This is a pretty old argument here. Briefly,
1. IIRC, both Iraq and Afghanistan were awash in guns under their respective tyrants, long before we showed up.
2. Again IIRC, in both countries our main enemies were not handheld firearms but IEDs, heavy weapons and a slew of related nonmilitary factors--such as our mission being "force this country to self-govern in a way they don't particularly like."
3. I have a hard time envisioning a situation wherein a tyrannical U.S. government is legitimately threatened by handheld firearms. At best, they'd be a minor factor, especially if the government retains control of lines of communication.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Dark Knight Rises
Collapse
X
-
With a hat tip to Felch, I again suggest ending the war on drugs for its drain on the penal system.
Leave a comment:
-
Disregarding the entirety of the trollish nature of the prevelance or US arms and 2nd Amendment discussions, the one isssue touched on by Asher that warrants further consideration is the threshold of (in)sane behavior before institutionalization (as opposed to simply preventing purchase of arms).
It has been reported that the degree to which individuals represent a danger to society and the threshold for psychiatric insitutionalization has dramatically risen. If so why and what is a reasonable non knee jerk response?
Leave a comment:
-
Asher is a self-hating half-American.
You renounce that American citizenship yet, Asher?
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by Asher View PostIn any case, America is largely ungovernable now. At some people people need to realize the experiment failed -- America is no longer a leader in anything worth striving for. It's an example of squandered opportunity.
Leave a comment:
-
What a stupid argument. We had tanks and stealth bombers in Iraq, too, and we couldn't get out of there fast enough. Or are you going to tell me the Iraqi insurgents didn't need assault rifles?Originally posted by Asher View PostYou're going to blow up tanks and stealth bombers with your AR-15 and handguns? Really?

Leave a comment:
-
If America didn't want to be governed, it would be ungovernable. I agree.Originally posted by Asher View PostYou're dreaming.
In any case, America is largely ungovernable now. At some people people need to realize the experiment failed -- America is no longer a leader in anything worth striving for. It's an example of squandered opportunity.
This is generally true. To force government you have to follow North Korea's or Stalin's path...
JMM
Leave a comment:
-
Try reading about the conversations and political manouvering in IJ at the time, rather than making your own assumptions.Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View PostHiroshima was bombed and the Japanese did not surrender. Nagasaki gets bombed and you think that causes a surrender six days away? Or was it the invasion by the Soviet Union the day of the Nagasaki bombing and the annihilation of the Kwantung (over 600,000 Japanese soldiers captured) in battles over the next week that caused Japan's surrendering on August 15th?
If the nukes did it, Japan would have surrendered immediately. No. They surrendered only after they were wiped out by the Soviets in Manchuria.
Leave a comment:
-
Hiroshima was bombed and the Japanese did not surrender. Nagasaki gets bombed and you think that causes a surrender six days away? Or was it the invasion by the Soviet Union the day of the Nagasaki bombing and the annihilation of the Kwantung (over 600,000 Japanese soldiers captured) in battles over the next week that caused Japan's surrendering on August 15th?Originally posted by kentonio View PostUtterly untrue.
If the nukes did it, Japan would have surrendered immediately. No. They surrendered only after they were wiped out by the Soviets in Manchuria.
Leave a comment:
-
You're dreaming.Originally posted by regexcellent View PostAmerican gun ownership, especially in concert with state militias like the National Guard, has the potential to make the country fundamentally ungovernable no matter how many people the government decides to kill.
In any case, America is largely ungovernable now. At some people people need to realize the experiment failed -- America is no longer a leader in anything worth striving for. It's an example of squandered opportunity.
Leave a comment:
-
Not particularly true, there have been many examples of both outcomes.Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View PostMass slaughterings in history have only galvanized rebels and insurgents.
Utterly untrue.Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View PostAnd the Japanese did not surrender because of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. They surrendered because of the annihilation of the army in Manchuria by the Soviet entry into the war.
Leave a comment:
-
American gun ownership, especially in concert with state militias like the National Guard, has the potential to make the country fundamentally ungovernable no matter how many people the government decides to kill.
Leave a comment:
-
Mmhmm.
You're right, though. Dallas wouldn't be enough. We'd also need to hit Philly.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: