We still lack thumbs and fingers, and thus manual dexterity (or "main"s (hands) at all...) to do things like create poison or pour it into anything. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/da709/da7093a9dae8542dc9468a98b9635ce35a2a0448" alt="Smile"
Post-smurfing, assuming I was smurffed, it's certainly possible, but there's no way I'm mafia #1. Not without Gargamel's knowledge anyway, given the beginning of the story. Ignore Ljube's story all you want, but there's no way I'm the only remaining mafia (mafia #1).
I was hesitant to think it was Gargamel at first too, for a similar reason - but there's a chance he could have done it, as he could have slipped the poison in earlier when we weren't watching. Azrael is a cat, and thus doesn't tend to notice things like that, usually preening himself and jumping after shiny things. Gargamel, though, was with Azrael and would have prevented me (well, probably would have helped ... but he would have KNOWN about it)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/da709/da7093a9dae8542dc9468a98b9635ce35a2a0448" alt="Smile"
Post-smurfing, assuming I was smurffed, it's certainly possible, but there's no way I'm mafia #1. Not without Gargamel's knowledge anyway, given the beginning of the story. Ignore Ljube's story all you want, but there's no way I'm the only remaining mafia (mafia #1).
I was hesitant to think it was Gargamel at first too, for a similar reason - but there's a chance he could have done it, as he could have slipped the poison in earlier when we weren't watching. Azrael is a cat, and thus doesn't tend to notice things like that, usually preening himself and jumping after shiny things. Gargamel, though, was with Azrael and would have prevented me (well, probably would have helped ... but he would have KNOWN about it)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/da709/da7093a9dae8542dc9468a98b9635ce35a2a0448" alt="Smile"
Comment