w00w00, childishly trolling with the
msg icon again!
I was not criticizing the movie. I was and am criticizing the review. This is the third time I am saying this in this thread.
Your long retort is entirely built on countering non-existant claims made against the movie. Hence, you're not really replying... but still, you ask "so what?", directly from me. What are you doing? Are you trolling?
msg icon again!
Originally posted by BeBro
And so what? The historical record is one thing - to idealize these practices today is another, and this is not only the opinion from those who published the review, as earlier posts here indicate. From other things we know about the movie I somehow doubt that they included some parts because they cared oh so much about historical correctness, while they had no problems to completely make up other parts.
And a movie which seriously has something like "Spartans defended democracy" (a similar comment on the official website of the movie) makes itself an easy target, btw.
And so what? The historical record is one thing - to idealize these practices today is another, and this is not only the opinion from those who published the review, as earlier posts here indicate. From other things we know about the movie I somehow doubt that they included some parts because they cared oh so much about historical correctness, while they had no problems to completely make up other parts.
And a movie which seriously has something like "Spartans defended democracy" (a similar comment on the official website of the movie) makes itself an easy target, btw.
Your long retort is entirely built on countering non-existant claims made against the movie. Hence, you're not really replying... but still, you ask "so what?", directly from me. What are you doing? Are you trolling?
Comment