FG: Go 16: Sign up thread

[Hercules]

Re the Default issue;

I think the last known individual default position should hold.

The given start default position is neutral, neutral so unless that is changed by the player that becomes that player's default position.

RE Homebases I vote A.

[Ljube]

Joncha has obviously brainwashed poor, innocent, tender Jaguar.

[Ljube]

Originally posted by Hercules
Re the Default issue;

I think the last known individual default position should hold.

The given start default position is neutral, neutral so unless that is changed by the player that becomes that player's default position.

Meaning A?

[joncha]

The are several options, not just two. Hence the multiple choice. I don't think it's a difficult concept.

A. Maximum defaults.
B. Some defaults.
C. No defaults at all, dire consequences.
D. No defaults, but not-so-dire consequences.

How is that a biased poll?

[civman2000]

Ugh...very badly done poll, though not to the point that it won't work.

1. A, though I wouldn't mind C. I'm not sure I would play if B won.
2. I don't care other than that I think D is a terrible idea...so can my vote be a negative one against D?

[joncha]

Originally posted by Ljube



Meaning A?

I think that means D, actually.

[joncha]

Originally posted by civman2000
Ugh...very badly done poll, though not to the point that it won't work.

1. A, though I wouldn't mind C. I'm not sure I would play if B won.
2. I don't care other than that I think D is a terrible idea...so can my vote be a negative one against D?

B is what we had last time.

[joncha]

Originally posted by Ljube
The simplest solution would be to make a run-off between two best placed options, even if one of them won a majority (but not absolute majority).

I didn't see this post.

I'm fine with a run-off between the top two if none gets an outright majority. I've been arguing against snoopy's spreadsheety "solution".

[Ljube]

Originally posted by joncha


I think that means D, actually.

It surely does not mean D.

[Ljube]

Originally posted by joncha


B is what we had last time.

A is what we had last time.

Joncha, you keep perverting things and confusing people so that more votes would be cast in favour of your untenable proposals. Look what you did to poor Jaguar. You baffled him completely.

[joncha]

D is the option for a set default that applies to everyone equally. That can conceivably be "last orders received" I guess (which is what I think he was saying). If that isn't what he meant, then I have no idea what option to make it.

[joncha]

Originally posted by Ljube



A is what we had last time.

Joncha, you keep perverting things and confusing people so that more votes would be cast in favour of your untenable proposals. Look what you did to poor Jaguar. You baffled him completely.

No. It is not. Last game I only allowed default OoBs and not default orders. Enough of your lies and obfuscations!

[Ljube]

Originally posted by Hercules
I think the last known individual default position should hold.

The given start default position is neutral, neutral so unless that is changed by the player that becomes that player's default position.

This is equivalent to:

Originally posted by joncha

Galactic Overlord
A New Forum Game from
Jamski Productions


*****


Each player may send in default orders. He must clearly indicate his intention to use these orders in case he fails to issue regular orders by titling the orders as Default Orders. Every time a player issues default orders, the previous default orders are superseded.


*****

Which I believe is closest to A. That's why I asked Hercules to clarify his vote.

[Hercules]

Edit : I got a bit confused with default OoB and default range and formation.

I tend to favour last known OoB as the default

[Ljube]

There are four options Hercules and your reply should be A, B, C or D.