The Beatles Vs. Phil Collins

[Ninot]

Friend and I are having a silly infantile debate, so I wanna see what Apolyton has to say.

For whatever reason you deem valid, who was better (in their prime), The Beatles, or Phil Collins(with or without Genesis)?

[Wezil]

You can't be serious?

[Ninot]

Sure I can, it's just hard sometimes.

[Richelieu]

Second time this week you've had me go

[ajbera]

What's your opinion, Ninot?

[Ninot]

Originally posted by Richelieu
Second time this week you've had me go

Maybe I'll go for a third.

[Ninot]

Originally posted by ajbera
What's your opinion, Ninot?

I think Phil Collins is a terrific musician.

But I think its a joke to put him in the same league as the Fab 4. Their music was revolutionary and it just doesn't get old.

But don't let that affect your voting

[Wezil]

In the interests of fairness for your poll we now need someone to post a glowing recommendation for Phil Collins.

Someone?

Anyone?

[Ninot]

He's a terrific drummer!

[Richelieu]

Originally posted by Ninot
He's a terrific drummer!

[Winston]

I think this is a thinly disguised attempt at finding something everyone can agree on, re. the debate we had a few days ago, started by Carolus Rex, on whether total agreement among Poly folk was achieveable.

I like Phil Collins' music and lyrics a lot, and I've a great amount of respect for his ability to stay on top for so long, but this is waay out there in left field, so to speak.

[Ninot]

Hahahaha, yes, i'm trying to unite Apolyton, and next i'll invite everyone to go see a Beatles Tribute band.

Honest to God tho, my friend curses out anyone who claims the Beatles are better in anyway, and he has found people who agree with him. The poll question is actually one of the first things he'll ask any stranger.

[Richelieu]

Originally posted by Ninot
Hahahaha, yes, i'm trying to unite Apolyton, and next i'll invite everyone to go see a Beatles Tribute band.

Honest to God tho, my friend curses out anyone who claims the Beatles are better in anyway, and he has found people who agree with him. The poll question is actually one of the first things he'll ask any stranger.

I wonder why he's not the one posting on Poly.

[Kontiki]

I could probably say that I liked Phil Collins better, but I'd never say he was even remotely as popular, big, important or lasting as the Beatles.

[Ninot]

Originally posted by Richelieu


I wonder why he's not the one posting on Poly.

he's on an extended vacation in the woods somewhere.

I was thinkin on him and thought to do this, something to show him when he gets back.