Sdc 5

[Case]

Leo, where's the traditional 'poly banana option?

(and don't say that it's CowboyNeal. You cannot substitute anything for the banana option. )

Oh, and I voted 2 humans, tactical historical battles and WW2. I suspect that somewhere in there I've backed the winner

[mordhiem]

As I've said before, 2 humans, tactical battle or alt. hist will suit me fine. From a design standpoint, I think that a simple human vs human tactical battle would be easiest to create, but that of course isn't the deciding factor.

[St Leo]

Since it's in the lead I say we just go with Alternate History...

I am sure WarVoid and/or Techumseh will seriously consider that option prior to making their final decision.

(and don't say that it's CowboyNeal. You cannot substitute anything for the banana option. )

If you don't like CowboyNeal, I'm willing to go with Mu as the wildcard option in the next poll.

Oh, and I voted 2 humans, tactical historical battles and WW2. I suspect that somewhere in there I've backed the winner

Tsk, tsk, tsk. You were supposed to vote for the candidates you like best and not the ones who are likely to win. I guess it's true what they say; people get the scenario design contest they deserve.

[mordhiem]

Tactical Battles of Alternate History Between 2 Human Players anyone?

[atomant]

french i think refers to a slightly tounge in cheek post i did on the discussion board relating the the sdc 5.....

[Panda]

dang, how did alt.hist get ahead

[DarthVeda]

So when we starting this?

[techumseh]

Scenario League Magazine will host SDC#5. Details will be included in the next issue, probably in about two weeks. We're still discussing things with St. Leo, but it's looking like an alternate history theme of some kind. There's not much support for the code names, so that will probably be changed. Otherwise, we have volunteers for judges and so on.

[St Leo]

dang, how did alt.hist get ahead

The trick was in making the WW2 option as well hidden as possible. It's almost as brilliant as using butterfly ballots.

[DarthVeda]

*demands recount*

[kobayashi]

i think the poll is flawed as many of the choices are overlapping and should have been options

examples

like two player doesn't conflict with famous tactical battles

unconventional design doesn't conflict with alternate history

pre-industrial asia doesn't conflict with map supplied

[St Leo]

i think the poll is flawed as many of the choices are overlapping and should have been options

Uh, they were options.

[kobayashi]

Originally posted by St Leo
i think the poll is flawed as many of the choices are overlapping and should have been options

Uh, they were options.

opps, I thought the only options were -


Option: Allow Existing Unreleased Scenarios 8 17.78%
Option: Keep Codename System 7 15.56%
Option: Don't Bother Us With Token Polls Again

too bad I can't vote again.

[DarthVeda]

Hey can we get some response out of this? Has a decision been made yet?

[St Leo]

The decision might be announced with the next SLM, whenever that is released.