From: Chairman Sheng-ji Yang of the Hive
To: Prime Function Aki-Zeta 5
You are a rational being, Aki Zeta. In many ways, you have a greater capacity for rationality than I. Therefore, look, and ask yourself, why do we really have such strong feelings on the use of Nerve gas? Does it really serve any humane purpose, or is it a senseless taboo from previous times? Almost three hundred years ago, at the Hague convention, Alfred Mayhan explained his opposition to a ban on poison gas thus:
[quote]
It was illogical, and not demonstrably humane, to be tender about asphyxiating men with gas when all were prepared to admit that it was allowable to blow the bottom out of an ironclad at midnight, throwing four of five hundred men into the sea, to be choked by the water, with scarcley the remotest chance to escape.
[quote]
I ask you, what is the real cause of your opposition to nerve gas? All are prepared to admit that the use of mindworms to inspire the greatest terrors imaginable in the hearts of men, and to destroy and then devour their very brains, is perfectly acceptable. We agree that burning men alive with napalm is a legal action in war, as is drowning the crew of a ship in the sea. Yet we maintain a purposeless taboo against Nerve gas. The Peacekeepers' slavish upholding of this taboo caused them great suffering when they failed to make use of this useful weapon against the hated Spartan Junta. Therefore, again I ask you, what is it about Nerve gas which makes it so terrible?
To: Prime Function Aki-Zeta 5
You are a rational being, Aki Zeta. In many ways, you have a greater capacity for rationality than I. Therefore, look, and ask yourself, why do we really have such strong feelings on the use of Nerve gas? Does it really serve any humane purpose, or is it a senseless taboo from previous times? Almost three hundred years ago, at the Hague convention, Alfred Mayhan explained his opposition to a ban on poison gas thus:
[quote]
It was illogical, and not demonstrably humane, to be tender about asphyxiating men with gas when all were prepared to admit that it was allowable to blow the bottom out of an ironclad at midnight, throwing four of five hundred men into the sea, to be choked by the water, with scarcley the remotest chance to escape.
[quote]
I ask you, what is the real cause of your opposition to nerve gas? All are prepared to admit that the use of mindworms to inspire the greatest terrors imaginable in the hearts of men, and to destroy and then devour their very brains, is perfectly acceptable. We agree that burning men alive with napalm is a legal action in war, as is drowning the crew of a ship in the sea. Yet we maintain a purposeless taboo against Nerve gas. The Peacekeepers' slavish upholding of this taboo caused them great suffering when they failed to make use of this useful weapon against the hated Spartan Junta. Therefore, again I ask you, what is it about Nerve gas which makes it so terrible?
Comment