Some news

[Jamski]

Jamski has ben authorized in CYCON since the day this thread was posted.

So why do we continue the debate?

Because I'm still waiting for authorisiation to join.

The "security of Hive information" is a non-argument, and you know it Tass. There's no difference between me being in the CPU or Not being in the CPU in terms of what information I know and what I could tell the CPU. There's nothing stopping me sending e-mails, PMs or chat messages to the CPU leadership, except my own sense of fairplay. Being in the faction would not change the probablity of me soilling the beans in any way.

-Jam

[Skanky Burns]

Yes has the highest percentage so far...

[Jamski]

When is the poll open untill?

-Jam

[GeoModder]

Originally posted by Impaler[WrG]
Tropical Islands have Bears???

Koala beers.

[Skanky Burns]

Drop bears.

[GeoModder]

Originally posted by Skanky Burns
Drop bears.

Only when they lose their grip on a branch

[Mead]

Originally posted by Comrade Tassadar
Don't vote no!
Vote for "Let Tass" decide. No is not going to win!

Tass,

Please change my vote to whatever ensures people stay with the team they joined.

I trust you to do what's best.


Mead

[FlameFlash]

Heh.

Tass, if we followed through with all of your reasons, especially the password thing, you'd never have become a god as you would have been banned from everything.

While granted I don't know what the maps look like for every faction, logically the largest and oldest are usually the best producers... same goes for the crawler parks. A couple fly-overs with a kamikazi noodle and either side's maps are available to Hive or CPU too. So map locations aren't that big of a deal.

[Nubclear]

Originally posted by FlameFlash
Tass, if we followed through with all of your reasons, especially the password thing, you'd never have become a god as you would have been banned from everything.

Such is true however, such is also largely irrelevant

While granted I don't know what the maps look like for every faction, logically the largest and oldest are usually the best producers... same goes for the crawler parks. A couple fly-overs with a kamikazi noodle and either side's maps are available to Hive or CPU too. So map locations aren't that big of a deal.

You could do that, but would that not cost you something? Indeed it would, and as such you might not do it due to the costs, thus the information still pertains.

[FlameFlash]

It's just, Tass, your entire premise of not letting this happen is based on not trusting people.

If Jam or HongHu wanted to, they could already do everything you claim might happen if they join CPU and PEACE. Which to me, means there's something wrong with those reasons.

If you gave me a clear reason why it would be bad for the game other than the fact that information that already can be divulged no matter what is divulged, I'd happily change my vote back to going with a 'no' or 'let Tass decide'.

And that would certainly tie it up.

[FlameFlash]

Talking with Tass via MSN he's given me... well, he's given me nothing really, except that our Tassgod's gut aches against this happening...

I really hate flip-flopping like this, but given the lack of an impression from Tass (he's very aware of not saying anything... too aware, methinks... but oh well) I'm going to have to change again...

I hate flip-flopping... but I'll go out on a limb and turst the gut 'o Tass.

(note that everything above was garnered via a very lack of Tass pointing fingers or anything... he was especially non-commital on any question, and even my inference that it's with a 'gut feeling' and other info available to him but not me had to be an inference... May the force be with you, Tass. )

[Jamski]

/me sighs at Tass's personal vendetta against him *

-Jam

[Mead]

Originally posted by Comrade Tassadar
Don't vote no!
Vote for "Let Tass" decide. No is not going to win!

Tass,

I thought a vote for "Let Tass/Googlie Decide" meant that you two could Add those votes to the 'No' or 'Yes' votes.

So for example:

If there were:

No - 7
Yes - 9
Let Tass/Googlie decide - 9

Then you could add your 9 votes to either the 'No' or 'Yes' votes to come up with the final outcome.


Mead

[Jamski]

I vote let GOOGLIE decide

-Jam

[Trithemius]

I voted for "Let him if CPU wants him" - which in my mind is the only reasonable choice. People can consider my vote to be a "Yes" though.