Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How does a 60+ hour work week look like?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Oncle Boris View Post
    BTW, that's the general logic of fiscal conservatives: a restriction that mostly applies to the working class is an 'incentive' (borrow to get your degree, you'll make it productive); but one that applies to wealthy people and entrepreneurs is a loss of freedom (tax 'em, and they'll leave somewhere where they can do business).

    Such a logic can only exist if the legal context has been fixed for it to make sense.


    Sorry, sweetheart, but you can't simply apply the word "restriction" in both cases and claim that there is some kind of equivalence between charging people for a service that they choose to consume and taxation. Somebody subjected to taxation can't simply choose to consume less of the services government provides and thereby reduce their tax bill. People CAN choose to consume more or less education. If they do not bear the cost of their education then they will consume too much education. A subsidy to education causes a distortion at the frontier between choosing to continue school and not (the producers and consumers of education see different prices). Similarly, income taxes cause a distortion at the frontier between work and leisure (workers and their employers see different prices).

    When producers see higher prices than consumers, then TOO MUCH of the good will be supplied and consumed (subsidy to education causes too much education). When producers see lower prices than consumers then TOO LITTLE of the good will be supplied and consumed (taxes on income cause too little work).

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Oncle Boris View Post
    Consequences of (3):
    -capital requires mobility, which it does get by law.
    -restrictions on working hours can be an incentive for innovation and productivity
    I have no idea where you get the first statement from.

    The second statement is as true as it is meaningless. If I place a restriction on the amount of steel that automakers are allowed to use to build cars, it will sure spur innovation in cars that use less steel. However, we will have purchased TOO MUCH innovation and investment in making cars with less steel. That's the whole idea behind the ****ing price system.

    Holy ****, this is like explaining things to third graders.

    EDIT: technically, the second statement is not a consequence of (3) either. The relatively high elasticity of labor demand can EITHER mean that employers are able to find substitutes for labor OR that employersrestrict output in the face of rising labor costs (or some combination thereof)...
    Last edited by KrazyHorse; October 13, 2010, 21:24.

    Leave a comment:


  • Krill
    replied
    Tomorrow is my eigth 12 hour day in 10 days, and 10th in 13.

    I'm starting to think you work them because it is less painful to be a zombie than feel the emotional pain of knowing you have nothing important to do with your life in your days off.

    Leave a comment:


  • Darius871
    replied
    Originally posted by Oncle Boris View Post
    BTW, that's the general logic of fiscal conservatives: a restriction that mostly applies to the working class is an 'incentive' (borrow to get your degree, you'll make it productive); but one that applies to wealthy people and entrepreneurs is a loss of freedom (tax 'em, and they'll leave somewhere where they can do business).

    How is it that the mere absence of an entitlement (getting your degree for free) anywhere near as much a "restriction" as affirmatively taking away money one already has? There has to be a better analogy than that...

    Leave a comment:


  • Fake Boris
    replied
    BTW, that's the general logic of fiscal conservatives: a restriction that mostly applies to the working class is an 'incentive' (borrow to get your degree, you'll make it productive); but one that applies to wealthy people and entrepreneurs is a loss of freedom (tax 'em, and they'll leave somewhere where they can do business).

    Such a logic can only exist if the legal context has been fixed for it to make sense.

    Leave a comment:


  • jaxl75
    replied
    I worked some pretty long shifts for weeks at time. Its hard man, real hard cause it just wears on you. And then later you hear on TV that there are people out there that work 2-3 jobs and raise a family and I just don't get how they do it.

    Leave a comment:


  • Fake Boris
    replied
    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    The theoretical, moral and empirical statements necessary to demonstrate that placing hurdles in front of those wishing to negotiate a longer workweek with their employer is a bad idea are quite simple and robust:

    1) Moral axiom: I have no preference to transfer wealth between individuals who are identical except in their personal labor supply curves
    2) Theoretical statement: the only way to alter the negotiating position of individual workers is to change the supply or demand curves for substitutes to their labor
    3) Empirical statement: the elasticity of labor demand is much higher than the elasticity of labor supply
    Consequences of (3):
    -capital requires mobility, which it does get by law.
    -restrictions on working hours can be an incentive for innovation and productivity

    Leave a comment:


  • Bugs ****ing Bunny
    replied
    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    As I said, the empirical evidence I'm aware of (elasticities of labor supply and demand) actually seem to imply that the only way this policy can benefit those who have more of a disdain for long hours is at the expense of those who have less of one.

    It's all about striking a balance.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hauldren Collider
    replied
    Originally posted by MikeH View Post
    In fact, even within national boundaries we're a less mobile labour market than the states. For reasons people don't really understand. Possibly because so many places have such strong regional identities.
    There are plenty of places in the US with extremely strong regional identities. I don't think tourists see it as much because the really big cities/tourist cities have a lot of transplants.

    Leave a comment:


  • DanS
    replied
    I think the reasons are well known and readily understood.

    Leave a comment:


  • MikeH
    replied
    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    Who the **** has claimed that the EU is one big, happy labor market? The fact that labor mobility is far lower across national boundaries in the EU than across state boundaries in the US is a well-understood and oft-cited phenomenon.

    The red herrings are really piling up here...
    In fact, even within national boundaries we're a less mobile labour market than the states. For reasons people don't really understand. Possibly because so many places have such strong regional identities.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dinner
    replied
    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    Who the **** has claimed that the EU is one big, happy labor market? The fact that labor mobility is far lower across national boundaries in the EU than across state boundaries in the US is a well-understood and oft-cited phenomenon.

    The red herrings are really piling up here...
    You did at least indirectly. You said if workers don't like it they can get a different job to which I said some places don't have a competitive job market so their option is to take what is offered or move. Thus showing that the ability to move is limited by a number of real life factors seems key to disproving the idealistic utopian nonsense you've been shoveling. Real life doesn't work as you described in the majority of the cases and that's why we actually need labor laws.

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    I don't believe anyone has claimed this here.


    I claim it, actually. I also claim that this in itself is an inappropriate argument to demonstrate almost anything at all about the desirability or even effect of a given policy.

    The point is, if you (the general "you", not you) believe that there is some kind of REASON to think that the effects of the policy in question will be different than those I claimed, then you should provide precisely what effect you believe is at play (no, the idea that there is an "asymmetry" or that there is "exploitation" doesn't cut it, without a more specific model of these things) and you should provide some sort of empirical justification to demonstrate the existence and importance of this effect.

    As I said, the empirical evidence I'm aware of (elasticities of labor supply and demand) actually seem to imply that the only way this policy can benefit those who have more of a disdain for long hours is at the expense of those who have less of one.

    Leave a comment:


  • Cort Haus
    replied
    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    The model "classical economics is wrong" is particularly useless.
    I don't believe anyone has claimed this here. However, like all models, classical economics is the map, not the territory. I'm fairly sure that Smith himself recognised that market distortions existed, and made the model slightly less than perfectly beautiful in reality. I think he also had some reservations about the social consequences of those distortions that he witnessed - ie, substantially favouring the owners of capital over the owners of labour. Others would later develop this idea.

    3) Empirical statement: the elasticity of labor demand is much higher than the elasticity of labor supply

    Well, exactly. I nearly posted this earlier, but couldn't quite be bothered. If we can all agree on this, the discussion is probably over.

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Guynemer View Post
    Indeed. They are now LIMITED to 80-hours a week max, with a maximum of 30 hours continuous. It is unclear how many residency programs fudge those numbers, but mine tried to play it pretty straight.

    Also, just for the record, while residents work 80 hrs/wk for anywhere from 3-9 years, depending on the residency, they are also getting paid barely above minimum wage.


    Jesus ****, I'm glad that's over.
    Min. wage is a bit of an exaggeration, to my understanding

    call it 4000 hrs a year, and the 1st year residents I know are making 14-15$ an hour

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X