions you mentioned, Ming, and my own disclaimer about photograpghs of members (these should only be allowed to whomever they belong too).

Thumbs down to this bit of nazism.

Let the kitten roam free, let no person infringe on another's freedom.

I might add it's a mockery that Krazy is attempting to force not one but TWO people to bow down to him, Eli and Mr Fun.

Seig heil.

[drake]

Give me a goddamned break KH

[orange]

I agree with KrazyHorse 100%

[Chris 62]

Originally posted by orange
I agree with KrazyHorse 100%

Well done, Orange, I fully support your new avatar.

[Locutus]

I have to agree with Chriss and GP (and others) here. Those of us who don' t have the right to use custom avatars also share avatars all the time. Claiming rights on a public domain picture is silly. What if someone on CG would use this avatar? Noone could stop that... Unless avatars are making fun of or insulting people or otherwise break the site's rules, I think they should be free.

[Grrr]

... and we have already "restricted" the use of certain types of avatars (ie, those that use Nazi symbols or others that can be perceived as hatefull).

I noticed .

[Lonestar]

While we're on the subject of Avatars, I'd like my custom avatar privilage returned before I leave for Basic Training Mingster.

[General Ludd]

Guys, he's only being half-serious.

(Atleast, it seems that way to me...)