CHRISTMAS MOVIES HURT OR HEAL - RUDOLPH'S REVENGE

[-Jrabbit]

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
16 - Scrooged ++
11 - A Christmas Carol
11 - Miracle on 34th Street
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
3 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer - -
11 - Elf
8 - White Christmas - -
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
14 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special --

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause

I've decided that, at least for me, TV specials don't count as movies. Otherwise I'd be touting "A Colbert Christmas: The Greatest Gift of All."

[ZEE]

I am not playing this game, but it seems people are adding 2 points instead of 1.

EDIT: I missed EPW's post. Carry on.

[Donegeal]

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
16 - Scrooged
11 - A Christmas Carol
11 - Miracle on 34th Street
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
3 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer
7 - Elf ----
8 - White Christmas
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
16 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special ++

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause

I'm sorry but I think Elf is one of the stupidest movies of all time.

[Dinner]

It's a wonderful life +2

Bad Santa -2

[Broken_Erika]

Whole list plz.

[Jon Miller]

While I agree with removing from Elf, we can't remove 4 in one go.

JM

[Jon Miller]

Every single listed movie I have seen on TV and only on TV. If I have seen it.

JM

[EPW]

ELF is great. plz stop.

[EPW]

I can't fix the list right now. Someone add two votes back to elf plz

[Donegeal]

I thought we were doubling the votes. -4 +2 instead of -2 +1. If we're not I apologize.

[EPW]

Two negative votes max per movie, 4 total. You have time to change it.

[EPW]

also ignore dinners vote since he's obviously not paying attention

[EPW]

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
16 - Scrooged
11 - A Christmas Carol
11 - Miracle on 34th Street
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
3 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer
11 - Elf ++ (removed donegeal extra votes --- he can revote if he so desires)
6 - White Christmas --
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
14 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special --

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause

[Jon Miller]

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
16 - Scrooged
11 - A Christmas Carol
11 - Miracle on 34th Street
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
1 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer --
11 - Elf
4 - White Christmas --
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
16 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special ++

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause

JM

[Donegeal]

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
16 - Scrooged
11 - A Christmas Carol
11 - Miracle on 34th Street
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
1 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer --
9 - Elf --
2 - White Christmas --
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
18 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special ++

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause

Sorry for my confusion. I messed up on my previous vote so I'll just leave it. Still dislike Elf. A lot.

[Ming]

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
18 - Scrooged ++
11 - A Christmas Carol
11 - Miracle on 34th Street
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
1 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer --
9 - Elf --
6 - White Christmas
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
14 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause

[EPW]

This is an arithmetic tragedy

[Jon Miller]

Hi Ming, is that a previous step or did we mess up?

JM

[-Jrabbit]

The numbering is all screwed up; I did the best I could without spending my morning trying to parse this. My +/- marks are correct. If Rudolph is already gone, please transfer that single ( - ) to the Charlie Brown TV special.

10 - Die Hard
12 - A Wonderful Life
18 - Scrooged
11 - A Christmas Carol
13 - Miracle on 34th Street + +
11 - National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation
0 - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer -
7 - Elf - -
6 - White Christmas
10 - The Nightmare before Christmas
14 - Polar express
13 - The Charlie Brown Christmas special -

Out
1st: Die Hard 2: Die Harder
2nd: Bad Santa
3rd: Home Alone
4th: A Christmas Story
5th - The Santa Clause
6th - Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer

[EPW]

Well done!