Originally posted by Alinestra Covelia
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
I'm sorry you have trouble pronouncing my name.
Collapse
X
-
Graffiti in a public toilet
Do not require skill or wit
Among the **** we all are poets
Among the poets we are ****.
-
Originally posted by onodera View PostThank you. However, I fear we need a new exploding brain smilie. I can grok the consonants, but East Asian tonal systems go completely over my head. How do Chinese who have no sense of pitch learn to speak Chinese?
Koreans and Japanese don't require tones for their language. Now, in some dialects (which are mutually intelligible, different like how Manchester English can be understood by a speaker of Midwestern American English) of Korean and Japanese, tones are how stress is marked within a word, but those tonal accents are not actually required.
Also, there's been a recent discovery correlating ethnic groups that developed actual tonal languages with having a specific mutation on a gene that isn't present in ethnic groups without tonal languages. It's an open question whether that mutation has changed anything, but it's an interesting note.Last edited by Q Classic; April 11, 2009, 16:33.B♭3
Comment
-
Originally posted by Q Classic View PostActually, the tonal thing is exclusively within the Chinese languages (yes, with an s. They are not mutually intelligible between then, hence the government's insistence on the Mandarin standard), and isn't an "East Asian" thing. You do see it for some Southeast Asian languages. I think it appears in some Sub-Saharan languages as well.Graffiti in a public toilet
Do not require skill or wit
Among the **** we all are poets
Among the poets we are ****.
Comment
-
Comment
-
Originally posted by onodera View PostI think Vietnamese and Thai are definitely tonal. They always have many diacritics in their transliterations.
Their Latin-based alphabet is the only one that actually has tonal markings built in, represented by those diacritics you mentioned.B♭3
Comment
Comment