An open rebuttal to Sheryl Crow.

[Raijer]

I surrender

[Berzerker]

"If it makes you happy it can't be that bad," eh? Well, Ms Crow, surgical experimention on humans made Nazi scientist Josef Mengele very happy, and that WAS actually "that bad."

I don't think you thought that lyric through all the way to it's logical conclusion, please try harder next time. Thank you.

Gee, was her message just for Mengele or did she include his victims? Were they happy to be experimented on? Try to understand that the definition of freedom excludes behavior like murder

the absence of coercion or constraint on choice or action

does not include murder

she understands that, you didn't think that thru...

[Legend]

I surrender

Continuiing the french theme?

[Mojotronica]

Gee, was her message just for Mengele or did she include his victims? Were they happy to be experimented on? Try to understand that the definition of freedom excludes behavior like murder

the absence of coercion or constraint on choice or action

does not include murder

she understands that, you didn't think that thru...

That may be implied, but is not explicitly addressed in the lyrics, which opens Crow up to criticism.

[Raijer]

Continuiing the french theme?

Oui

[SlowwHand]

"If it makes you happy it can't be that bad," eh? Well, Ms Crow, surgical experimention on humans made Nazi scientist Josef Mengele very happy, and that WAS actually "that bad."

I don't think you thought that lyric through all the way to it's logical conclusion, please try harder next time. Thank you.

Get a grip.

[bumfister]

Frappez le fromage avec le poisson.

[duke o' york]

Et le cul?

[Berzerker]

That may be implied, but is not explicitly addressed in the lyrics, which opens Crow up to criticism.

It aint implied, its a given (assumed by the listener who dont have some political axe to grind)! Did her lyrics expressly address Mengele or was that implied too? Was she really telling psychopathic fans of Joe Mengele to run out and torture people if it makes then happy in spite of their victims' unhappiness? Where in her lyrics did she expressly say happiness may be pursued only by murderers and to hell with everyone else?

what a hatchet job, sounds like you watch too much Hannity or Beck. I'd expect this from them...

[Raijer]

Get a grip.

Like the one your anus has around your neck?

[Mojotronica]

what a hatchet job, sounds like you watch too much Hannity or Beck. I'd expect this from them...

[Raijer]

It aint implied, its a given (assumed by the listener who dont have some political axe to grind)! Did her lyrics expressly address Mengele or was that implied too? Was she really telling psychopathic fans of Joe Mengele to run out and torture people if it makes then happy in spite of their victims' unhappiness? Where in her lyrics did she expressly say happiness may be pursued only by murderers and to hell with everyone else?

what a hatchet job, sounds like you watch too much Hannity or Beck. I'd expect this from them...

...

[duke o' york]

Sorry for the repost (by someone else), but this guy is spoiling for a FIGHT, FIGHT!

(and I'm on Sloww's side)

[SlowwHand]

These are babies. I have neither the time, nor the inclination to deal with babies.

[Raijer]

These are babies. I have neither the time, nor the inclination to deal with babies.

Get a grip