Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prediction Thread: When Will Russia Conquer Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • BeBMan
    replied
    Originally posted by PLATO View Post
    I think we all thought Russia's victory was inevitable. Of course, it would have been hard to predict the amount of weapons support Ukraine is getting from the West so it may have been somewhat justified. At this point, I think Ukraine has a decent chance if Western aid continues. Still too many variables to really tell at this point. The Ukrainians sure do seem to be fighting harder than the Russians though...
    I certainly thought Russia would make more, and faster progress. How wrong I was

    IIRC there were military folks before the war who thought the war would turn into an endless guerilla style thing when Ukraine's regular military had been defeated.

    But many also pointed out that the estimated no. of troops Russia had on Ukraine's borders in late Feb would simply not be enough to occupy a country of the size of Ukraine, since the invader would need a large numerical advantage over the defender.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Dauphin View Post
    That can be re-parsed with one change:

    The problem for Vietnam and the enormous advantage for the USA that makes a US victory continue to seem inevitable is that while the US can reach out and destroy almost any part of the Vietnam economy and infrastructure, Vietnam can barely scratch the US in return. The US can maintain an entire large economy with a large military sector and keep sending it into Vietnam but Vietnam is almost totally dependent on foreign aid.

    If the US out-waits the foreign aid, Vietnam collapses as a state.



    My point, I think is that Russia has to have the wherewithal to take the losses it is taking. Can Putin afford to let this run for months, years. etc....
    If Vietnam had been a neighboring state and the US had leadership that could cling to power like Putin Vietnam would have been screwed. The US was also quite unwilling to conquer or attempt to conquer the north. Russia views all of Ukraine as fair game. If anything the comparisons to Vietnam make Ukraine's situation appear even more severe.

    Leave a comment:


  • Broken_Erika
    commented on 's reply
    That can also be said about the French vs. Vietnamese, Chinese vs. Vietnamese and Mongols vs. Vietnamese.... Or any war against Afghanistan.

  • Dauphin
    replied
    That can be re-parsed with one change:

    The problem for Vietnam and the enormous advantage for the USA that makes a US victory continue to seem inevitable is that while the US can reach out and destroy almost any part of the Vietnam economy and infrastructure, Vietnam can barely scratch the US in return. The US can maintain an entire large economy with a large military sector and keep sending it into Vietnam but Vietnam is almost totally dependent on foreign aid.

    If the US out-waits the foreign aid, Vietnam collapses as a state.



    My point, I think is that Russia has to have the wherewithal to take the losses it is taking. Can Putin afford to let this run for months, years. etc....

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    Originally posted by Dauphin View Post

    I don't think it was that a military win was inevitable so much as a war goal would be achieved - a forced concession or de facto annexation of captured territory. My recollection from back in February was that most informed observers thought that if Ukraine could survive two weeks, it would survive indefinitely in a slogfest.

    I don't think anyone expected Ukraine to take the fight to Russia (see sinking ships, Crimean airfields, etc), or retain/recapture Donbass.

    I don't think Russia expected the economic response - the willingness of Europe to forego Russian hydrocarbons. That may not last come winter.....(but I expect it will largely hold the line)
    The problem for Ukraine and the enormous advantage for Russia that makes a Russian victory continue to seem inevitable is that while Russia can reach out and destroy almost any part of the Ukrainian economy and infrastructure, Ukraine can barely scratch Russia in return. Russia can maintain an entire large economy with a large military sector and keep sending it into Ukraine but Ukraine is almost totally dependent on foreign aid.

    If Russia out-waits the foreign aid, Ukraine collapses as a state.

    Leave a comment:


  • EPW
    commented on 's reply
    | I think we all thought Russia's victory was inevitable.

    I think if you look at the poll at the beginning of this thread you'll see that's not true for 3 of us.

  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by PLATO View Post
    I think we all thought Russia's victory was inevitable. Of course, it would have been hard to predict the amount of weapons support Ukraine is getting from the West so it may have been somewhat justified. At this point, I think Ukraine has a decent chance if Western aid continues. Still too many variables to really tell at this point. The Ukrainians sure do seem to be fighting harder than the Russians though...
    I don't think it was that a military win was inevitable so much as a war goal would be achieved - a forced concession or de facto annexation of captured territory. My recollection from back in February was that most informed observers thought that if Ukraine could survive two weeks, it would survive indefinitely in a slogfest.

    I don't think anyone expected Ukraine to take the fight to Russia (see sinking ships, Crimean airfields, etc), or retain/recapture Donbass.

    I don't think Russia expected the economic response - the willingness of Europe to forego Russian hydrocarbons. That may not last come winter.....(but I expect it will largely hold the line)

    Leave a comment:


  • Uncle Sparky
    replied
    According to Russian state media, Gorbachev is dead. So, he was probably about to condemn Russian war crimes in Ukraine.

    Leave a comment:


  • Geronimo
    replied
    I would love to see Anders Puck Nielsen debate both of judge Andrew Napolitanos guests.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ming
    replied
    Sure they are fighting harder than the Russians... they are defending their home land and trying to protect their people from Russian war crimes.. While the Russians know that what they are doing is evil and don't even want to be there.

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    I think we all thought Russia's victory was inevitable. Of course, it would have been hard to predict the amount of weapons support Ukraine is getting from the West so it may have been somewhat justified. At this point, I think Ukraine has a decent chance if Western aid continues. Still too many variables to really tell at this point. The Ukrainians sure do seem to be fighting harder than the Russians though...

    Leave a comment:


  • BlackCat
    replied
    Interesting analysis of Serb and what it will take for him to get normal

    Leave a comment:


  • pchang
    replied
    I’m sure everything is proceeding as planned.

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    replied
    Originally posted by Serb View Post
    You have missed my confession about my meeting with president Reagan.
    I saw that and thought it was a great story! I met him once at an event in Nashville and got to hear him speak in person. He was truly amazing!

    Leave a comment:


  • PLATO
    commented on 's reply
    Sometimes it is so hard to tell if your are a liar, deceived, or just stupid.
Working...
X