Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Lessons from the Bible
Collapse
X
-
That is a tautology. You seem to be saying that you believe it because it makes the most sense to you. I was asking you why it makes more sense to you. Is it not something you can qualitatively or quantitatively describe? Is it just more intuitive to you?
-
Fundamentally by experience.Originally posted by Hauldren Collider View PostWhat I'm most interested in, Jon, is how you justify Christianity as more valid than, say, Hinduism. Or Judaism. Or any religion, seriously just pick one.
Initially, when I was in highschool and reevaluating what I believed, because I recognized that I was sinful and the other religions don't provide a solution for that.
JM
(And the non-major religions were not believable, so I didn't consider them.)
Leave a comment:
-
JM, so you're saying God has the right to decide who dies and when? When he tells people they shouldn't kill, it's not because killing is wrong, but because they are infringing on god's right to decide when people die?
Leave a comment:
-
What I'm most interested in, Jon, is how you justify Christianity as more valid than, say, Hinduism. Or Judaism. Or any religion, seriously just pick one.
Leave a comment:
-
The Bible is the Word. The Bible tells you what to do, what to believe, etc.Originally posted by gribbler View PostYou have to worship the Bible to be a real Christian?
Leave a comment:
-
By the way, I don't have a problem with religion or religious people. It just baffles me. Thought I would throw that out there
Leave a comment:
-
You have to worship the Bible to be a real Christian?Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View PostYeah it gets nowhere. Jon Miller and Imran and others are frankly not real Christians. They twist and contort Scripture to fit their own sensibilities when the Word is supposed to be supreme. But we've been over and over this before.
Somehow them saying everything's about context and interpretation in response doesn't cause them to realize that it's all bunk then.
Either you take the Word as it is given (as the Bible freaking tells you to on NUMEROUS occasions) or you are not a Christian.
Leave a comment:
-
I've always found the whole murder-is-bad thing to be much simpler to explain. I don't like the idea of someone killing me, and I'm willing to eschew killing other people if I can be reasonably assured they will eschew killing me. Boy, I'm glad I don't have to sip wine and eat cardboard every sunday to figure that out.
Leave a comment:
-
Genocide was acceptable because it was necessary to survive. At least, that is my understanding.
Just like (possibly, I don't claim to be a great judge of morality) bombing Japan/German cities in WW2 was acceptable because it was necessary to win the war (in a timely fashion).
In war things become acceptable which are not acceptable in peacetime. Like killing another human being (for a just war).
God knew what could happen, therefore He knew what Israel should do.
Also, God can take life away. He can choose his instruments as He wishes.
So no, genocide was not acceptable because it would keep Israel faithful to God. Just liking killing is not acceptable because it would keep someone faithful to God. Genocide was acceptable because God judged the canaanites and knew the future, and knew what was best.
This is based on my understanding of the story. Not this doctrine, but that it applies to this story.
Was God wrong for destroying Sodom (in the story in Genesis)?
JM
Leave a comment:
-
No one's a real christian. Everyone thinks christianity is what they want it to be. I wish they'd go a step further and realize that they can and in fact are formulating their own beliefs based on what makes sense to them. If they did that maybe they'd dispense with their superstitious nonsense altogether.Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View PostYeah it gets nowhere. Jon Miller and Imran and others are frankly not real Christians. They twist and contort Scripture to fit their own sensibilities when the Word is supposed to be supreme. But we've been over and over this before.
Somehow them saying everything's about context and interpretation in response doesn't cause them to realize that it's all bunk then.
Either you take the Word as it is given (as the Bible freaking tells you to on NUMEROUS occasions) or you are not a Christian.
Leave a comment:
-
gribbler, his faith is predicated on the insistence that it is important to be faithful. You cannot convince people they are wrong when they believe their wrongness is what makes them right.
Leave a comment:
-
JM, are you saying the ends justify the means? Genocide was acceptable because it would have kept them faithful to God?
Leave a comment:
-
Yeah it gets nowhere. Jon Miller and Imran and others are frankly not real Christians. They twist and contort Scripture to fit their own sensibilities when the Word is supposed to be supreme. But we've been over and over this before.Originally posted by Hauldren Collider View Postyawn, another religion troll thread. gribbler, when will you learn that arguing about these things is not worth your time or energy? The entire stated point of religion these days is the ability to engage in doublethink ("faith"). By definition you cannot bring people over to your side.
Somehow them saying everything's about context and interpretation in response doesn't cause them to realize that it's all bunk then.
Either you take the Word as it is given (as the Bible freaking tells you to on NUMEROUS occasions) or you are not a Christian.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: