Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

So how long will Ben last this time?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Arguments can be rational and still wrong, Aeson. Arguments can be irrational and correct.
    We are specifically talking about racism and misogyny. Racism is irrational. Misogyny is irrational.

    You think they are rational. That's part of why I say you are racist and misogynist ... the other reasons being the many instances of you expressing yourself in racist and misogynist ways.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Horsey, what do you say about this crap BK is spewing. I can't believe that anyone else believed that crap. He's lying about protestantism. I can tell you that much.

    Leave a comment:


  • NICE MOBIUS
    replied
    Originally posted by NICE MOBIUS View Post
    What part of 'blanket statement' don't you understand!?

    Concentrating exclusively on women staying at home to look after children younger than school age, I imagine many would if that was their choice. I think it is obvious that in an optimum scenario that one parent was able to look after their children at home at least until school age, but that their careers shouldn't necessarily be penalised for doing so. Hence why so many European countries have the sorts of commie socialist childcare options that would be anathema to cold-hearted capitalists like you.

    The point is that you didn't make that distinction, you implied that women would be happy being stay at home housewives whether there were children or not. I imagine if, god forbid, you got married, you'd be happy coming home to a cooked meal after work and all the household chores done for you except the 'man stuff'...

    Any parent wants what's best for their child. Personally I believe that an optimum scenario if affordable by the parents is for at least one of them to be able to stay at home bringing up the child at least until he or she is of school age. The major difference with you is that I make no distinction whether that is the mother or the father.

    You need to think in less sexist terms.
    What's wrong, Ben, my post doesn't warrant a response?

    I shall assume that's a tacit admission that I am right... and you need to buck up your ideas about women...

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    You clearly said that women are superior. You said you would have no reason to live without women. You said you believe in your religion because women brought you to it. You have a serious problem. God does not favor women.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    You clearly said that women are superior.
    Where?

    You said you would have no reason to live without women.
    Indeed I did. For they brought me into this world.

    You said you believe in your religion because women brought you to it. You have a serious problem. God does not favor women.
    Then why is Mary called, most blessed?

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    And it doesn't matter what gender they are. Did Christ not say in Heaven there are neither male or female?
    .

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Uh, I was a protestant.



    I stated that you despise the Theotokos and claim that we worship her. I did not accuse you of thinking that women are inferior, but rather, that there is nothing special about women and that men and women are no different. This is contrary to what scripture teaches that men and women are unique. This is a good thing. Catholics believe that women have special graces and men have special graces and that these God-given graces ought to be cultivated, not denied.



    No, sir. I am right about this. I was a Protestant.
    It doesn't matter that you were a protestant. You're a damn liar!

    Furthermore, no protestants believe that women aren't different you lying *******!

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I didn't specify a timeframe. There are many instances of royal incestuous relationships throughout history.
    Not in Europe. You are aware that for most of medieval Europe that the Pope forbade anything more than 4th order consanguinity?

    routinely blighted the world with is your ideal government
    Constitutional monarchy is not a bad form of government. My ideal government would have a mixture of what Canada has, and what the US has, with an elected Senate with equal regional representation, and an elected House of Commons, followed with the Queen of the head of state, and defender of the Catholic Faith. I hope that one day I'll live to see that.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    Ah ... so now the "more contemporary" view should supercede the original intent? But just a while ago you were claiming the original intent of the founders was most important. Why the sudden change of heart? Oh, right! Because you were wrong and your own criteria disproved your stance!
    I claim that the original intent of the Constitution is to affirm the inalienable rights of all, not just free white men. Are you asserting otherwise?

    It quite clearly did not apply to non-white men, or women, as originally applied. History happened as it did, deal with it.
    Does it make the distinction between Free men and slaves? Does it say, "inalienable rights to white men"? It does not. Ergo, I conclude that it was the intent of the Founders to phrase it as it does.

    Not in regards to our discussion on whether "natural born citizen" can apply to citizens by birth born outside the US. That is solely determined by whether "natural born citizen" can apply to citizens by birth born outside the US.
    Yes, except that the same law denies that all men are created equal. Ergo I can only conclude that the greater law supercedes the lesser. We cannot simply take the part of the law we like and discard the parts we do not, we must consider the law as it was written in it's entirety order to truly understand why it was written that way.

    Again, I already asserted the intent of the law, and the intent is vastly different from yours. Ergo, I can only conclude that the law doesn't advance your cause in the slightest. It is a blind alley.

    You're just casting up strawmen to try to distract from the fact that you were obviously wrong by your own stated measure.
    I'm amused that you're citing, voluntarily, laws that you believe are racist and misogynist in defense of your own arguments.

    (I want to point out I don't just believe you are a racist and misogynist ... it's something that is a very obviously fact given your posting history.)
    Indeed, it is a fact that you believe I am racist and misogynist. I do not contest that in the slightest.

    You are a cherry picking hypocrite backtracking from the logic you were previously using to pick a source.
    No, I'm just someone who happens to have read the opinions of the founders regarding slavery and is aware that the intent was explicitly to affirm that inalienable rights are not limited by race. Shall I quote your beloved Jefferson?

    The law of 1790 wasn't overturned by SCOTUS (the actual method where something is deemed to "not uphold the constitution of the united states"). It was updated, it's a very different thing.
    It was superceded. That is a very specific word. I argue that the Fourteenth applies the constitution correctly with regards to the laws concerning naturalization. That it specifically affirms natural born citizenship based on where you are born, not your race is a problem for you. But then, I'm not the one arguing against the Fourteenth.

    That's just another strawman you've erected to try to distract from the fact you were wrong.
    You explicitly stated that I must be a racist because I argued that I understood their rationale behind their arguments, IE, that they believed that it was important to maintain the European culture of the United States at the time. This is a logical fallacy.

    Arguments can be rational and still wrong, Aeson. Arguments can be irrational and correct.

    You want to pretend that it's rational to only want white men to be citizens. It isn't rational. It's racist and misogynist. You can't see that because you are racist and misogynist.
    No, Aeson, we have a fundamental disagreement concerning the application of reason and truth. I've stated before that not all truth is rational. Some is, yes, but human reason is limited.

    Kant, fwiw, says the same thing. He would be helpful to understand where I am coming from.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    The problem is that this theory doesn't bear up when looking at the pedigrees of most European nobles at the time.
    I didn't specify a timeframe. There are many instances of royal incestuous relationships throughout history.

    I would make the argument that they understood quite well the principles of consolidation (ie, doubling up on good lines), and outcrossing every third generation. People were used to animal husbandry and quite skilled at that. European nobility did the same.
    And the mad tyrants they routinely blighted the world with is your ideal government

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    No. You are lying about Protestants.
    Uh, I was a protestant.

    No protestants believe women are inferior. NONE!
    I stated that you despise the Theotokos and claim that we worship her. I did not accuse you of thinking that women are inferior, but rather, that there is nothing special about women and that men and women are no different. This is contrary to what scripture teaches that men and women are unique. This is a good thing. Catholics believe that women have special graces and men have special graces and that these God-given graces ought to be cultivated, not denied.

    This is how bigots talk. You are like the KKK lying about what black people believe and how they are trying to destroy the white culture. You're a bigot!
    No, sir. I am right about this. I was a Protestant.

    Leave a comment:


  • Aeson
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    I stated that the understanding at the time of the constitution was that there was a distinction for natural born citizens that applied to them being born inside the United States. I was able to show this through my earlier quote of one of the discussions surrounding the 14th Amendment. Which, naturally, sought to supercede the earlier standard of restricting citizenship based on race and replacing it with one based on the location where one was born.
    Ah ... so now the "more contemporary" view should supercede the original intent? But just a while ago you were claiming the original intent of the founders was most important. Why the sudden change of heart? Oh, right! Because you were wrong and your own criteria disproved your stance!

    The Constitution does not defend discrimination on race, it does not say that only 'free men' are to be recognized in their God given rights. It says that all have been granted by God inalienable rights.
    It quite clearly did not apply to non-white men, or women, as originally applied. History happened as it did, deal with it.

    So it matters not a whit that the law specifically excludes anyone who isn't white?
    Not in regards to our discussion on whether "natural born citizen" can apply to citizens by birth born outside the US. That is solely determined by whether "natural born citizen" can apply to citizens by birth born outside the US.

    You're just casting up strawmen to try to distract from the fact that you were obviously wrong by your own stated measure.

    No. You believe that I am racist and misogynist. Those are two different things, Aeson.
    Thus the "AND", you moron.

    (I want to point out I don't just believe you are a racist and misogynist ... it's something that is a very obviously fact given your posting history.)

    Nonsense, I argue that the law you quoted did not uphold the constitution of the united states, and thus was superceded by the Fourteenth, which the Constitution anticipated. Of course, I say that because I believe that the Constitution protects the rights of everyone, not just Free white men.
    You are a cherry picking hypocrite backtracking from the logic you were previously using to pick a source. The law of 1790 wasn't overturned by SCOTUS (the actual method where something is deemed to "not uphold the constitution of the united states"). It was updated, it's a very different thing.

    That being said, I'm curious why you're arguing the fallacy that only arguments you agree with are rational arguments.
    That's just another strawman you've erected to try to distract from the fact you were wrong.

    You want to pretend that it's rational to only want white men to be citizens. It isn't rational. It's racist and misogynist. You can't see that because you are racist and misogynist.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ben Kenobi
    replied
    I claimed hereditary rule has an innate pressure to consolidate power by marrying close relations.
    The problem is that this theory doesn't bear up when looking at the pedigrees of most European nobles at the time. I would make the argument that they understood quite well the principles of consolidation (ie, doubling up on good lines), and outcrossing every third generation. People were used to animal husbandry and quite skilled at that. European nobility did the same.

    I've already cited the example of James VI/I who founded the Stuart dynasty of England who was only 12.5 percent inbred. This is not particularly notable nor unusual.

    Leave a comment:


  • NICE MOBIUS
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    Yes. 47 percent of women staying at home with their children who are younger than 6 is an indication that many do want to stay at home. I did not say most. I said many. I'm not sure why that is controversial.
    What part of 'blanket statement' don't you understand!?

    Concentrating exclusively on women staying at home to look after children younger than school age, I imagine many would if that was their choice. I think it is obvious that in an optimum scenario that one parent was able to look after their children at home at least until school age, but that their careers shouldn't necessarily be penalised for doing so. Hence why so many European countries have the sorts of commie socialist childcare options that would be anathema to cold-hearted capitalists like you.

    The point is that you didn't make that distinction, you implied that women would be happy being stay at home housewives whether there were children or not. I imagine if, god forbid, you got married, you'd be happy coming home to a cooked meal after work and all the household chores done for you except the 'man stuff'...

    Mhmm, I was surprised that number was as high as it was. So that should lead you to believe that I thought that number would be considerably less.
    Any parent wants what's best for their child. Personally I believe that an optimum scenario if affordable by the parents is for at least one of them to be able to stay at home bringing up the child at least until he or she is of school age. The major difference with you is that I make no distinction whether that is the mother or the father.

    You need to think in less sexist terms.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kidlicious
    replied
    Originally posted by Ben Kenobi View Post
    So I hate men because I affirm the unique, and God-given dignity of women?
    No. You are lying about Protestants. No protestants believe women are inferior. NONE! This is how bigots talk. You are like the KKK lying about what black people believe and how they are trying to destroy the white culture. You're a bigot!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X