Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Lessons from the Bible

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • giblets
    replied
    Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View Post
    gribbler, what you should be pointing out is when God ordered people killed. Notice Jon Miller has said nothing about the Golden Calf incident or the Pharaoh's heart being hardened causing the plagues.

    I have yet to see a Christian who stands by what God ordered the Levites to do following the Golden Calf.
    Nope, I should be pointing out the collective punishment of all Egyptians for what the Pharoah did. I'm guessing the author of Exodus (or that part of Exodus, anyway) believed in guilt by association.

    Leave a comment:


  • giblets
    replied
    Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View Post
    That 'he' is with respect to the Kingdom of Judah personified as a he, not to God.

    Really, is this a reverse troll? You're doing it all wrong.
    Yes, God was with Judah and Judah was stopped with iron chariots. That would seem to suggest iron chariots are more powerful.

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    gribbler, what you should be pointing out is when God ordered people killed. Notice Jon Miller has said nothing about the Golden Calf incident or the Pharaoh's heart being hardened causing the plagues.

    I have yet to see a Christian who stands by what God ordered the Levites to do following the Golden Calf.

    Leave a comment:


  • giblets
    replied
    Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
    The real issue is how pro-woman that is compared to the customs of the time.

    At the time, women who were forced were generally considered worthless and were left without husband/etc. In a society where women depended on men and their children to care for them, that would be a atrocious.

    If the father was gifted, then that serves as a dowry for his daughter (in a way) and he can care for her if she is unable to marry.

    And it is completely obvious in the story that even the old testament author understood that this was not right or correct behavior. That this was every man doing what was right in their own sight, not in God's sight. Which is wrong, as one of the core messages of every story in the Bible.

    So quit looking for a fight and learn. Or if you want to keep looking for a fight, go ahead. But anyone who has sense will ignore you.

    JM
    I'm not looking for a fight. I'm discussing bizarre iron age belief systems.

    But I like your interpretation. Yahweh, the all-powerful god, really does think women are people, but he could only accomplish small, incremental changes in attitudes.

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    Originally posted by gribbler View Post
    [19] And the LORD was with Judah, and he took possession of the hill country, but he could not drive out the inhabitants of the plain, because they had chariots of iron.

    Judges 1:19

    Seems like Yahweh wasn't conceived as some sort of omnipotent master of the universe when this was written. I mean, iron chariots can stop him?
    That 'he' is with respect to the Kingdom of Judah personified as a he, not to God.

    Really, is this a reverse troll? You're doing it all wrong.

    Leave a comment:


  • giblets
    replied
    I'm guessing you think that treating it like mythology instead of trying to rationalize all of the barbaric cruelty is a no-no?

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Originally posted by gribbler View Post
    There isn't any indication that Yahweh objected to this practice. In fact I pointed out that the laws Yahweh gives to the Israelites allow men to take virgins by force, as long as the woman's father receives compensation. The story is a reflection of the author's complete lack of concern for what the woman thinks. I don't see much divine inspiration there! Does Yahweh think it's acceptable to treat women as property? The message in the story seems to be that not violating oaths is important.
    The real issue is how pro-woman that is compared to the customs of the time.

    At the time, women who were forced were generally considered worthless and were left without husband/etc. In a society where women depended on men and their children to care for them, that would be a atrocious.

    If the father was gifted, then that serves as a dowry for his daughter (in a way) and he can care for her if she is unable to marry.

    And it is completely obvious in the story that even the old testament author understood that this was not right or correct behavior. That this was every man doing what was right in their own sight, not in God's sight. Which is wrong, as one of the core messages of every story in the Bible.

    So quit looking for a fight and learn. Or if you want to keep looking for a fight, go ahead. But anyone who has sense will ignore you.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Have you read the old testament gribber?

    I don't mean looking for verses to complain about, I mean read it seeking to understand. Read the stories. See what the sentences were referring to.

    Remember, the Bible was written from the POV of humans.

    Over 99.999% of the Bible sentences are entirely worthless by themselves. Just like in any other story.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • giblets
    replied
    [19] And the LORD was with Judah, and he took possession of the hill country, but he could not drive out the inhabitants of the plain, because they had chariots of iron.

    Judges 1:19

    Seems like Yahweh wasn't conceived as some sort of omnipotent master of the universe when this was written. I mean, iron chariots can stop him?

    Leave a comment:


  • Felch
    replied
    Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View Post
    Or before that... God hardens the Pharaoh's heart. What is that about? Everytime the Pharaoh is about to give in to Moses to keep the Egyptian people from suffering further, God hardens his heart. Really, God?

    God really enjoys human suffering (and apparently, doesn't value free will).
    I was taught, as a Catholic, that the Old Testament is written with an incomplete understanding of God. The New Testament has a more lenient portrayal, because the people writing it have a better understanding of God's will. It's still not perfect, since human beings aren't perfect, but it's better than the old understanding.

    Leave a comment:


  • giblets
    replied
    Originally posted by MrFun View Post
    How does it feel to get PWNed, gribbler?
    There isn't any indication that Yahweh objected to this practice. In fact I pointed out that the laws Yahweh gives to the Israelites allow men to take virgins by force, as long as the woman's father receives compensation. The story is a reflection of the author's complete lack of concern for what the woman thinks. I don't see much divine inspiration there! Does Yahweh think it's acceptable to treat women as property? The message in the story seems to be that not violating oaths is important.

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    Or before that... God hardens the Pharaoh's heart. What is that about? Everytime the Pharaoh is about to give in to Moses to keep the Egyptian people from suffering further, God hardens his heart. Really, God?

    God really enjoys human suffering (and apparently, doesn't value free will).

    Leave a comment:


  • MrFun
    replied
    Originally posted by Imran Siddiqui View Post
    Your answer is in the final verse:



    Ponder it for a while and the answer may leap out at you.
    How does it feel to get PWNed, gribbler?

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    So no Golden Calf issues?

    I mean God hasn't even given the 10 Commandments to Moses yet so the Hebrews are not even familiar yet with the prohibition against false idols and what not... yet God specifically orders those who are true to kill every man, woman, and child... and those righteous few are then cursed to wander the desert for 40 years because of it.

    Huh, God?

    I have yet to meet a Christian who 1) was familiar with God's orders and 2) agreed with them. Yet why this revelation doesn't demolish their faith, I have no idea.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Because they didn't follow God.

    Reread judges, if it has been a while.

    JM

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X