Originally posted by Oncle Boris
View Post

Sorry, sweetheart, but you can't simply apply the word "restriction" in both cases and claim that there is some kind of equivalence between charging people for a service that they choose to consume and taxation. Somebody subjected to taxation can't simply choose to consume less of the services government provides and thereby reduce their tax bill. People CAN choose to consume more or less education. If they do not bear the cost of their education then they will consume too much education. A subsidy to education causes a distortion at the frontier between choosing to continue school and not (the producers and consumers of education see different prices). Similarly, income taxes cause a distortion at the frontier between work and leisure (workers and their employers see different prices).
When producers see higher prices than consumers, then TOO MUCH of the good will be supplied and consumed (subsidy to education causes too much education). When producers see lower prices than consumers then TOO LITTLE of the good will be supplied and consumed (taxes on income cause too little work).
Leave a comment: