Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How does a 60+ hour work week look like?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    What does this mean then?

    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    The fact that you think there is a substantive difference between allowing employees to "accept" working longer hours and allowing employers to "require" working longer hours is indicative of the level of understanding of most people in this thread.
    Same relationship but in the positive sense of allowing... Why would they be no difference in this sense, but a difference in my negative sense?

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Al B. Sure! View Post
    KH:

    What the hell are you talking about? Oerdin's right. There is a difference between outlawing people from working 40+ hours and simply making it such that employers can't force it if the employee doesn't want to do it.

    Good thing I didn't equate those two things then, you ****ing twit.

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Dauphin View Post
    Except that wasn't the point of his comment.
    Yes, it was.

    Also, I'm not saying everyone should work more than 40 hours, all I'm saying is that people SHOULD be able to if they want to. I don't think that it's "unfair competition" for somebody to be willing to work longer hours.


    So some sort of waiver system is in order, perchance?


    The second statement is a non-sequitur, unless you believe that all activities which should be allowed should also require the parties to sign waivers to engage in them.

    This is why the computer analogy was apt.

    The argument then turned to some sort of discussion about this law as a protection of worker safety, rather than simply a protection of worker choice. I hold no truck with that argument either, but the argument there is slightly more involved, as you are beginning to place conditions around the type of agreements which require a government waiver (those which you believe adversely impact worker safety).

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    KH:

    What the hell are you talking about? Oerdin's right. There is a difference between outlawing people from working 40+ hours and simply making it such that employers can't force it if the employee doesn't want to do it. Employment in America is usually on an at-will basis anyway but in countries or states where that is not so, that distinction would have relevance.

    There are people who don't want to work 40+ hours and employers who would force them to do so. That happens all the time. I suppose those people would love it if there was some law that restricted being forced into working extra hours (not saying that there should be. Just that it would apply to them).

    Overtime for hourly workers exists for roughly that reason. It discourages employers from demanding employees to work heavy hours by forcing additional compensation which may make hiring additional workers more attractive and it encourages workers who may not have been willing to work 40+ hours to do so.

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Oerdin View Post
    I have yet to find a single person in this thread say someone should not be allowed to work longer hours. I have seen several people say it is unreasonable for an employer to try to make people work longer hours and that they thus like having some form of legal protection no matter how limited. You're building a strawman here.
    The fact that you think there is a substantive difference between allowing employees to "accept" working longer hours and allowing employers to "require" working longer hours is indicative of the level of understanding of most people in this thread.

    To the extent that there is any friction at all caused by such a nonsensical distinction, it is a transaction cost placed between employers who would like employees to work longer hours and employees who would like to work longer hours, borne almost entirely by workers who would like to work longer hours (the elasticity of labor supply is far lower than the elasticity of labor demand).

    This type of requirement (whether it be a waiver in the UK or exempt employee status in the US) is nothing more than a ridiculous intrusion of economic illiterates into private transactions.

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    Originally posted by Bugs ****ing Bunny View Post
    Let me put my hand on my heart and say that I will fight to the death for the right for Americans to kneel naked before their employers, reach back, pull apart their quivering buttocks and say "I am ready to accept you at your whim, Sir" whilst nervously chattering about the inherent nobility of the act.
    Funny, my employer has no interest in getting anything from me but my labor, which I provide for a price. If I don't like the conditions of my employment or the price I am paid, I will go elsewhere. At no point in this does my dignity feel hurt in accepting a negotiated agreement between myself and another party. Do you think my employer feels put out when it is faced with the choice of paying me or losing me?

    However, I got a very nice job without going in for that, and I'm perfectly happy to let the employment laws help ensure my kids don't end up calling me "Uncle." I'll work long hours if I choose, but that's my call.


    Employment laws don't prevent that; your own choices do. The vast majority of Americans choose to work ~40 hours a week, as do the vast majority of Britons, and employment laws have little if anything to do with it.

    The idea that without the government looking out for you by making you sign a waiver you would end up toiling in the salt mines for untold weeks on end lets me know precisely how much faith in yourself you have to make good decisions...

    Leave a comment:


  • Dinner
    replied
    Eat your heart out, *****. :smoke:

    Leave a comment:


  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by Oerdin View Post
    I have yet to find a single person in this thread say someone should not be allowed to work longer hours. I have seen several people say it is unreasonable for an employer to try to make people work longer hours and that they thus like having some form of legal protection no matter how limited. You're building a strawman here.
    My god, I agree with what Oerdin says. Purely coincidence I bet.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dauphin
    replied
    Originally posted by KrazyHorse View Post
    Er...what?

    The analogy was made to demonstrate the flawed reasoning behind "this is a choice which is up to the individual in making a career decision" -> "employers should have to obtain a waiver from their employees"
    Except that wasn't the point of his comment.

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    Originally posted by Jon Miller View Post
    Actually, from what I have heard most people who get stuck with long work hours have them due to volunteering to do them when they started with the company (to impress/etc). Then later, despite them not being expected for everyone else, they are expected for the poor person who had initially volunteered them (whether he wants to continue to do them or not).

    You don't want to give your employer the expectation that you work extra hours, rather that when you do work extra hours it is a really big deal and something that should get you a lot of reward/etc.

    This is probably not true in physics (and Wall Street).

    I could be wrong, I am not that experienced.

    JM



    Yeah. It's a bad idea to be the model employee willing to sacrifice everything for your employer. That puts you on the fast-track to a dead-end.

    I am crazy competitive though so I probably would do it anyway.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dinner
    replied
    Originally posted by Hauldren Collider View Post
    I agree that it is a personal decision, and I don't think less of people for not wanting to work long hours, but I do find it ridiculous to say that nobody should be allowed to work long hours because you don't want to have to compete with the people who are willing.

    xpost
    I have yet to find a single person in this thread say someone should not be allowed to work longer hours. I have seen several people say it is unreasonable for an employer to try to make people work longer hours and that they thus like having some form of legal protection no matter how limited. You're building a strawman here.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jon Miller
    replied
    Actually, from what I have heard most people who get stuck with long work hours have them due to volunteering to do them when they started with the company (to impress/etc). Then later, despite them not being expected for everyone else, they are expected for the poor person who had initially volunteered them (whether he wants to continue to do them or not).

    You don't want to give your employer the expectation that you work extra hours, rather that when you do work extra hours it is a really big deal and something that should get you a lot of reward/etc.

    This is probably not true in physics (and Wall Street).

    I could be wrong, I am not that experienced.

    JM

    Leave a comment:


  • Hauldren Collider
    replied
    Well obviously if they break your contract or refuse to pay you should be able to sue. That's essentially theft and I most definitely agree that theft is illegal....

    And yes, I admit to not having workplace experience, this is obvious given that I'm still in high school, regardless, I think I can wrap my head around the economics of wage controls and similar things.

    xpost, again

    Leave a comment:


  • KrazyHorse
    replied
    JM:

    And I'm quite supportive of your ability to make that choice, allowing you to have your pick of one of the millions of jobs where you wouldn't be expected to do so.

    By the way, the number of hours worked by those not in the top few percent of the income distribution has been declining for a number of decades in the US....

    Leave a comment:


  • Al B. Sure!
    replied
    Originally posted by Hauldren Collider View Post
    Why'd you take the job if you didn't want to work that long?
    Hours change, HC. You agreed to employment, worked there for years, then all of a sudden, they need you to do something else. You can't just quit and be unemployed for months while you search for a new job. That's absurd. Now that isn't really relevant to this issue (because being ordered to work more hours usually isn't that big of a deal) but you seem to have no conception of what it is like to work. Nor of the fact that people can hate their jobs but be forced to stay for various reasons, namely that they can't afford to not work.

    One problem is HC has no experience being a mere cog in a corporate machine, being promised things like 2 weeks paid vacation and not being allowed to take it (nor even cash it out!) because you're 'too instrumental' to the operation... having hourly workers have WORKED OVERTIME deducted from their hours because they were over budget, etc. There is so much corruption in corporate America it's absurd.

    I am all for being able to work crazy hours though as long as you get paid for it! But I also understand that employers dick you around and can change what they need from you at a moment's notice.

    Also, as I was trying to show, it's not always in the employer's best interest to burn out their employees. It doesn't make business sense to do so.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X