Kevin Smith vs. Joel Siegel

[VetLegion]

Mallrats is the best one
Clerks is a bit raw, but also good.

Dogma is too pretentious, and Chasing Amy is not too bad except the main female character has a face like she is crying and grinning at the same time and that was somewhat annoying.

[Q Classic]

Mallrats was the worst one.

We're not mentioning that abortive Bennifer one. That's not a movie, that's an embarassment.

[ajbera]

Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back was worse than Mallrats, but Mallrats was the second worst of his movies. Both had funny moments, but were well below Clerks, Amy & Dogma in quality.

[Lorizael]

Jay and Silent Bob Strikes Back and Jersey Girl are obviously his two best films. Anyone who disagrees is a moron.

[Richelieu]

Dogma
Salma

[ajbera]

Salma dancing in her underwear

[chequita guevara]

Ain't seen Mallrats or Jay and Silent Bob.

[Lonestar]

Chasing Amy Sucked, it was even worse than Jersey Girl

[DanS]

I was beginning to think I was losing my touch.

Well... He has been off his game lately...

[DanS]

Originally posted by Japher
better quotes

37???!!!!

Best quote ever.

[snoopy369]

Dogma

Any movie with Alanis Morrisette as God gets my vote

[-Jrabbit]

I still can't figure out whatever everyone saw in Clerks. Maybe it was just so hyped that I was doomed to be disappointed. Saw Mallrats next and figured it was proof this guy was way overrated.

Then I saw Dogma.

Haven't seen the others. I will probably see this one when it gets to cable.

Regarding the article, it struck me a lot like his movies:
Point made, dude, but how many times must you repeat it?

[chequita guevara]

It's on our office calender.

[MRT144]

meh, kevin smith makes vaguely amusing movies, nothing thats ever left me thinking, "comic genius"

on the other hadn the fans are what really makes me wonder. its like if you dont like kevin smith movies or think they are the height of comedy youre a nazi or worse.

[Sikander]

Re: Re: Kevin Smith vs. Joel Siegel

Originally posted by Guynemer



Dude. That's his best movie.

Yes, Chasing Amy is the best one. I'm not a huge fan or anything, but I've seen most of his stuff.