Judge rejects right-to-die delay

[Mrs. Tuberski]

I refuse to believe the man doesnt have a motive but thats neither here nor there Im not here to judge him nor have I simply stated that While I agree to let her die i dont agree to it by starvation.

[GePap]

Agreed. Let him euthenise her.

Except that route is closed here in the US.

So she should be left to vegitate until euthenisia is legal?

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by Sava
actually, your argument might be more absurd than the gay marriage leads to beastiality argument... I find it offensive.

What's offensive?

My oldest sister was retarded, she was as, MRT said:

shes a waste of space and anyone that can find something redeeming about her living is nuts.

So, by his reasoning my sister should have been killed.

I find that idea offensive.

ACK!

[Sava]

I don't see any mention of retarded people.

[Boris Godunov]

Originally posted by Tuberski
My wife's statements weren't malicious. So you are wrong legally and in your context.

Implying sans evidence that someone is seeking for their wife of many years to die out of nefarious reasons might just be seen as malicious.

Regardless, perhaps instead of relying on a website, you could look the word up--especially its everyday, non-legal usage--in an actual dictionary. They tend to be more ellaborative. And in mine, it notes that slander is something false that damages another's reputation. No malice necessary (though I suppose it would be rather implied).

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by GePap
Agreed. Let him euthenise her.

Except that route is closed here in the US.

So she should be left to vegitate until euthenisia is legal?

She's been there 15 years, plenty of time for the husband or any other interested party to get the law changed.

ACK!

[GePap]

Originally posted by Tuberski


She's been there 15 years, plenty of time for the husband or any other interested party to get the law changed.

ACK!

Wha...

Last time I checked, passing new laws, unless you are part of a well financed interest lobby, is a very, VERY hard thing for one individual to do. How the hell was one man going to change the state laws on euthinesia?

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by Sava
I don't see any mention of retarded people.

Um, Vegetative is severely retarded.

Retarded mental function.

ACK!

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by GePap


Wha...

Last time I checked, passing new laws, unless you are part of a well financed interest lobby, is a very, VERY hard thing for one individual to do. How the hell was one man going to change the state laws on euthinesia?

Doesn't mean they should try does it?

Have they?

ACK!

[Mrs. Tuberski]

Ok I didnt understand a word he just said. I seem to believe that there is more to it then him just not walking away.I didnt say he was a gold digger or anything. But if the parents want her alive why cant he just so ok and walk away

[MRT144]

Originally posted by Tuberski


Let's kill all the retarded people out there too, then we can do it to lazy people , fat people.

The list goes on.

HEIL!

ACK!

if only killing one person whose been braindead for YEARS was a slippery slope. what are you? some kind of idiot?

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by MRT144


if only killing one person whose been braindead for YEARS was a slippery slope. what are you? some kind of idiot?

Your reason for killing her is idiotic.

What does that make you?

ACK!

[GePap]

Originally posted by Mrs. Tuberski
Ok I didnt understand a word he just said. I seem to believe that there is more to it then him just not walking away.I didnt say he was a gold digger or anything. But if the parents want her alive why cant he just so ok and walk away

Maybe he thinks the parents are making the wrong choice for her based on thier wish not to see their child die before them because he thinks she would be better off death than in her current state?

That is the other possible choice, besides the one of him having alterior and selfish motives that are central to his desire.

[MRT144]

my reason? cause shes a vegetable thats outlived the usefullness of medical procedure, and has people who are so concerned with a sham life want to keep her life. Im not an idiot, im spiteful.

[Tuberski]

Originally posted by MRT144
dude, let her die. shes a waste of space and anyone that can find something redeeming about her living is nuts.

I don't see anything about usefullness of medical procedure in that post.

All I see is an attempt at asshattery.

ACK!